logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2024
1 h

Scholes, Carragher & Ornstein Discuss Be...

The Overlap
About this episode

Welcome back to The Overlap’s Fan Debate, brought to you by SkyBet.

 

This week we hear all about David Ornstein’s journey to becoming the man who breaks the big transfer news.


Manchester United legend Paul Scholes talks us through his role as the Director of Recruitment at Salford City and how transfers work in the lower leagues.

 

We are also joined by some of the biggest fan channels across England as they give their club’s best and worst transfers, from Cantona joining Manchester United, to Balotelli signing for Liverpool.


Plus Paul Scholes, David Ornstein and Jamie Carragher give us their best and worst Premier League transfers. 

 

Let us know your team’s best and worst transfers in the comments below.

 

 

 

00:00 - Promo 

 

00:54 - Intro 

 

01:05 - Paul Scholes on transfers at Salford City

 

03:18 - David Ornstein’s origin story! 

 

11:52 - Fan questions to Paul Scholes and David Ornstein

 

23:21 - Paul Scholes on Manchester United’s best and worst transfers

 

24:27 - Adam on Manchester United’s best and worst transfers

 

26:43 - Big Steve on Manchester City’s best and worst transfers

 

28:48 - Chloe on Liverpool’s best and worst transfers

 

30:00 - Baz on Everton’s best and worst transfers 

 

33:58 - Dan on Crystal Palace’s best and worst transfers

 

35:24 - Shaun on Chelsea’s best and worst transfers

 

40:57 - Greg on Nottingham Forest's best and worst transfers

 

42:41 - Ben on Tottenham Hotspur's best and worst transfers 

 

52:18 - Alex on Arsenal's best and worst transfers 

 

57:17 - David Ornstein on his Premier League best and worst transfers 

 

59:09 - Jamie Carragher on his Premier League best and worst transfers 

 

1:00:37 - Outtakes 


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Oct 7
Liverpool’s Slip-Up, Arsenal Go Top & Amorim Ready To Go? | The Overlap Fan Debate
Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes return for another episode of The Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet. This week, our fans dive into all the biggest stories across the Premier League, with strong opinions, plenty of disagreement, and a few laughs along the way.The discussion b ... Show More
1h 27m
Sep 9
Man Utd’s Worst Signing, Diving Debate & Transfer Magic Gone | The Overlap Fan Debate
Welcome back to another episode of the Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet.Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes are joined by some of the biggest fan channels across the country to talk all things football, in this episode the fans share their biggest hot takes in the game today!Ea ... Show More
43m 18s
Sep 2
Isak to Liverpool Confirmed, VAR Controversy & Arteta’s Big Problem | Deadline Day Fan Debate
Welcome back to the Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet, it is our Deadline Day special and with that comes fireworks.Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes are joined by some of the biggest fan channels in the country to discuss what could be the most chaotic transfer window ever, f ... Show More
1h 27m
Recommended Episodes
Sep 9
What’s NEXT for Spurs After Levy? The Manchester Derby Preview, Owen vs Rooney & Levy’s BEST & WORST Signings
Daniel Levy’s shock departure ended an era at Tottenham. Spurs’ longest-serving chairman is gone, but what's next for the North London club? Flav joins Rory, Adam and Buvey to unpack Levy’s exit: why he left, how it came to this, and what the future holds. In addition, the fellas ... Show More
54m 40s
Apr 2025
Man Utd vs Man City: Super Sunday derby stalemate exposes both sides' flaws
David Jones is joined by Roy Keane, Micah Richards, Gary Neville and Izzy Christiansen to review the action from Old Trafford as Manchester Utd and Manchester City played out a drab derby draw. Hear from Manchester Utd manager Ruben Amorim and the Manchester City boss Pep Guardio ... Show More
55m 26s
Dec 2024
MNF | Manchester United 0 Newcastle 2 | Soaring Magpies spread their wings to heap more pressure on Amorim
Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville join Dave Jones to look back on Newcastle’s 2-0 win at Manchester United, that condemns the Red Devils to a third straight home loss.      Hear from a deflated Man Utd boss Ruben Amorim, as well as one of Newcastle’s goal scorers, Alexander Isak, ... Show More
39m 26s
Mar 2025
"The WORST Manchester United Attack I've EVER Seen!"
Should Arsenal be looking over their shoulder in a Top 4 battle and are we witnessing Man Utd's WORST ever striking partnership? Ben and Tom are joined by Watto to discuss the key talking points from the weekend’s Premier League action including: 🏆 - The Title Race is now OVER! ... Show More
1h 6m
Aug 24
Fulham frustrate Man Utd after Bruno's penalty nightmare!
Kelly Cates is joined by Ashley Young and Louis Saha to discuss Manchester United's 1-1 draw with Fulham, a match which saw Emile Smith Rowe cancel out Leny Yoro’s controversial opener.Listen to every episode of the Sky Sports Premier League Podcast here: skysports.com/sky-sports ... Show More
1h 2m
Sep 14
Haaland and Foden star as Man City put three past rivals Man Utd
David Jones is joined by Roy Keane, Izzy Christiansen, Micah Richard and Gary Neville on Super Sunday to discuss Manchester City's 3-0 victory over their rivals Manchester United. Listen to every episode of the Sky Sports Premier League Podcast here: skysports.com/sky-sports-prem ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2021
Analysing Anfield: What to remember about Thiago | Klopp’s Fabinho question | And were Carra and Neville right about Salah?
Josh Williams and Dave Hughes return with the latest Analysing Anfield podcast to look back on the win over Southampton, preview the double-header with Manchester United and West Brom, and pick their Premier League team of the season. To the naked eye it appeared Liverpool’s stru ... Show More
56m 5s
Feb 2025
Is There ANYONE Like Messi, Manchester United Relegation, Last Merseyside Derby, Struggling Chelsea & More
On this week’s episode of the Joy of Football Podcast, Neil and Martin compare players to the one and only Lionel Messi, we have 'We Need To Talk About' featuring the struggles of Chelsea and Borussia Dortmund, respectively. Then it's on to 'The Way We Were&ap ... Show More
1h 37m
Feb 2025
Mid-Season Review: Are Villa Quietly Becoming a Superpower?
On this week’s episode, the lads dive into the madness of the Premier League’s mid-season—who’s smashing it, who’s collapsing, and who’s just clinging on for dear life…With the transfer window firmly shut, we break down the biggest winners and losers. Has Chelsea completely lost ... Show More
44m 4s
Aug 28
Roy’s Advice for Amorim, Eze’s Journey & Mainoo’s Man Utd Future | Stick to Football EP 91
Welcome back to Stick to Football, brought to you by ARNE.In this episode, Gary Neville, Jamie Carragher, Roy Keane, Jill Scott and Ian Wright return after another dramatic week of Premier League action.We revisit Newcastle v Liverpool on Monday night, were Liverpool lucky to com ... Show More
1h 31m