logo
episode-header-image
May 2024
1h 16m

216: The Wellnitz Family Murders

Erica Kelley
About this episode
For nearly a decade, the Wellnitz family murders haunted the small town of Columbia, Kentucky. The tight knit community had no clue why these good people were mercilessly executed in their own home. They were known for their thriving veterinary clinic and their kind hearts. But someone had been viciously murdered the family and even though investigators were pretty sure they knew who did it, the case went cold. It took ten years and heroic undercover work to get justice for the Wellnitz family. 

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley 
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank 
Additional writing by Erica Kelley
Edited and Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner 
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio 
Suggested by Dana Schmidt

Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/wellnitz-family

This episode is brought to you by:  
  • Visit SimpliSafe.com/southernfried to get 20% off any new system with Fast Protect Monitoring. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
  • Get the confidence of smelling great from your pits to your feet: try Lume, the whole body deodorant. Go to LumeDeodorant.com and enter code SFTC for 15% off your order. 
  • Treat yourself to the best bras and shapewear on the market and save 20% off at honeylove.com/SFTC.
  • Füm: Start the Good Habit at tryfum.com/sftc to save 10% off the Journey Pack today. Don’t panic, it’s botanic!
  • Download the Teladoc Health app today, or go to TelaDocHealth.com, to schedule your next doctor’s appointment. Don’t pull the covers over your head, your health is too important!
  • This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Get it off your chest and try online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/SOUTHERN. 
Up next
Oct 2024
The Best of October Southern Fried: 2022, Ep167: The Murder of Fred Jablin
Today's episode is a "best of October" Southern Fried is from 2022, 167: The Murder of Fred Jablin Dr. Fred Jablin, a highly regarded professor of communication, was a dedicated husband to his wife, Piper Rountree. For years, he did everything in his power to make her happy, but ... Show More
1h 19m
Jul 2024
The Disappearance & Murder of Emily Anderson - Part 1 of 2
The last time anyone saw 49-year-old Emily Anderson was December 29, 2005. As husband, Jerry Anderson was naturally the first suspect. But he seemed to be able to account for his time that day and he passed a polygraph. After an anonymous call, Emily’s body was discovered on Janu ... Show More
52m 8s
Jul 2024
Introducing Gone Cold – Texas True Crime
Texas is known for being tough on crime and those who commit it. Or at least the ones who get caught. There are tens of thousands of unsolved homicides in Texas and nearly as many open missing persons cases. Every week, Gone Cold Podcast—Texas true crime—presents in-depth account ... Show More
8m 39s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
The Bedside Murders /// Part 1 /// 773
<p>The Bedside Murders /// Part 1 /// 773</p><p><br />Part 1 of 2 <br /><br />www.TrueCrimeGarage.com </p><p><br />Sometime between the waning hours of October 13th and the dawning of October 14th a young mother and her grandmother were viciously beaten and strangled.  The night ... Show More
45m 35s
Jul 2024
The Bedside Murders /// Part 2 /// 774
<p>The Bedside Murders /// Part 2 /// 774</p><p><br />Part 2 of 2 <br /><br />www.TrueCrimeGarage.com </p><p><br />Sometime between the waning hours of October 13th and the dawning of October 14th a young mother and her grandmother were viciously beaten and strangled.  The night ... Show More
1 h
Apr 2025
Who Killed Emily Pike? No More Stolen Sisters
<div>On February 14th, 2025, 14-year-old Emily Pike’s dismembered body was found in garbage bags in a remote part of an Arizonan forest. This discovery came about three weeks after she had gone missing. Not only was this a horrible crime committed against a child, but Emily was a ... Show More
1 h
Aug 21
448: The Murder of Hadas Winnick (from "I'm Related to a Killer")
<div>On September 25, 2007, 22-year-old Amy Winnick left her job near Calabasas, California, and headed home. Her cell phone rang. It was was her 25-year-old brother Jesse. "Don't go home," he told her. And then he said "I just killed Mom," and then he hung up. This unimaginable ... Show More
48m 32s
Jun 2025
314. The Murder of Emma Compton: Crime, Control, and the Hidden Struggles of Strong Women | lovelustfridays x Big Mad True Crime x Critical Incidents
In this episode of lovelustfridays, hosts Jake Deptula and Michele Locke, alongside producer Haley Gray, are joined by Heather Ashley of Big Mad True Crime and Kyle Ashley from Critical Incidents to discuss the tragic story of Emma Compton. They explore the harsh realities of dom ... Show More
1h 37m
Feb 2025
Episode 309 - A Murder in the Walls: The Haunting of the Foley House Inn
This Valentine's Day, prepare yourself for a twisted love story that will leave you questioning what's truly buried in the past. In this chilling episode, we dive into the eerie history of Savannah’s first bed and breakfast, the Foley House Inn, where a deadly obsession leads to ... Show More
58m 27s
Oct 17
S3 Ep350: Murder on the Eve of Halloween | The Killing of Dr. Jablin (Part 1)
<div>Just after sunrise on October 30, 2004, police in a Richmond, Virginia suburb responded after a neighbor walking his dogs discovered the body of 52-year-old University of Richmond professor Dr. Fred Jablin lying in his driveway. He’d been shot multiple times as he went outsi ... Show More
1h 9m
Jun 2022
Lured - The Lululemon Murder
On the morning of March 12, 2011, Rachel Oertli arrived to work at LuLuLemon, an athleisure store located in Bethesda, Maryland where she was the store Manager. From the moment she opened the unlocked door she knew something was terribly wrong. The store was in complete disarray ... Show More
39m 25s
Oct 12
Episode 287 - Who the Hell is Jim McIntyre? - The Murder of Mindi Kassotis
<div>The Airbnb in Savannah, Georgia was just one more stop in a long line of temporary homes. Their 50th rental since they’d started running, maybe their 60th. By then, Nicholas Kassotis had stopped keeping count.<br> <br> What mattered wasn’t the number. It was survival. Stayin ... Show More
58m 26s
Nov 2024
348: Moody Massacre (Scott Moody)
In the early morning hours of Sunday, May 29th, 2005, shots rang out from the Shaker Farm in Bellefontaine, Ohio. Nikki Vagades received a call from her 15-year-old step sister, begging for help. When Nikki arrived at the farmhouse, she immediately called 911. Detectives arrived ... Show More
58m 16s