logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2024
39m 50s

430: My Rental Burned Down! What I Wish ...

BIGGERPOCKETS
About this episode

You get a call one day from the fire department, telling you, “You’ve had a house fire that’s destroyed your rental property.” What do you do first? Check on the tenants, call the insurance company, or start thinking of ways to financially recover? Your tenant has lost all their belongings; you’ve lost an investment you worked hard to acquire. If everyone is safe, what’s the next step you should take? Or, a more important question: what would you have wished you knew BEFORE this happened?


If you think the elite investors at BiggerPockets are immune to these tragedies, you’re wrong. BiggerPockets CFO Aaron Sallade was in this exact position earlier this year when he got a phone call no one wants to receive. His property was destroyed, but thankfully, his tenant walked away unscathed. He now needed to go through the next steps: submitting insurance claims, getting restoration quotes, and, if he chose to do so, selling the property.


Aaron shares the entire timeline from the rental burning down to reaching out to insurance, getting restoration quotes, and eventually deciding what to do with the property. He even dives into what he wishes he had known BEFORE this tragic event, and not hearing his advice could cost you!


In This Episode We Cover

What to do when a tenant accidentally burns down your rental property 

Why you MUST require renters insurance on every property in your portfolio 

Filing rental property insurance claims and how long it’ll take to get paid for the damages 

Rebuilding vs. selling and whether it’s worth the time to renovate a burnt-down home

The rarely discussed “1033 exchange” that can help you during a tragic event like a house fire 

The two things you NEED before you can get reimbursed from your insurance company

And So Much More!


(00:00) Intro

(01:05) First Rental Property Numbers 

(03:55) "Your House Was Destroyed" 

(06:49) Getting the Tenant Settled 

(09:10) Working with Insurance 

(13:15) Restoration Timeline and Insurance Payout

(14:47) What to Know BEFORE This Happens

(18:53) Rebuild or Sell?

(22:52) Other Options to Sell

(26:46) Final Numbers On the Rental

(28:32) Insurance Rate Changes 

(30:50) Worst Case Scenario Resolved! 


Check out more resources from this show on BiggerPockets.com and https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/rookie-430

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email advertise@biggerpockets.com.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Today
Should You Buy Your First Property with a Partner or Solo? (Rookie Reply)
Welcome to another Rookie Reply, where Tony J Robinson and Ashley Kehr answer questions from the BiggerPockets Forums and Real Estate Rookie Facebook group. This time, we’re covering questions like: House hacking with a friend, can you legally do this? How to handle one tenant wa ... Show More
21m 10s
Oct 8
5 Ways to Buy Rentals Without a Huge Bank Account
Most rookies think you need a mountain of cash to buy a rental property, but the truth is that the financing strategy you choose matters much more than the size of your bank account. Today, we’re breaking down five of the best (and sometimes overlooked) ways to get your hands on ... Show More
38m 3s
Oct 6
4 Overlooked Real Estate Investments That Pay Big in 2025
There are dozens of ways to make money in real estate—including some tactics that are currently flying under the radar and quietly making smart investors a ton of money in 2025. The best part? Many of them are easier to implement than you probably think, and in this episode, we’l ... Show More
43m 39s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2025
Pro’s Guide to Property Management: Work Less, Make More from Your Rentals!
Property management can make or break your real estate portfolio, and most new investors don’t know where to start. Do you hire a property manager or self-manage your rental(s)? How do you know a property manager will ensure your rental is performing instead of just collecting a ... Show More
35m 47s
Apr 2025
Buying ONE Rental Changed My Life: 4 Years Later, I Quit My Job
Just buy ONE rental property and watch your life change. Today’s guest was working multiple jobs, and a single property purchase allowed her to finally free up her weekends and regain some freedom in her life. The best part? She did it with just around $4,000, then repeated the p ... Show More
38m 51s
Sep 2024
A Better Retirement After Buying Just ONE Rental (and Never FOMO-ing)
Mike Baum owns just one rental property, but this one property alone has changed his life. It’s allowed him to become such an investing expert that he’s constantly being asked for his opinion on the BiggerPockets forums, and he provides some of the most well-thought-out investing ... Show More
34m 37s
Jul 2024
985: Seeing Greene: How to Use Home Equity to Retire, Buy Rentals, or House Hack
Should you use a HELOC to buy investment property? Would we use home equity to retire? When is it time to sell a performing property and exchange it for a more expensive one? If you’ve got home equity, this episode could help you reach financial freedom faster as we answer real l ... Show More
47m 38s
Mar 2025
13 Rental Units with a “Rinse and Repeat” Investing Method
This investor built a multimillion-dollar real estate portfolio with low-money-down loans and little cash-to-close. Thanks to his smart “rinse and repeat” strategy, he’s quickly scaled from zero to 13 rental units in just four years, all while collecting thousands of dollars of c ... Show More
38m 14s
Jan 2024
879: How to Buy a House in 2024
You asked, and we answered. Here’s our step-by-step guide on how to buy a house in 2024. Whether you’re looking for a first primary residence, rental property, house hack, or short-term rental, these are the EXACT steps you’ll have to follow to buy a house. But before you can eve ... Show More
44m 12s
Feb 2025
‘Building’ 7-Figure Wealth with ONE Very Lucrative Rental Property
Though only five years into his rental property investing career, David Rosenbeck is making a seven-figure wealth-building move. If it all pans out, he’ll be one million dollars (or more) richer, with a brand new investment property that’ll spit out $7,000 cash flow monthly! This ... Show More
38m 35s
Jan 2025
How to Make More Passive Income with Fewer Rentals (& ACTUALLY Retire Early) w/Chad Carson
Want to retire early? Then, STOP buying rental properties. You heard that right; buying more rental properties may actually push you further away from early retirement IF you’ve crossed a certain threshold. Today’s guest proves you don’t need dozens of rental properties to reach ... Show More
47m 38s
Oct 2
You Can’t Afford To Be Careless With Money
🤔 ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Think you’re good with money? Take our Money in America quiz!⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Dave Ramsey and Dr. John Delony answer your questions and discuss: "Should I keep cash at my house?" "Should we live close to our parents for a low monthly rent or move further a ... Show More
2h 18m
Aug 7
Lose the Ego, Win With Money
📈⁠⁠ ⁠Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a free personalized plan.⁠⁠⁠ Dave Ramsey and Rachel Cruze answer your questions and discuss: "How can I get my wife on board with the Ramsey plan?" "My tenant isn't paying a plumbing bill, should I pay for it?" "I want to pay off my ... Show More
2h 16m