logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2024
1h 5m

Ep. 220: Political violence and speech

FIRE
About this episode

Did overheated political rhetoric lead to the assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump?

On today’s show we explore political violence: its history, its causes, and its relationship with free speech. Flemming Rose is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute. He previously served as foreign affairs editor and culture editor at the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten. In 2005, he was principally responsible for publishing the cartoons that initiated the Muhammad cartoons controversy.

 

Nadine Strossen is a professor emerita at New York Law School, former president of the ACLU, and a senior fellow at FIRE.

 

Jacob Mchangama is the founder and executive director of The Future of Free Speech. He is a research professor at Vanderbilt University and a senior fellow at FIRE.

 

Timestamps

 

0:00 Intro

2:45 Initial reactions to Trump assassination attempt

7:39 Can we blame political violence on rhetoric?

15:56 Weimar and Nazi Germany

26:05 Is the Constitution a “suicide pact”?

39:21 Is violence ever justified?

49:24 Censorship in the wake of tragedy and true threats

59:06 Closing thoughts

1:04:54 Outro

 

Show notes: “Freedom of expression and social conflict” by Christian Bjørnskov and Jacob Mchangama

FIRE’s 2024 College Free Speech Rankings (featuring data on college student support for violence)

Recent court ruling in DeRay McKesson protest case

The Tyranny of Silence” by Flemming Rose

Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media” by Jacob Mchangama

 

Up next
Aug 12
Ep. 249: FIRE Reacts — Where does Harvard go from here? With Larry Summers
2025 has not been kind to Harvard. To date, the Trump administration has revoked nearly $3 billion in research funding to the university, demanding violations of free speech, academic freedom, and institutional autonomy in return for restoring the funding. In response, Harvard fi ... Show More
1h 8m
Aug 6
Ep. 248: Commercial speech and the First Amendment
Imagine the government forcing you to label your all-natural milk product as “imitation.” Florida tried to make one dairy farm do just that, sparking a First Amendment question: Where’s the line between a business’s right to speak and protecting consumers from deception? In this ... Show More
50m 42s
Jul 24
Ep. 247: Justin Amash
Throughout his career, former Congressman Justin Amash has been a strong advocate for freedom of speech, writing that “The value of free speech comes from encountering views that are unorthodox, uncommon, or unaccepted…Free speech is a barren concept if people are limited to expr ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
The assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump: Political implications, how the attack could have taken place, and the history of political violence in America
Today on the show, Fareed is joined by an expert panel to discuss the assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump. Eurasia Group president Ian Bremmer, New Yorker staff writer Evan Osnos, and CNN presidential historian Timothy Naftali all join to talk about the politic ... Show More
42m 9s
Jul 2024
The Long Simmer of Political Violence in America
America is not new to political violence, but the near-assassination of Donald Trump is an attack without comparison in 21st-century politics. How do process it? What happens next? And how true are the claims, as President Joe Biden put it in the immediate aftermath of the shooti ... Show More
23m 44s
Jul 5
EP:2 Murder by Policy: Empire of Violence : The Complicity of American Power
What happens when a society built on "never again" becomes the very force it once condemned? In this unflinching examination of America's role in global violence, Scott Horton and Daryl Cooper peel back the comfortable narratives we tell ourselves about being the world's moral le ... Show More
1h 6m
Aug 2024
The Free Speech Debate
After the government announced it may ditch the Conservatives' law to fight cancel culture on campuses, Ed Vaizey asks whether freedom of speech at University is under threat. He hears the cases for and against - including from former universities minister Robert Halfon, who was ... Show More
48m 10s
Oct 2024
Why Trump is a Fascist (EXTENDED VERSION)
Donald Trump is being called a fascist – by his former appointees and his opponent Kamala Harris.On Sunday, in a rally at Madison Square Garden in New York, Trump and his allies traded in crude and racist insults, amplifying the nationalistic rhetoric his camp has become known fo ... Show More
30m 36s
Nov 2024
Trump and the Crisis of Liberalism
Donald Trump’s victory in the 2024 U.S. presidential election comes at a moment of turbulence for global democracy. It’s been a year marked by almost universal backlash against incumbent leaders by voters apparently eager to express their anger with the status quo—and also an era ... Show More
35m 13s
Apr 2025
The Conservative Activist Pushing Trump to Attack U.S. Colleges
This week, we interviewed two people with leading roles in the rapidly escalating conflict between the Trump administration and American higher education.Today, we speak with Christopher Rufo, who led the conservative critique of, and assault on, critical race theory and diversit ... Show More
43m 49s
Jan 2025
The Reinvention of Jan. 6
Since the riot on Capitol Hill four years ago, President-elect Donald Trump and his allies have set out to sanitize the events of that day, changing it from a day of violence into, in Mr. Trump’s words, a day of love.As he prepares to take office for his second term, Mr. Trump sa ... Show More
35m 32s
Jul 29
The 300-year battle over free speech
From the French Revolution to the social media age, Fara Dabhoiwala charts the surprising history of the idea that people should be able to say what they like From America's founding fathers via John Stuart Mill to today's social media giants, humanity has long wrestled with the ... Show More
37m 32s
May 13
Kanye West Racism Debate + Cassie Testifies at Diddy Trial
Last week on Uncensored, Piers Morgan held a debate on racism which sparked a furious row when Lilly Gaddis - speaking on behalf of Shiloh Hendriz, the mom raising funds after being caught racially-abusing a five-year-old boy - openly admitted to freely using the N-word. We also ... Show More
56m 22s