logo
episode-header-image
May 2024
43m 37s

114: Book vs. Big Screen: 3 Body Problem...

Neil Soni, Nat Eliason, and Adil Majid
About this episode

"But if science tells you that something’s impossible, and it happens anyway, it means one of two things. Either the science is wrong, or it’s a scam.”

Welcome back to another episode of Made You Think! Today, we're exploring the 3 Body Problem TV series on Netflix, inspired by Cixin Liu's acclaimed novel. Listen in as we discuss Season 1's adaptation from book to screen, analyzing character shifts, narrative changes, and the portrayal of scientific concepts. If you enjoyed The Three-Body Problem book series or consider yourself a sci-fi fanatic, this one is for you!

We cover a wide range of topics including:

  • What narrative changes and expansions were made for the TV adaptation
  • The show's production costs compared to Game of Thrones
  • How the creators translated the scientific aspects from the book series
  • Our main praises and critiques of the show
  • Book or series - is there a clear winner?

And much more. Please enjoy, and make sure to follow NatNeil, and Adil on Twitter and share your thoughts on the episode.

Links from the Episode:

Mentioned in the Show:

Books Mentioned:

People Mentioned:

Show Topics:

(0:31) Welcome to our first TV show episode! Today, we’re covering the TV series based on one of our previous reads, The Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu. Go check out the episode on the book if you haven't already! We dive into our overall thoughts on Season 1 and how it measured up to the book.

(4:09) *Spoiler alert!* If you haven’t watched the show or read the book series, we suggest you do that first before continuing this episode. We talk a bit about the depth, or lack of depth, of the characters in the book and TV series.

(6:55) Neil talks about the pivotal scene in Episode 5 that changed his mind about the show, and how the shows portrayal of something can be completely different than what you had pictured in your head.

(9:38) From character shifts to the order of events, how did the show differ from the book series? 

(13:48) How the creators of the show had a unique challenge of keeping the intriguing scientific elements from the book series in the show while maintaining a pace that keeps the viewers interested.

(15:43) The cost per episode in 3BP was higher than the final season of Game of Thrones. Which aspects of the show and scenes may have taken up the largest pieces of the budget?

(21:24) We talk about the relationships between the heroes of the books and how they're all close friends. It sets you up to think there might be a happy ending... but is there?

(25:36) Nat, Neil, and Adil share their thoughts on a character addition that wasn't in the books. 

(28:45) From Blood Meridian to The First World War, many books have some grotesque elements to it. It's interesting to see how authors capture the emotions and events from something that actually happened and put them into a book. 

(32:55) Our thoughts on the scene where the universe blinks, and how it was shown in the movie vs. in the book. 

(34:50) We list off one major criticism of the show, as well as many things that we felt the producers did a great job on.

(39:03) How effective was the show in portraying scientific aspects from the book? We share our final thoughts 3BP Season 1.

(42:10) That concludes this episode! Make sure to check out our episode on The Three-Body Problem and check out the Netflix series if you haven’t already. We highly recommend it! Next up is Einstein’s Dreams by Alan Lightman. Pick up a copy of the book and read along with us!

If you enjoyed this episode, let us know by leaving a review on iTunes and tell a friend. As always, let us know if you have any book recommendations! You can say hi to us on Twitter @TheRealNeilS@adilmajid@nateliason and share your thoughts on this episode.

You can now support Made You Think using the Value-for-Value feature of Podcasting 2.0. This means you can directly tip the co-hosts in BTC with minimal transaction fees. To get started, simply download a podcast app (like Fountain or Breez) that supports Value-for-Value and send some BTC to your in-app wallet. You can then use that to support shows who have opted-in, including Made You Think! We’ll be going with this direct support model moving forward, rather than ads.

Thanks for listening. See you next time!

Up next
Jun 24
121: The Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect
“Prime Intellect was an uncertain god. It had acted because it had to, but if it had been human its hand would be shaking on the controls.” Welcome back to another episode of Made You Think! This episode dives into The Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect by Roger Williams, a soft sc ... Show More
1h 5m
May 20
120: Wired To Heal: Regeneration and The Body Electric
“The greatest polluting element in the earth's environment is the proliferation of electromagnetic fields. I consider that to be a far greater threat on a global scale than warming, or the increase of chemical elements in the environment.” Welcome back to another episode of Made ... Show More
57m 47s
Dec 2024
119: Surviving Against All Odds: Endurance by Alfred Lansing
“In that instant they felt an overwhelming sense of pride and accomplishment. Though they had failed dismally even to come close to the expedition's original objective, they knew now that somehow they had done much, much more than ever they set out to do.” Welcome back to another ... Show More
1h 36m
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2023
Season 5, Episode 27: Popcorn Reading + Joys and Challenges of Reading as Our "Job"
On this week’s episode of Currently Reading, Meredith and Kaytee are discussing: Bookish Moments: a meeting with an app and a personal audiobook win Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: we’ve been asked how it affec ... Show More
52m 40s
Jun 2024
Season 6, Episode 43: Meeting Bookish Friends + Starting New Books
On this episode of Currently Reading, Meredith and Roxanna are discussing: Bookish Moments: meeting bookish friends and “salt” books Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: difficulty in starting new books The Fountain ... Show More
1h 11m
Mar 2024
Entering the 3 Body Problem world & China’s Cultural Revolution
Hosts Dr. Maggie Aderin-Pocock and Jason Concepcion dive headfirst into Netflix’s 3 Body Problem, as they share their reactions to the opening episodes and welcome their first guests. Jason sits down with 3 Body Problem’s award-winning showrunners Alexander Woo (True Blood), Davi ... Show More
51 m
May 2013
S3 Ep13: A Cast of Kings Bonus Ep. – Spoilers Galore (GUEST: Myles McNutt from Cultural Learnings)
Joanna is joined by TV critic Myles McNutt for a very special SPOILER episode of A Cast Of Kings.  If there is anythingyou’re worried about having spoiled, do yourself a favor and skip this episode.  We’ve got book spoilers and we’ve got show spoilers.  If you’re only partway thr ... Show More
1h 15m
Apr 2023
Season 5, Episode 34: Many Generations of Readers + No-Prep Current Reads
On this week’s episode of Currently Reading, Meredith and Kaytee are discussing: Bookish Moments: the generations after us and before us in our reading lives Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: what did we learn fr ... Show More
1h 6m
May 2023
Season 5, Episode 41: Summer Reading + Book Hangovers
On this week’s episode of Currently Reading, Meredith and Kaytee are discussing: Bookish Moments: summer reading guides and plane reading Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: we are chatting about the dreaded book h ... Show More
53m 43s
Jun 2023
Season 5, Episode 44: Your Homework + Literary Festival Tips and Tricks
On this week’s episode of Currently Reading, Kaytee and Meredith are discussing: Bookish Moments: a summer reading conundrum, and a box full of galleys Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: best practices and encoura ... Show More
57m 3s
Nov 2018
“Gods of Thrones” – “Fire and Blood” Initial Thoughts
Anthony and I talk about GRRM’s latest book, Fire and Blood, which is a complete and in-depth historical account of the 300 year old Targaryen dynasty in Westeros. We discuss our initial thoughts, anything that might have changed some of our thoughts in Gods of Thrones, any intri ... Show More
1h 25m
Jun 2023
Season 5, Episode 43: Way Past a Book Hangover + All Things Fourth Wing
On this week’s episode of Currently Reading, Meredith and Roxanna are discussing: Bookish Moments: even worse than a book hangover, it’s a book coma!, and single-track reading Current Reads: all the great, interesting, and/or terrible stuff we’ve been reading lately Deep Dive: It ... Show More
1h 5m
Oct 2022
About Change, TV Series & A Book | عن التغيير و مسلسلات و كتاب
In this episode I share my thoughts on "change" and the pressure of wanting to change but feeling guilty of that change. And how society pressure can truly leave a negative impact on your life. I also share my thoughts on few shows I have watched on Netflix titled "28 days haunte ... Show More
41m 28s