logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2024
38m 36s

Sir Alex or Pep? Carragher or Neville? P...

The Overlap
About this episode

Welcome back to the Fan Debate, brought to you by SkyBet, with Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher alongside some of the biggest fan channels from across the country.


This time it's the fans' turn to ask the questions, and we have a new voting system using our Fan Debate paddles.


00:46 Fans ask the questions!

00:15 Toney or Watkins for England?

03:15 Do Luton deserve to stay up?

05:15 Would the PL be fairer if the Super League teams left?

11:18 Do Arsenal over-celebrate late winners?

15:08 What does success/failure look like for Man City?

17:37 Should West Ham stick with David Moyes?

18:32 If United and Liverpool could have one player from each squad who would you pick?

22:52 Can Postecoglou win a big trophy playing his way?

24:09 What would be success for England at EURO 2024?

26:09 What would be a success for Klopp in his final season?

28:17 Quick fire questions with paddles

28:38 If Arsenal don't win a trophy will it still be a successful season?

28:51 City & Liverpool is a better rivalry than United & Arsenal?

30:51 Harry Kane should have stayed at Spurs?

31:01 Would Carra would get into the current Liverpool squad?

31:30 Would Gary make the current United XI?

32:04 Would you scrap VAR completely?

32:19 When Pep leaves City will he be classed as the GOAT?

34:32 Is winning the UCL bigger than the PL?

37:55 Who is the better pundit Gary or Jamie?


SUBSCRIBE TO THE CHANNEL HERE

https://www.youtube.com/c/theoverlap?sub_confirmation=1


LISTEN TO OUR PODCASTS

Stick to Football - https://tr.ee/JI6l3Dj-4O

The Overlap - https://tr.ee/h07F3Fsuh3


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Aug 18
Daniel Levy: Ange, Thomas Frank & The Future of Tottenham | The Overlap Exclusive
On this episode of The Overlap, brought to you by Sky Bet, we are hosted at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium by Daniel Levy ahead of his 25th year as club chairman. He takes us on an in-depth tour, showcasing the stadium’s unique features while discussing the club’s key decisions, c ... Show More
35m 24s
Aug 8
Sesko to United, Man City Charges & Son’s Legacy Bigger Than Kane? | Fan Debate Part 2
The Premier League is almost here and Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes are back with Part 2 of our Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet and this one gets lively. We kick things off with Manchester City as fans discuss Pep Guardiola’s trophyless season and the latest on the 115 ch ... Show More
1h 16m
Aug 6
Isak to Liverpool? Gyokeres' Arsenal Impact & Can Chelsea Challenge?
Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes return alongside our Premier League fans to kick off the 2025/26 season preview, brought to you by Sky Bet.If your club isn’t featured, don’t worry, part two of our season preview drops later this week.We open with a heartfelt tribute to Diogo Jot ... Show More
59m 38s
Recommended Episodes
May 8
Arsenal Backtracking & Europa Still Failure for United? | Stick to Football 82
Welcome to another episode of Stick to Football, brought to you by Sky Bet with Gary Neville, Roy Keane, Jill Scott, Ian Wright and Paul Scholes.The panel discuss Arsenal’s Champions League and Premier League campaign and whether their results this season signal progress or a ste ... Show More
1h 5m
May 2021
Liverpool.com podcast: What all-English Champions League final means for Liverpool
In the week that both Chelsea and Manchester City reached the Champions League final, what does that mean for next season and for Liverpool? Will both clubs be in contention for the Premier League title - and what would it take for Liverpool to join them? Host Dan Morgan is joine ... Show More
45m 22s
Oct 2024
Liverpool to make Arsenal statement, Tuchel media coverage and Howe under pressure? | Three Up Front
Football writer Henry Winter joins Simon Jordan and Graeme Souness to discuss Liverpool, Arsenal, Newcastle and the media’s reaction to Thomas’s Tuchel’s appointment as England head coach.They debate whether Liverpool are the real deal this season: Henry reveals what the players ... Show More
47m 50s
Apr 2025
Peter Crouch | Delap or Osimhen for Man Utd? Where should Isak go? KDB or Gerrard?
Peter Crouch joins Rio and Joel to discuss Liverpool’s Premier League title win after they beat Spurs at Anfield. According to Rio, Crouchy gives the BEST explanation of why Liverpool supporters are responding differently to the possibility of Trent Alexander Arnold leaving the c ... Show More
1 h
Apr 2025
'I'm getting really ANGRY!' | Nev's passionate football 'freedom' rant after Old Trafford stalemate
Gary Neville is joined by Peter Drury at Old Trafford to react to Manchester United's goalless draw against Manchester City. The pair also discuss Kevin De Bruyne's Premier League legacy and talk through Liverpool's dissapointing defeat to Fulham, with Neville admitting that Arne ... Show More
20m 21s
Feb 2025
Salah stars as Liverpool ease past Man City | Nev reacts to Slot's side going 11 points clear at the top of the Premier League
Gary Neville is joined by Peter Drury to react to Liverpool's 2-0 victory against Manchester City at The Etihad. Neville believes Liverpool might have one hand on the Premier League trophy following their comfortable display.  The pair also discuss Arsenal's disspointing defeat t ... Show More
17m 23s
Oct 2024
Three Up Front: Liverpool to make Arsenal statement, Tuchel media coverage and Howe under pressure?
Football writer Henry Winter joins Simon Jordan and Graeme Souness to discuss Liverpool, Arsenal, Newcastle and the media’s reaction to Thomas’s Tuchel’s appointment as England head coach. They debate whether Liverpool are the real deal this season: Henry reveals what the players ... Show More
47m 49s
Apr 2025
Man Utd vs Man City: Super Sunday derby stalemate exposes both sides' flaws
David Jones is joined by Roy Keane, Micah Richards, Gary Neville and Izzy Christiansen to review the action from Old Trafford as Manchester Utd and Manchester City played out a drab derby draw. Hear from Manchester Utd manager Ruben Amorim and the Manchester City boss Pep Guardio ... Show More
55m 26s
Sep 2024
Jamie Carragher: Everton Fan to Liverpool Legend! | Stick to Football EP 49
Welcome back to Stick to Football, brought to you by SkyBet. In today's special guest episode, we have none other than our very own Jamie Carragher in the spotlight. Joining him are former England teammates Gary Neville and Paul Scholes, along with Roy Keane and Ian Wright, as th ... Show More
55m 59s