logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2024
1h 14m

The E31 BMW 850CSi and other 8-series — ...

Hagerty Media
About this episode

E31 Syndrome: The explanation of why the E31 8-series is widely regarded as a beautiful failure. This is the full history of the BMW 850i, 850Ci, 850CSi, and 840Ci.


===

Click here to join the Hagerty Driver's Club: https://bit.ly/Join-HDC-Cammisa-Rev

===


The BMW 850i had the first post-war German V12. It made 300 hp and was installed in a pillarless, Ferrari-esque coupe almost universally praised for its beauty.


After its debut at the 1989 IAA Frankfurt Motor Show, its first 3 years of production were sold out. But many of those orders were cancelled once the press got a hold of the 850i.


Was it a bad car? In no way. The problem was that its Ferrari looks were married to an uninspired driving experience. The E31 had been conceived by BMW's R&D department (not its marketing department) as a rolling showpiece for its capabilities. And so BMW's priorities were perhaps not in line with market expectations.


In other words: E31 Syndrome. A car that looks one way but drives differently.


The discrepancy was solved when BMW's Motorsport Division made an M8 out of the 850i... but the marketing issue remained because BMW didn't badge it an M8. It was called 850CSi, which wasn't enough of a differentiator. And was made worse because the 850i was renamed 850Ci for no explicable reason.


The 850CSi was a success — it landed to rave reviews, and sold out almost immediately. But its lack of M Badging has cost it enthusiast recognition. Even though it's a full M car with a WBS VIN prefix and the same treatment that the E36 got becoming an M3 out of a 325i.


Learn all about this car on this episode of the Carmudgeon Show — a part of the Hagerty Podcast Network.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Aug 18
Car Week Kickoff At Motorlux — The Carmudgeon Show w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 201
Jason and Derek escape the studio this week to record from Hagerty's Motorlux event, the kickoff to Monterey Car Week 2025. We join them at this year's highlighted Bruno Sacco display, featuring designs that defined Mercedes-Benz in the 80's, 90's, and 2000's. The legacy of Sacco ... Show More
37m 51s
Aug 11
Go Rallying With Your Friends — The Carmudgeon Show w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 200
In celebration of 200 episodes of The Carmudgeon Show, Jason Cammisa and Derek Tam Hyphen Scott debrief their recent weekend-long Pacific Coast Rally with friends. === The Carmudgeon Show Sponsor, Vredestein Tires: https://www.vredestein.com/ === Indecisive between his BMW 850CSi ... Show More
55m 46s
Aug 4
Ask Us Anything: Part 4 — The Carmudgeon Show with Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 199
We've finally run out of questions to answer! As we come to an end of our AMA series, Jason and Derek continue to tackle the remaining questions from the last Q&A Some topics you asked about (and some you didn't), including but not limited to: - Opel Manta(?) - Nissan Altima Driv ... Show More
51m 20s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 18
Does BMW's M5 Touring Miss the Mark?
Spike, Jonny, and Zuckerman review two BMW M5 Tourings while debating whether they're worthy of the M badge. Spike shares his unexpected modeling career for Nobleman Magazine, while Henry Catchpole from Hagerty joins to discuss his mind-bending experience driving the Porsche 963 ... Show More
50m 3s
Mar 2025
We Bought the Untouched E39 BMW M5
Zuckerman just scored a unicorn—a Dakar Yellow E39 BMW M5 with only 633 ORIGINAL MILES! Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Drew Leslie from EAG break down the absurd negotiation process, the restoration challenges, and whether this car is too perfect to drive. Plus, Spike dishes on his ... Show More
1h 9m
Oct 2024
We've driven the new 717bhp BMW M5 #235
Dan Prosser and Andrew Frankel review the new hybrid BMW M5. With 717bhp it's easily the most powerful M5 yet, but at 2435kg it's the heaviest by a distance too. Has BMW M managed to overcome all that weight to make another great M5? Dan and Andrew also discuss Lando Norris's rac ... Show More
45m 18s
Jun 2024
The greatest Le Mans in years and the best BMW M5 #217
Dan Prosser and Andrew Frankel discuss this year's 24 Hours of Le Mans, won in style by Ferrari. Andrew, who was there with BMW, recalls one of the best runnings of the race he's witnessed in all the years he's been going. Dan and Andrew also tee up BMW M5 week on The Intercooler ... Show More
46m 58s
Jun 13
Maserati Is Doomed. Trump Selling His Tesla on Cars & Bids? $45K for an E46 M3?
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! Upgrade your wardrobe and save on @trueclassic at https://trueclassic.com/CARS #trueclassicpod Acre Gold - https://www.getacregold.com 30 ... Show More
1h 26m
Nov 2024
Spike is a BMW Guy
After spending 2 weeks in Zuckerman's 1985 BMW M5 E28, Spike falls hard for the brand. Jonny returns from his white glove training with Rolls Royce with tales of overeating, then reviews the new Mercedes AMG S63. And the group weighs in on the Peanut the Squirrel execution. All t ... Show More
1h 25m
May 2024
TestDrive: BMW M3 Touring (ACS3 Sport)
The M3 Touring (AC Schnitzer ACS3 Sport) test drive. Write to us with your Car Debates, Car Conclusions, and Topic Tuesdays at everydaydrivertv@gmail.com or everydaydriver.com. Sadly, the 3-series Touring is forbidden fruit - it isn’t available in North America. But there’s many ... Show More
22m 9s
May 30
Porsche Kills the 718! China Crushes Tesla! Doug on BMW’s Ugly Redemption Arc!
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! DeleteMe - https://joindeleteme.com/DEMURO Get 20% off your plan! Download Cash App Today: https://capl.onelink.me/vFut/kk6qvwgr#CashAppPod ... Show More
1h 34m
Apr 2025
Seen Through Glass's Nightmare Ferrari Restoration
This week, Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Sam Fane from ‪https://youtube.com/@seenthroughglass‬ unpack why Sam’s ditching his Porsche Boxster, the chaos of restoring a Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale he accidentally bought, and Matt Farah's 8-hour The Smoking Tire 1000th episode. Als ... Show More
1h 6m
Jul 19
#2557: Baby Driver
Janet fr Charlotte(or maybe it was Charlotte from Janet?) had a simple question: automatic or stick for her 16 year old daughter's new car? But when Click and Clack find out that the new car is a BMW Z3 M Roadster -it's fireworks time on this episode of the Best of Car Talk. Get ... Show More
37m 44s