logo
episode-header-image
May 2024
46m 10s

Noah Presgrove // 407

Dark West Productions
About this episode

In September of 2023, a 19-year-old man allegedly left a friend’s birthday party after a weekend of fun in Oklahoma. But when someone stumbled upon his body on the side of the road in the early morning hours, brutally killed, numerous police organizations jumped in the help. With everyone at the party keeping quiet about the evening, and deleting all video and photo proof of the night, everyone is left to wonder: What are they hiding? This is the story of Noah Presgrove.

Up next
Yesterday
Simeonette Mapes-Crupi // 519
In July of 2012, a beloved high school teacher was found murdered inside her Staten Island home. Although it was initially believed to be a home invasion gone wrong, the scene left behind raised immediate questions with investigators. And a daunting four-month investigation would ... Show More
48m 54s
Jul 8
The Hiding Man: Anatomy of a Serial Killer // 518
Serial killers are not just the stuff of horror movies or thriller novels. They walk among us, hidden in plain sight, sometimes quiet, sometimes charming, almost always disarmingly ordinary. But what turns a human being into a hunter of humans? How do they emerge? And more import ... Show More
1h 1m
Jul 4
Sade Robinson // 517
In April of 2024, a 19-year-old student vanished after heading out for a promising first date in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. But hours later, her torched car was found in another part of the city, and later that day, dismembered body parts began popping up along the coastline… Although ... Show More
1h 5m
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2022
Introducing: Very Scary People
After Ron DeFeo Jr. finds his parents and younger siblings dead in their Amityville, New York, home, police begin to search for the killer. Host Donnie Wahlberg and local journalist Joel Martin revisit that horrific evening in 1974, the crime scene and the investigation — all in ... Show More
31m 43s
Apr 2023
Road Trip to Murder
What started out as the cross-country road trip of a lifetime for 29-year-old Philip Reagan and his 39-year-old brother Matthew ended in tragedy just a day later when their bodies were discovered on a remote road on the Navajo Nation in Arizona. Authorities believe it was a tragi ... Show More
35m 18s
Jun 2022
Murder in Boystown
In 2004, 31-year-old Kevin Clewer goes out for a night on the town in an area near Chicago called “Boystown.” The next day, his father finds him dead in his apartment--he has been stabbed over 40 times. New developments in the case have led investigators to focus on a possible su ... Show More
39m 58s
Mar 2021
1. The Killing Zone
After Tristan Beaudette’s murder, other victims come forward telling similar tales. . . of a sniper in Malibu who has been shooting at campers and at moving cars for the past 18 months. Always in the dark of night, at 4AM.The cops say they can’t connect the crimes, but then they ... Show More
37m 48s
Jun 2023
Ep. 2: The Aftermath
Nearly eight hours after the murders, police receive a 911 call from the King Road house. Why the delay? Who discovers the murder scene and what do they see? Police don’t offer many answers initially, except to say they believe the murders were “targeted,” and that the community ... Show More
38m 51s
Feb 2023
Body in Cedar Creek
Tyler Smith is just weeks away from realizing his dream of becoming a police officer when he is found dead, face down in a drainage ditch in Galesburg, IL. Local police say the 23-year-old National Guardsman passed out and drowned, but his parents believe Tyler was murdered, and ... Show More
37m 2s
Feb 2023
#239: The Whole High School Covered For A Killer For 20 Years- Case of Melanie Paquette
The 20 year high school reunion was a big deal for these friends. They had all grown up, started their own families, but one thing has always united them. Their oath of silence. Their oath of protection.Everyone sat down at their seats but their smiles quickly faded once they saw ... Show More
1h 19m