logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2024
1h 13m

Ep. 217: 'Defending pornography'

FIRE
About this episode

It is said that censorship is the strongest drive in human nature — with sex being a weak second.

But what happens when these two primordial drives clash? Does censorship or sex win out?

Nadine Strossen is a professor emerita at New York Law School, a former president of the ACLU, and a senior fellow at FIRE. She is also the author of "Defending Pornography: Free Speech, Sex, and the Fight for Women's Rights." First released in 1995, the book was reissued this year with a new preface.

Mary Anne Franks is a law professor at George Washington University and the president and legislative and tech policy director of the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative. She is the author of "The Cult of the Constitution: Our Deadly Devotion to Guns and Free Speech" and the forthcoming "Fearless Speech: Breaking Free from the First Amendment."

Show Notes:

Transcript

Timestamps

0:00 Intro

2:17 Defining pornography

7:20 Is porn protected by the First Amendment?

11:10 Revenge porn

22:05 Origins of "Defending Pornography"

25:06 Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon

29:20 Can porn be consensual?

35:02 Dworkin/MacKinnon model legislation

52:20 Porn in Canada

56:07 Is it possible to ban porn?

1:03:26 College professor's porn hobby

1:12:39 Outro

Up next
Aug 26
Ep. 280: Social media, speech, and kids w/ Joel Thayer and Kate Ruane
**Editor's note: This episode was recorded before Meta settled a social media addiction trial with a coalition of state attorneys general on Aug. 26, 2026. The case alleged the company knew some of its features on Facebook and Instagram could be harmful to kids and the company pu ... Show More
1h 13m
Aug 7
Ep. 279: Legendary lawyer Michael Tigar on juries, free speech, and the trial of John Peter Zenger
Long before the First Amendment, John Peter Zenger stood trial for publishing criticisms of New York's then colonial governor. Although the law seemed to guarantee a guilty verdict, a jury refused to convict him. Zenger's trial was an early indication that the American colonists ... Show More
45m 14s
Jul 29
Ep. 278: The Trump admin wants to change how scientific research is funded w/ Catharine Young, Evan Morris, and Ryne Weiss
In May 2026, the Office of Management and Budget proposed sweeping changes to how the federal government administers billions of dollars in federal research grants. That funding fuels scientific discovery, medical breakthroughs, and technological innovation. The proposal was open ... Show More
59m 58s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2024
Defending Pornography, Hate Speech and the ACLU: Nadine Strossen on The Unspeakable
<p>This week, Meghan talks with legal scholar, former law professor, and legendary free speech advocate Nadine Strossen.</p> <p>Nadine was president of the American Civil Liberties Union from 1991 to 2008 and she's the author of many books, including Defending Pornography, which ... Show More
1h 21m
May 2019
Does Porn Kill Love?
Love and sex are two of the strongest human desires. Robin Basselin and Ryan Geertsma look at a difficult subject: does using pornography hurt relationships?Check out more Spotlight English content at: www.SpotlightEnglish.com 
15m 1s
May 2023
How Much Porn Is Too Much?
How much porn is too much porn? Is all porn bad? This has been a debate in the conservative community recently and I have a lot to say about it. Plus, an Indiana bar pleads for customers to return after telling them they were not welcome for speaking out against the trans Dylan M ... Show More
36m 15s
Sep 2023
Ep. 1215 - We Have To Stop Letting The Porn Industry Hide Behind 'Free Speech'
Today on the Matt Walsh Show, the Left is normally very opposed to free speech in this country. But they do make one exception: pornography. While attacking free speech everywhere else, suddenly they've decided that even the most basic regulations on the porn industry are an unte ... Show More
1h 11m
Mar 2021
Erika Lust: Can porn be feminist?
Porn is one of the biggest drivers of internet traffic and a generator of vast amounts of money, but also an industry in a state of flux. The biggest online porn platforms have been accused of profiting from criminality and abuse. Stephen Sackur interviews Erika Lust - pornograph ... Show More
22m 58s
Aug 2021
The Right to Sex, with Amia Srinivasan and Merve Emre
How should we talk about sex? It is a thing we have and also a thing we do; a supposedly private act laden with public meaning; a personal preference shaped by outside forces; a place where pleasure and ethics can pull wildly apart. In this week's episode Amia Srinivasan speaks t ... Show More
30m 39s
Feb 2024
Women watch porn too - so why can’t we talk about it?
A quarter of people watching pornography are women, but why do we find it hard to comprehend? We speak to the author of a new book who has interviewed one hundred women about their porn habits - what can we learn about women’s pleasure? This podcast was brought to you thanks to t ... Show More
26m 17s