logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2024
7m 2s

Book Talk: Divorcing Traditions: Islamic...

Al-Mahdi Institute
About this episode

Divorcing Traditions is an ethnography of Islamic legal expertise and practices in India, a secular state in which Muslims are a significant minority and where Islamic judgments are not legally binding. Katherine Lemons argues that an analysis of divorce in accordance with Islamic strictures is critical to the understanding of Indian secularism.

Lemons analyzes four marital dispute adjudication forums run by Muslim jurists or lay Muslims to show that religious law does not muddle the categories of religion and law but generates them. Drawing on ethnographic and archival research conducted in these four institutions-NGO-run women's arbitration centers (mahila panchayats); sharia courts (dar ul-qazas); a Muslim jurist's authoritative legal opinions (fatwas); and the practice of what a Muslim legal expert (mufti) calls "spiritual healing"-Divorcing Traditions shows how secularism is an ongoing project that seeks to establish and maintain an appropriate relationship between religion and politics. A secular state is always secularizing. And yet, as Lemons demonstrates, the state is not the only arbiter of the relationship between religion and law: religious legal forums help to constitute the categories of private and public, religious and secular upon which secularism relies. In the end, because Muslim legal expertise and practice are central to the Indian legal system and because Muslim divorce's contested legal status marks a crisis of the secular distinction between religion and law, Muslim divorce, argues Lemons, is a key site for understanding Indian secularism.


Up next
Jun 18
Shi'ism and the LGB Challenge: A Look Within with Dr Muhammed Reza Tajri | Thinking Islam | Ep.5
In this episode of Thinking Islam, Dr Zoheir Esmail is joined by Dr Muhammed Reza. Tajri to explore the complex intersection between Shi'a Muslim identity and LGB experiences through the lens of sociology. Drawing from his unique position as an insider-researcher, Dr Tajri unpack ... Show More
1h 31m
Jun 12
The Codex Mashhad: Unlocking the Early History of the Qur’an by Dr Morteza Karimi-nia
What does a rare Qurʾānic manuscript from the 1st century AH reveal about the early history of Islam?In this seminar, Dr Morteza Karimi-Nia, a leading scholar in Qurʾānic manuscript studies, presents his research on Codex Mashhad, a nearly complete Qurʾān written in ḥijāzī script ... Show More
37m 16s
May 28
Mental Health in Islam: Anxiety, Depression & Healing with Dr Zoheir Esmail | Thinking Islam | Ep.4
Is being depressed a sign of kufr? Is my anxiety due to sinning? In this episode of Thinking Islam, we explore how Islamic approaches towards mental health challenge traditional stigmas and modern psychological frameworks with Dr Zoheir Esmail. From examining the concepts of qalb ... Show More
1h 47m
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2024
Shehnaz Haqqani, "Feminism, Tradition and Change in Contemporary Islam: Negotiating Islamic Law and Gender" (Oneworld, 2024)
Shehnaz Haqqani's new book Feminism, Tradition and Change in Contemporary Islam: Negotiating Islamic Law and Gender (Oneworld 2024), masterfully blends textual analysis of pre-modern and modern Islamic consensus with qualitative interviews with Muslims in the contemporary United ... Show More
1h 24m
Dec 2024
Shehnaz Haqqani, "Feminism, Tradition and Change in Contemporary Islam: Negotiating Islamic Law and Gender" (Oneworld, 2024)
Shehnaz Haqqani's new book Feminism, Tradition and Change in Contemporary Islam: Negotiating Islamic Law and Gender (Oneworld 2024), masterfully blends textual analysis of pre-modern and modern Islamic consensus with qualitative interviews with Muslims in the contemporary United ... Show More
1h 24m
Aug 2024
Rachel M. Scott, "Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and the Nation State in Egyptian Constitution Making" (Cornell UP, 2021)
By examining the intersection of Islamic law, state law, religion, and culture in the Egyptian nation-building process, Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and the Nation State in Egyptian Constitution Making (Cornell University Press, 2021) highlights how the sharia, when attached t ... Show More
1h 5m
Feb 2025
10/1: Why is Zina Haram But Mut'ah Deemed Halal? | The Real Shia Beliefs
Things you'll learn in this episode of The Real Shia Beliefs:- Common objection against Mut'ah marriage- Significance of signatures in our societies- Why are witnesses needed for divorce but not for Nikah?- How a signature makes an illegal act legal- The impact of the ver ... Show More
35m 41s
Apr 25
Surah An-Nisaa: The Women - Verse 21 - No Cash, No Divorce!
The dowry is a woman's right in Islam. However, we find that it often causes problems during the divorce. In today's Tafsir, we will explain the dowry's role during separation and divorce and how some Muslim men abuse and coerce their wives for material gain. If you or someone yo ... Show More
1s
Apr 2024
Arsalan Khan, "The Promise of Piety: Islam and the Politics of Moral Order in Pakistan" (Cornell UP, 2024)
The Promise of Piety: Islam and the Politics of Moral Order in Pakistan (Cornell University Press, 2024) by Arsalan Khan is an incisive ethnographic study of Pakistan’s Tablighi movement. This piety movement attracts Pakistani Muslim men across class, caste, and social contexts a ... Show More
1h 21m
Mar 2025
Should Muslims Leave the West? - Fatima Barkatulla & Mufti Barkatulla
Shaykha Fatima Barkatulla was joined by her father Mufti Abdul Qadir Barkatulla where they discussed the place of Muslims in the West and how Muslims can be a force for good at a time when the West is collapsing spirtually and morally. 00:00 - Introduction 01:42 - Early Muslim Co ... Show More
1h 3m
Oct 2024
27 Islam in a Secular Age | Surah Al Jumu'ah
Download the Surah Al-Jumu'ah guided workbook at https://www.bayyinah.com In episode twenty seven of A Deeper Look Surah Al-Jumu'ah, Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan tackles the misconceptions surrounding secularism and its impact on religious expression in different societies. Through an ... Show More
25m 1s
Dec 2024
DEBUNKING Feminist Freedom and Finding Ultimate Truth | Ramia Sultan
OnePath Network sits down with Sister Ramia Abdo Sultan, an Australian-Palestinian lawyer & Community Relations Advisor to the Australian National Imams Council (ANIC) to debunk some common misconception about law in the Islamic and secular world, as well as helping us navigate s ... Show More
55m 47s
Aug 2024
Rachel M. Scott, "Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and the Nation State in Egyptian Constitution Making" (Cornell UP, 2021)
By examining the intersection of Islamic law, state law, religion, and culture in the Egyptian nation-building process, Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and the Nation State in Egyptian Constitution Making (Cornell University Press, 2021) highlights how the sharia, when attached t ... Show More
1h 5m