logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2024
1h 6m

Ep. 213: Campus unrest - live webinar

FIRE
About this episode

Host Nico Perrino joins his FIRE colleagues Will Creeley and Alex Morey to answer questions about the recent campus unrest and its First Amendment implications. 

 

Timestamps

 

0:00 Introduction 

0:41 What is FIRE?/campus unrest

5:44 What are the basic First Amendment principles for campus protest?

11:30 Student encampments 

18:09 Exceptions to the First Amendment

29:01 Can administrators limit access to non-students/faculty?

34:13 Denying recognition to Students for Justice in Palestine

36:26 Were protesters at UT Austin doing anything illegal?

40:54 The USC valedictorian 

45:09 What does “objectively offensive” mean? / Does Davis apply to colleges?

46:55 Is it illegal to protest too loudly?

50:03 What options do colleges have to moderate/address hate speech?

54:20 Does calling for genocide constitute bullying/harassment?

59:09 Wrapping up on the situation 

 

Show Notes

 

USC canceling valedictorian’s commencement speech looks like calculated censorship,” Alex Morey

Emerson College: Conservative Student Group Investigated for Distributing ‘China Kinda Sus’ Stickers,” FIRE’s case files

HATE: Why We Should Resist it With Free Speech, Not Censorship,” Nadine Strossen

Defending My Enemy: American Nazis, the Skokie Case, and the Risks of Freedom,” Aryeh Neier (pdf)

David Goldberger, lead attorney in ‘the Skokie case,’” “So to Speak” Ep. 118

Transcript

Up next
Aug 12
Ep. 249: FIRE Reacts — Where does Harvard go from here? With Larry Summers
2025 has not been kind to Harvard. To date, the Trump administration has revoked nearly $3 billion in research funding to the university, demanding violations of free speech, academic freedom, and institutional autonomy in return for restoring the funding. In response, Harvard fi ... Show More
1h 8m
Aug 6
Ep. 248: Commercial speech and the First Amendment
Imagine the government forcing you to label your all-natural milk product as “imitation.” Florida tried to make one dairy farm do just that, sparking a First Amendment question: Where’s the line between a business’s right to speak and protecting consumers from deception? In this ... Show More
50m 42s
Jul 24
Ep. 247: Justin Amash
Throughout his career, former Congressman Justin Amash has been a strong advocate for freedom of speech, writing that “The value of free speech comes from encountering views that are unorthodox, uncommon, or unaccepted…Free speech is a barren concept if people are limited to expr ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2023
The Free Speech Wars on Campus
Between student protests, controversial speakers, and debates over “safe spaces,” complaints about free speech on campus are louder than ever. How do school leaders respond to these gripes? And how do they balance freedom of expression – and the idea that speech can be violence?  ... Show More
33m 30s
May 2024
The Campus Protesters Explain Themselves
This episode contains explicit language. Over recent months, protests over the war in Gaza have rocked college campuses across the United States. As students graduate and go home for the summer, three joined “The Daily” to discuss why they got involved, what they wanted to say an ... Show More
50m 12s
Dec 2023
Anti-Semitism and academic freedom: what’s happening on US college campuses?
The viral clip of Harvard President Dr. Claudine Gay - unable to condemn those on campus calling for genocide - has kicked off a wider debate about academic freedom and double standards. The president of University of Pennsylvania - who offered similar responses - has now resigne ... Show More
32m 16s
May 2024
‘Student revolution’: US protesters vow to continue despite crackdown
More than 1,000 people have been arrested in crackdowns on university protests across the United States. Facing police brutality, arrests, and attacks from counter-protesters, what will student protesters do next?  In this episode:  Dalia Darazim (@columbiasjp), Student at Columb ... Show More
19m 22s
May 2024
TAMARA RASAMNY - A Global Stand for Gaza (Ep.404)
A conversation with Tamara Rasamny - MA at Columbia University's Climate School. A look at the student encampment at Columbia University in support of Gaza, the wider meaning of a global movement demanding justice and freedom for Palestine, Tamara's own detainment during the poli ... Show More
40m 24s
Apr 2024
Outrage at Columbia University
The White House has condemned what it calls “blatantly antisemitic” statements at student protests against the war in Gaza.Fractious demonstrations at Columbia University in New York have rumbled on for six days, while arrests have been made at other major colleges including Yale ... Show More
35m 34s
May 2024
Why campus protests worsen divisions, and how to mediate: Advice from Eboo Patel
On this episode of the GZERO World Podcast with Ian Bremmer, Eboo Patel, founder of Interfaith America, advocates for cooperation over division on college campuses in response to protests, highlighting the need for civil discourse and pointing out that despite some instances of v ... Show More
27m 34s
Jan 2022
218. Free Speech and Cambridge | James Orr and Arif Ahmed
As an alternative for those who would rather listen ad-free, sign up for a premium subscription to receive the following: • All JBP Podcast episodes are ad-free.• Monthly Ask Me Anything episodes (and the ability to ask questions).• Presale access to events.• Premium, detailed sh ... Show More
1h 24m
Dec 2023
Antisemitism and Free Speech Collide on Campuses
Warning: this episode contains strong language.Universities across the country strained under pressure to take a public position on the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by Hamas.Nicholas Confessore, a political and investigative reporter for The Times, explains the story behind a congress ... Show More
30m 48s