logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2024
1h 12m

What We Get Wrong About Studying Muslim ...

MUHAMMAD JALAL
About this episode

It is said a people without a past are a lost soul. And in today’s turbulent world, the Muslim ummah has come to realise that we have, in many cases, been taught a version of history that fails to appreciate what the late Shabbir Akhtar called Islam as a imperial faith.

Dr Yakoob Ahmed is an academic specialising in late Ottoman history. He was until recently a lecturer in Islamic history at Istanbul University. He is a regular to this podcast and writes and lectures extensively on Ottoman history. He is the author of a soon to be published title, Does History Matter – history done islamically - the conversation of today.


Let me remind all viewers that to help us continue to engage critical thought at this time, Please consider becoming a Patron. https://www.patreon.com/TheThinkingMuslim

You can also support The Thinking Muslim through a one-time donation: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/Donate


Sign up to Muhammad Jalal's newsletter: https://jalalayn.substack.com


Purchase our Thinking Muslim mug: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/merch


Find us on:


Twitter: https://twitter.com/thinking_muslim


Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/The-Thinking-Muslim-Podcast-105790781361490


Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thinkingmuslimpodcast/


Telegram: https://t.me/thinkingmuslim


Host: https://twitter.com/jalalayn


Website Archive: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com



0:00 Introduction

2:00 Gaza at the crossed roads

8:08 History as a vocation

11:08 Islam as an Imperial Faith

14:40 Historians providing solutions

19:48 What are we doing wrong with history?

25:26 Idealism?

32:50 The Quran and History

37:32 Ibn Khuldun’s cyclical theory

43:22 Islam and the production of knowledge

50:40 Fiction and Ertrugul

55:20 Islamic method of history?


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Oct 7
2 Years On: Has the Resistance Won? With Dr Norman Finkelstein
Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipDonate to our charity partner Baitulmaal here: http://btml.us/thinkingmuslim This week on The Thinking Muslim, we have Dr. Finkelstein to discuss Gaza two years after October 7, 2023. We explor ... Show More
1h 14m
Sep 30
Charlie Kirk - is the US heading for Civil War? Imam Tom Facchine
Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipImam Tom Facchine joins us to discuss the MAGA Right’s stance on 9/11, why the Right must wake up to Israel’s propaganda, and the importance of Muslims building strong institutions.You can find ... Show More
52m 41s
Sep 19
The Gaza Doctor TRUMP Needs To Hear | Dr. Bilal Piracha
Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipDr Bilal Piracha has just returned from a haunting trip to Gaza. He shares the stark reality: the extermination campaign is in its final stages, and we are running out of time. Dr Piracha is an ... Show More
58m 32s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2022
DAY 57: Defending Islam Intellectually - Story of Al-Kindi | Sheikh Usama Al-Attar
A good question is half of knowledge. Raising the right questions in the face of authoritarian ideas and theories can sometimes lay them bare. One such question by a student made Yaqoob al-Kindi, the famous Muslim philosopher and polymath, discard his own work.Listen to Shaykh Dr ... Show More
7m 33s
Oct 2023
Ep 9: The 500-year history of Islam in America, with Dr Sylviane Diouf and Dr Hussein Rashid
Our latest episode tells the story of how Islam arrived in America, possibly as early as the 1400s on ships from Europe and West Africa.  We have two guests on this episode. One is Sylviane Diouf, a visiting scholar at the Center for the Study of Slavery and Justice at Brown Univ ... Show More
39m 50s
May 2025
123: How Horses Collapsed The Muslim Empire w. Saad Yaqoub
Georgetown PHD Candidate ,Saad Yaqoub, reveals the untold history of the rise and fall of Muslim civilization. The answer is: horses? Saad also debunks the myth of a unified and monolithic Islamic empire and the notion of “golden ages” in history. Lastly he gives a blueprint for ... Show More
1h 19m
Sep 2024
103: The Pope, TimeTravel, Sana Manuscripts & The Modern Quran w. Sh Uthman Ibn Farooq
Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farouq (one message foundation) come back on the Ansari podcast! For another insightful conversation about all things Quran, bible, politics & Islamic history! Sheikh Uthman ends all debate about Quranic preservation and dives into the history of it's Divine ... Show More
1h 41m
Sep 2016
#011: America's Islamic History Museum w/ Amir Muhammad, "The People's Historian."
This podcast was recorded at America's Islamic History Museum, in Washington, D.C. with the founder and curator of the museum, Amir Muhammad a.k.a. "The People's Historian." http://www.aihmuseum.org/home.html **Path & Present** Is a community endeavor produced for the sake of sha ... Show More
1h 10m
Feb 2025
114: What Does The Reviver of Islam Look Like in the 21st Century? w. Dr. Ermin Sinanovic
Dr. Ermin Sinanovic, Executive Director of the Center for Islam in the Contemporary World at Shenandoah University and a Faculty Associate in Research at Cornell University, explores the concept of Mujaddid (the renewer of Islam) and their relevance in the 21st century. He studie ... Show More
56m 34s
Feb 2024
E79:The ProphetﷺLost Ring, Pirates of the Caribbean & Crows of the Arabs w. Mustafa Briggs
Mustafa Briggs once again joins the podcast with a jampacked episode full of fascinating stories of Muslim figures throughout history. The origin and definition of "Taha" & "Yasin" are Ethiopian? The Fierce first female sultana! The crows of the arabs - the poets! The prophet Muh ... Show More
1h 44m
Mar 2025
Book Talk: The Story of the Qur'an: Its History and Place in Muslim Life by Prof. Ingrid Mattson
Join Professor Ingrid Mattson in this insightful Book Talk as she explores her book 'The Story of the Qur’an: Its History and Place in Muslim Life.' Prof. Mattson delves into the historical, theological, and cultural significance of the Qur’an, examining its revelation, transmiss ... Show More
11m 20s
May 2025
Surah An-Nisaa: The Women - Verse 23 - Prophet Muhammad's Secret
In today's Podcast, we address a story the critics of Islam have long celebrated and, sadly, is repeated by Muslims who are ignorant about their faith. Both claim that our beloved Muhammad was chasing his desires—God forbid. Today, we defend our beloved Muhammad and explain the ... Show More
12m 37s
Feb 2025
Season 4, Episode 5: Eugene Rogan, The Arabs: A History
Send us a textJoin Professor Jeffrey Sachs and historian Eugene Rogan, professor of Modern Middle Eastern History at Oxford, as they delve into the complex history of the Arab world, from the Ottoman conquest in 1516 to today’s geopolitical crises of the modern Middle East. Throu ... Show More
52m 39s