April 6, 1947 (Kraft Foods / Mutual Broadcasting System)
Dennis Green & Anthony Boucher The legendary writing duo behind many of the finest New Adventures episodes—known for clever plotting, strong atmosphere, and a deep respect for Doyle's canon.
Tom Conway — Sherlock Holmes
Nigel Bruce — Dr. John H. Watson
Joseph Kearns — Supporting roles (various)
Gwen Delano / Betty Lou Gerson — Featured female roles (depending on episode rotation)
Harry Bartell — Announcer
Dean Fosler — Music Director
Elliott Lewis — Often featured in villain or character roles during this period
(Cast lists for these episodes varied slightly week to week, but Conway, Bruce, Bartell, and Fosler were constants.)
A titled gentleman—Sir Timothy Mallory, a baronet of impeccable reputation—vanishes under mysterious circumstances. His abandoned motorcar is found near a flooded quarry, and Scotland Yard fears the worst: suicide or accident.
Holmes, however, is unconvinced.
A strange waterlogged dispatch case, a pair of boots that do not match the baronet's size, and a cryptic note referencing an old family scandal lead Holmes and Watson into a mystery involving:
A forged identity
A submerged crime scene
A long‑buried inheritance dispute
And a villain who uses water as both weapon and disguise
Holmes ultimately reveals that the "submerged baronet" is neither dead nor missing—but hiding behind a carefully engineered deception meant to frame an innocent relative and seize control of the Mallory estate.
This episode is a classic example of the Conway era's atmospheric mysteries, often involving isolated locations, aristocratic intrigue, and elaborate misdirection.
The flooded quarry setting allowed the writers to create a moody, cinematic soundscape, with Fosler's orchestra and the sound effects team delivering some of the best water‑based Foley work of the series.
Conway's Holmes is cool, analytical, and slightly more urbane than Rathbone's—perfect for stories involving aristocratic deception.
Nigel Bruce's Watson shines here, offering both comic warmth and genuine concern for the missing baronet.
The script's twist—Holmes proving the baronet engineered his own disappearance—is one of the more memorable reveals of the 1947 season.
March 31, 1947 (Mutual Broadcasting System)
This is one of the radio series' adaptations of the original Conan Doyle classic, first published in The Strand Magazine in 1891.
Dennis Green & Anthony Boucher Adapted from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's original short story.
Tom Conway — Sherlock Holmes
Nigel Bruce — Dr. John H. Watson
Harry Bartell — Announcer
Joseph Kearns — Jabez Wilson / Duncan Ross (depending on casting rotation)
Elliott Lewis — John Clay (often cast in villain roles)
Gwen Delano / Betty Lou Gerson — Supporting roles
Dean Fosler — Music Director
One of the most beloved Holmes stories—and Conan Doyle's own #2 favorite—comes to life in this lively radio adaptation.
Holmes is consulted by Jabez Wilson, a pawnbroker with flaming red hair who has been hired by the bizarre Red‑Headed League to copy the Encyclopaedia Britannica for generous pay. When the League suddenly dissolves without explanation, Wilson seeks Holmes's help.
Holmes quickly deduces:
The League is a fraudulent front
Wilson was deliberately kept away from his shop
A criminal gang is tunneling beneath the premises
And the mastermind is John Clay, one of the cleverest villains in the canon
The radio version adds:
Expanded dialogue between Holmes and Watson
A more dramatic confrontation in the bank vault
A humorous exchange between Wilson and Watson
A slightly heightened villain monologue from Clay
Holmes's final reveal—explaining the muddy knees, the mismatched job posting, and the timing of the League's dissolution—remains one of the most satisfying deductions in the entire canon.
Conway's Holmes brings a smooth, urbane confidence to the case, contrasting nicely with Bruce's baffled but loyal Watson.
The adaptation stays remarkably faithful to Doyle's plot while adding radio‑friendly pacing and humor.
Elliott Lewis (if cast as Clay) delivers one of the best villain performances of the Conway era—cold, articulate, and quietly menacing.
The sound design for the tunneling sequence and the bank vault confrontation is particularly strong.
This episode is often cited by collectors as one of the best New Adventures adaptations of a canonical story.
Two great radio adventures from The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes starring Tom Conway and Nigel Bruce