logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2024
30m 48s

CHAPTER EIGHT: The Trouble Closer to Hom...

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

Soon after Steve started texting with his biological mother, he discovered he had a sister named Amy, a school bus driver in Virginia. At this point, Steve wanted to get to know Amy, who’d grown up under Sandi’s roof. He was curious about her childhood, the road he hadn't taken. But he wasn’t so sure he wanted to know their mother. In this episode, Todd discovers the trauma that shot through Steve’s birth family was worse than he could have ever imagined.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Apr 2024
CHAPTER NINE: Finding his Father
A lot of relatives on Sandi’s side came out of the woodwork after Steve found his biological mother. Some of his long-lost relatives on his maternal side he let in, some he kept at arm’s length. In this episode, Todd goes to a family get-together to spend time with Steve’s half-s ... Show More
26m 49s
Apr 2024
CHAPTER TEN: The Reunion
In our season finale, Steve’s sisters roadtrip to his hometown to see him. Their stay in Cherryville and a surprise guest ends up unraveling the goodwill between Steve’s new relatives and his longstanding ones. Todd grapples with his involvement with the family and realizes that ... Show More
38m 12s
Apr 2024
CHAPTER ELEVEN: This One’s for Todd
In our first bonus episode, we try to make sense of an unimaginable loss. In early January 2024, our “Hello, John Doe” host Todd Matthews died, suddenly. This episode memorializes Todd, a pioneer and an original. We couldn’t let him go to the other side of the veil without a prop ... Show More
31m 22s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
Replay: Brenda Sue Davidson
<p>This episode originally aired on September 12, 2018.</p><p>13-year-old Brenda Sue Davidson disappeared from Woodbridge, Virginia, on March 4, 1974. Her little sister, Lisa, was just seven at the time. She grew up believing that Brenda ran away. When Lisa grew up, she decided t ... Show More
45m 30s
Feb 2025
Roberta Michels-Hopkins
<p>In February of 1981, Roberta Michels-Hopkins, a 29-year-old mother of two, disappeared from Camden, New Jersey, without a trace. The story goes that she left her home, heading out to buy a pack of cigarettes, and never returned. Roberta's sister said she received a phone call ... Show More
1h 6m
Aug 2025
The Disappearance of Michael Madore (Maine)
<p>When Michael Madore vanished almost 30 years ago, the first theories of his disappearance were pulled from letters found at his house: he was supposedly leaving behind his home and belongings and dogs to start a new life in Alaska. That’s the story police in Milo, Maine, first ... Show More
38m 44s
Oct 2024
Cameron Sequeira Part 1: Missing on the Mountain
<p>It was late June 2010 when 32-year-old Cameron Sequeira disappeared from Forest Lakes, Arizona. The story goes that Cameron left his young daughter with one of his girlfriend's relatives and then went for a walk with his beloved dog, Zero. Zero returned a couple of days later, ... Show More
58m 29s
Oct 2022
1. A Child is Missing
For more than 20 years the case of the murder of six-year-old Rikki Neave went unsolved. In this new ten part investigation, award-winning journalist Winifred Robinson, has unearthed the truth through unprecedented access to police interview rooms, and follows the investigation a ... Show More
19m 53s
Apr 2025
Brian Laundrie Is Alive? His Confession Note For Killing Fiance Similar To Famous Horror Novel
tail spinning
1h 47m
Oct 2024
61: MISSING: Gabriel Johnson
On December 20th, 2009, Logan McQueary was supposed to gain physical custody of his nearly eight month old son, Gabriel. But when Logan arrived to pick him up, both he and Gabriel's mother, Elizabeth Johnson, weren't home. For days, Logan tried contacting Elizabeth, but she didn' ... Show More
38m 2s
Sep 2025
Episode 1167: Missing child not seen for three years may have been killed and hidden
Police are hunting for a second young child discovered to have been missing for years after a woman told social workers he had been killed.The child, who would now be seven years old, hasn’t been seen since he was three and his disappearance was only reported on the anniversary o ... Show More
13m 14s
Jan 2025
Steve Pankey
<p>Steve Pankey was a husband, father, car salesman, and Idaho gubernatorial candidate. He was recently convicted of murdering 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews, bringing closure to a case that had been cold for decades.&nbsp;</p><p>Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Steve Pankey and ... Show More
1h 5m
Jan 2022
S3 E1 Vanished
In this episode you will hear the voice of Michael Dunahee himself. Michael's parents Bruce & Crystal Dunahee shared home video with Producer Laura Palmer. Felicia Bernier was one of Michael's little chums. She describes her friend Michael through the lens of a childhood playmate ... Show More
39m 18s