In January 2023, Ana Walshe, a 39-year-old mother and successful real estate executive, vanished under mysterious circumstances from her home in Cohasset, Massachusetts. Her sudden disappearance sparked an extensive investigation, revealing unsettling details and raising numerous questions about her personal life. As authorities uncovered a series of suspici ... Show More
Jan 30
The Haves and the Have Nots: Inside the Washington D.C. Mansion Murders
When a beloved D.C. power family vanished behind the doors of their mansion, a routine workday spiraled into a nightmare of lies, ransom, and fire. What investigators uncovered inside would expose a meticulously cruel plot—and leave one haunting question that still lingers: did o ... Show More
34m 26s
Jan 23
From Classroom Crush to Contract Killing: Pamela Smart’s Secret
On a quiet New Hampshire street in 1990, a young husband was executed in his own home—what looked like a botched robbery quickly unraveled into something far darker. This episode explores the explosive case of Pamela Smart: a forbidden affair, teenage accomplices, a murder-for-hi ... Show More
1h 1m
Dec 2024
EP104: Silent Night: The Unsolved Mystery of JonBenét Ramsey (Part 1)
Visit Patreon.com/psychopediapod to join our family of freaks and gain access to exclusive content!
At 1:05 PM on December 26, 1996, the body of a beautiful six-year-old girl was found by her father in a dark, frigid basement room of their family home in Boulder, Colorado. Just s ... Show More
1h 25m
Dec 2024
246. What Happened to Mary Day?
In this episode, Payton and Garrett unravel the mysterious case of Mary Day, a teenage girl who vanished after an argument with her parents. As years pass with no sign of her, mounting evidence points to foul play, prompting investigators to seek answers. Just when the case seems ... Show More
45m 23s
Oct 2024
Beneath the Soil
On Monday, June 24th, 2019, 33-year-old Kaylynn Blue failed to show up for her shift at a Walgreens in Idaho Falls, raising concern among her coworkers. Kaylynn had already missed two days—which was highly unusual for her. Worried, they reached out to her family, who soon involve ... Show More
1h 25m
Nov 12
KIDNAPPED: Elizabeth Smart
In 2002, 14 year-old Elizabeth Smart was kidnapped from her Salt Lake City home in the middle of the night, sparking one of America’s most intense true crime investigations. For nine months, she was held captive by a self-proclaimed prophet and his wife: hidden in plain sight. Mo ... Show More
1h 33m
Jul 2025
EP. 208 - TEXAS: The Killing Of 11-Year-Old Audrii Cunningham
In February of 2024, a young girl disappeared in the deep, dark heart of Livingston, Texas. And when the full story was eventually investigated and revealed, the story took a darker turn than the people involved could possibly imagine. In today's episode, we spoke with Cassie Cun ... Show More
1h 37m
Dec 2024
12 Years Old & PREGNANT: Disappearance of Celina Mays
<p>A Pregnant Preteen, A Family Secret & A Religious Cult. </p>
<p> The chilling case of Celina Mays, a 12-year-old girl who vanished without a trace in 1996. At the time of her disappearance, Celina was not only a young teenager but also nine months pregnant, adding even mor ... Show More
34m 28s
Oct 2025
EP 220 - MINNESOTA: The Most Infamous Murder Case In Minnesota History: The Abduction And Murder of Jacob Wetterling
In October of 1989, a young boy went missing from a small town in Minnesota. As time ticked on, and no leads were found, the town, and the nation, grew desperate. However, when the answers to their questions were finally revealed, people were shocked at how their suspect had been ... Show More
2h 4m
Sep 2025
MISSING: Asha Degree
She was smart, cautious, and afraid of strangers. So why did 9-year-old Asha Degree leave her North Carolina home in the middle of the night and vanish forever? Now, 25 years later, Morgan and Kaelyn revisit the key evidence: the missing backpack, a mysterious green car, and a DN ... Show More
1h 17m