logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2024
53m 15s

Should We Legalize the Market for Human ...

Open to Debate
About this episode

There are currently 103,000 people in the U.S. waiting for life-saving organ transplants and 17 people die each day waiting for one. The demand for organ transplants worldwide far exceeds the supply due to a reliance on altruistic donations in most countries. Some economists and health experts wonder whether creating a free or regulated market for selling human organs would solve this issue. Those in support of a market argue that each person has a choice to decide what they want to do with their bodies and that with proper regulations, it can be safe, ethical, and financially beneficial for both sellers and buyers. Those who don’t support it have ethical and practical concerns about turning body parts into market commodities and worry about the risks of abuse that would be difficult to control and could undermine the integrity of the medical system, even with regulation. 

  

With this background, we debate the following question: Should We Legalize the Market for Human Organs? 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Jul 8
Think Twice: Reading the Constitution with Justice Stephen Breyer
As an Associate Justice on the Supreme Court for almost three decades, Stephen Breyer was no stranger to hearing arguments for different sides in major cases. In this episode, our moderator-in-chief, John Donvan, and Chief Content Officer, Lia Matthow, interview Justice Breyer an ... Show More
53m 15s
Jul 1
Are Sanctions An Effective Policy Tool?
Open to Debate, in partnership with the Human Rights Foundation and the Oslo Freedom Forum, is examining a strategy employed by many countries to respond to aggressive or authoritarian regimes. In recent years, these have been levied against countries such as Russia, Venezuela, a ... Show More
53m 15s
Jun 24
Is Trump's America a Reliable Ally?
Under President Trump, America’s role on the global stage is being redefined — but can other countries trust its allyship under his leadership? Critics argue his transactional approach and threats to abandon allies undermine trust and force nations to reconsider their security. S ... Show More
53m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2024
CLASSIC: The Red Market: Is China Executing People To Harvest Their Organs?
Until the day we're able to manufacture affordable, reliable organs from scratch, organ transplants will remain the only hope for millions of sick and dying people across the planet. For this reason, organs have been a big business for decades -- and not all aspects of the busine ... Show More
57m 24s
Aug 2024
Can I sell my eggs and sperm for a profit? Part 1
Selling your sperm or eggs is illegal in Australia, and has been for a long time. Unlike other parts of the world, where you can make a considerable profit – in some cases up to $10,000 per egg cycle, and hundreds of dollars per sperm donation – in Australia we’re only able to pa ... Show More
18m 7s
Jun 20
The Organ Transplant Revolution Starts Here
At any given moment, more than 100,000 people are waiting for an organ transplant. Every day, 17 of them die waiting. This is a story of survival, bravery, and a medical breakthrough that could solve everything – using organs from animals. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit ... Show More
30m 27s
Oct 2009
Munger on Shortages, Prices, and Competition
Mike Munger of Duke University talks with EconTalk host Russ Roberts about the limits of prices and markets, especially in the area of health. They talk about vaccines, organ transplants, the ethics of triage and what role price should play in allocating. The discussion concludes ... Show More
1h 8m
Oct 2023
S2 Episode 5: When Is It Time to Talk About Kidney Transplantation?
Join experts Drs Matthew Sparks and Samira Farouk as they pull back the curtain to help patients and providers better understand the transplant journey. Relevant disclosures can be found with the episode show notes on Medscape (https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/991605). The to ... Show More
28m 50s
May 2024
Tom Mueller, "How to Make a Killing: Blood, Death and Dollars in American Medicine" (Norton, 2023)
Dialysis is a medical miracle, a treatment that allows people with kidney failure to live when otherwise they would die. It also provides a captive customer for the dialysis industry, which values the steady revenues that come from critically required long-term care that is guara ... Show More
1h 9m
Nov 2024
Daniel S. Goldberg, "Tackle Football and Traumatic Brain Injuries: Law, Ethics, and Public Health" (Johns Hopkins UP, 2024)
Football is the national game in the United States – and many families and friends bond over their love of the sport. While few people play professional football, many participate in tackle football as children and adolescents. In the last decades, more attention has been paid to ... Show More
1h 3m
Apr 2023
The benefits of longterm thinking in the TikTok age
Future citizens have, by definition, no voice but someone needs to speak on their behalf if we’re meant to build a longterm society. The solution to the global housing crisis requires longterm thinking, creating solutions that will sustain us for at least the next 100 years, not ... Show More
27m 23s
Apr 2024
Me and my medical data
Patients care apps - which give patients unprecedented access to their health records - are being rolled out by NHS trusts across the country. You might imagine, says Will Self, that 'this previously unimaginable access to such a wealth of medical data should empower me, make me ... Show More
10m 59s