logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2024
1h 37m

Is Israel’s War Unjust? | Mark Oppenheim...

Brain in a Vat
About this episode

Join us for an intense debate featuring Mark Oppenheimer, who defends Israel’s war as just, and Raja Halwani, who argues Israel’s war is unjust. The debate covers historical contexts, moral principles, and the roles of both Israel and Hamas, aiming to provide nuanced insights into one of the most challenging global issues of our time.


[00:00] Introduction to the Debate


[01:08] Raja's Opening Statement: Israel's War is Unjust


[11:13] Mark's Opening Statement: Israel's Right to Self-Defense


[21:37] Raja's Rebuttal: Addressing Misconceptions


[27:34] Mark's Rebuttal: The Reality of the Conflict


[32:10] Cross Examination: Raja Questions Mark


[47:45] Debating the Justification of War


[48:39] Israel's Response to October 7th


[49:59] Military Options and Intelligence


[51:11] Idealistic Solutions and International Cooperation


[52:21] Transition to Open Discussion


[52:48] Questioning Israel's Conduct in Gaza


[56:16] One-State vs. Two-State Solutions


[01:04:07] Legitimacy and Rights of Israel


[01:07:48] Hamas Ideology and Anti-Semitism


[01:10:37] Civilian Casualties and Proportionality in War


[01:18:07] Historical Context and Atrocities


[01:19:57] Gaza: Open-Air Prison or Ghetto?


[01:27:39] Closing Statements

Up next
Jul 6
Patriotism Unpacked | Spencer Case (Rebroadcast)
What does it mean to be patriotic, or to love your country? Some argue that patriotism is virtuous because it allows us to transcend our selfish needs and act for the good of our community. But others argue that patriotism is overly narrow-minded, arbitrary and sometimes immoral. ... Show More
59m 38s
Jun 29
Is Tarot a Tool for Thought? | Georgi Gardiner
In this episode of Brain in a Vat, Georgi Gardiner returns to explore the epistemic value of tarot: its capacity to shape self-understanding, spark creative reflection, and influence major life decisions.Drawing on personal experience and philosophical analysis, Georgi examines h ... Show More
1h 1m
Jun 22
Living The Philosophical Life | Agnes Callard
In this episode, Brain in a Vat is joined by public philosopher and author Agnes Callard to explore the relevance of philosophy in everyday life. Drawing from her work on Socrates, Agnes makes a case for why philosophical inquiry matters, now more than ever. From the pig farmer a ... Show More
55m 21s
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2024
The End of Hamas?
In the second of three conversations about the crisis in the Middle East, recorded shortly before the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was reported, Yezid Sayigh talks to Adam Shatz about why he sees Hamas’s attack on Israel on 7 October as an inflection point both for the Pale ... Show More
36m 51s
Oct 2024
Inside Israel
In the first of three episodes on the crisis in the Middle East, Adam Shatz is joined by Mairav Zonszein and Amjad Iraqi to discuss the experiences of Israeli Jews and Palestinian citizens of Israel. While the Netanyahu government is opposed by many Israeli Jews, and increasing n ... Show More
1 h
Nov 2023
Col Douglas Macgregor:Grappling with Ethical Dilemmas: Technology, Warfare, and Morality
Ready to grapple with some of the most challenging ethical dilemmas of our time? Today, we walk a tightrope between technology, warfare, and morality with @DougAMacgregor. We're kicking off by examining how an over-reliance on technology may have paved the way for mishaps like th ... Show More
28m 19s
Oct 2024
The Creation of Israel | Welcome to Season Eight!
One year ago, Hamas terrorists attacked Israel and killed or captured well over a thousand of its citizens. In response, the Israeli government launched its largest military campaign since 1973 and killed thousands in the Gaza Strip. The war has since expanded with Israel battlin ... Show More
18m 57s
Nov 2023
Life in the West Bank with Sari Bashi
It’s been over a month since Hamas' rampage in Southern Israel killed over a thousand Israeli men, women and children, and over a month of Israel's war against Hamas in Gaza that has claimed 10,000 lives, according to the Gaza Health Ministry. In this episode, we’re focusing on t ... Show More
54m 44s
Sep 2024
Buck Brief - Hamas Kills Hostages Because it is Evil
Buck Sexton delves into the brutal actions of Hamas, labeling it an "enemy of civilization" and a "death cult" committed to the destruction of Israel and the Jewish people. He discusses the recent execution of six hostages, including a dual U.S. citizen, and criticizes those who ... Show More
13m 37s