logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2024
28m 56s

He Lured Men on Craigslist to his Forest...

We Are Verified
About this episode

In the Summer of 2011, in a small town in Southern Ohio, a weird craigslist ad was posted. The ad was posted by a man named Jack who was looking for an older man, single, and willing to move onto his property for a few months to keep up with the maintenance of his land and animals. The ad even stated %E2%80%9CIt%E2%80%99ll feel like a vacation if you enjoy nature and country life.%E2%80%9D while also including you would get paid weekly for your services. This ad sounded like a dream come true, getting to enjoy the slow country life and tending to the farm while getting paid to do it. This ad would receive hundreds of replies from applicants interested in the position. But what these applicants didn't know was that the person on the other side of the screen, was a serial killer.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Jun 30
How did This Group of "Millionaires" Frame Karen Read of Murder?: Case of John O' Keefe
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices 
1h 25m
Jun 18
Woman Steals Baby out of Mothers Stomach: Case of Reagan- Simmons Hancock
Taylor Morton was described as a con-artist and a pathological liar to a lot of people who knew her. Taylor would tell a lot of fake stories about herself to many people including being a billionaire family heiress, a nurse, a surgeon, an OBGYN, and has million dollar contracts w ... Show More
1h 12m
Jun 18
Woman Steals Baby out of Mothers Stomach: Case of Reagan- Simmons Hancock
Taylor Morton was described as a con-artist and a pathological liar to a lot of people who knew her. Taylor would tell a lot of fake stories about herself to many people including being a billionaire family heiress, a nurse, a surgeon, an OBGYN, and has million dollar contracts w ... Show More
1h 15m
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2021
EP. 13 MINNESOTA: A Mother's Murder: The Needless Killing of Carol Thompson
This murder was the inspiration for the movie "FARGO". Our story takes place in St. Paul, Minnesota, in a neighborhood called Highland Park. It’s March of 1963, and the homes within this neighborhood are filled with members of the upper-middle class. It was a neighborhood that a ... Show More
27m 47s
May 2
Robert Ben Rhoades, Truck Stop Killer
Robert Rhoades is the perfect named for a man who drove trucks around America, little did anyone know, however, he had a secret dungeon in the back... Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapterpodcast Business enquires : tha ... Show More
46m 12s
Feb 2025
True Crime Vault: Golden State Killer
A series of rapes in Northern California. The rapist moves down the coast, his crimes escalating to murder.Originally aired: 05/04/18 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
47m 22s
Sep 2022
Jean-Claude Romand Pt. 1
For years, everyone believed Jean-Claude Romand was a prestigious international doctor, not an unemployed con man living off stolen money. But once someone asked for their money back, people ended up paying... with their lives. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoic ... Show More
49m 32s
Sep 2023
EP. 123 COLORADO - The Breckenridge Killer: Caught After 40 Years
In 1982, two young women were brutally murdered at random in the icy cold of Breckenridge, Colorado. And their killer escaped justice, for years... but in 2021, a break in the case would finally lead to the arrest of their killer... and it was somebody with a CRAZY story to share ... Show More
1h 5m
Mar 2023
EP. 101 MARYLAND - The Cannibal Serial Killer of Baltimore: Joe Metheny
On a cold night in December of 1996, a night of hanging out and getting high turned into the darkest nightmare for Rita Kemper. A man named Joe Metheny, whom she had known for a few months, invited her over to his desolate trailer in South Baltimore. Rita trusted Joe but little d ... Show More
1h 3m
Apr 7
SERIAL KILLER: "The Baton Rouge Killer" Pt. 1
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, serial killer Derrick Todd Lee stalked women throughout southern Louisiana. At first, he liked to watch them through their windows. But it wasn't long before his desires became more violent... and he turned to murder. Killer Minds is a Crime Hou ... Show More
1h 1m
Dec 2024
The Apocalypse Killer: Herbert Mullin 2
Herbert Mullin's struggles with delusions made him an especially dangerous serial killer. Unable to overcome the voices in his head, he preyed on people all around Santa Cruz, California in the early 1970s. But because there was so much violent crime in the area, Herb's killing s ... Show More
47m 49s
Mar 2025
SERIAL KILLER: "The Dark Strangler" Pt. 1
Known for his hulking frame and olive complexion, Earle Leonard Nelson was known as the Dark Strangler. In the early 20th century, this terrifying serial killer targeted older women in San Francisco. He charmed his way into their homes... then murdered them with his bare hands. K ... Show More
59m 58s