logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2024
31m 37s

CHAPTER THREE: Sandi

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

The answers to what happened to Steve as an infant were only a car ride away. In this episode, Todd visits with Steve’s biological mother Sandi to find out why she let him go. In the 1960s, Sandi fled her overbearing parents the best way she knew how: she married a man she didn’t love at 18, stepping into an unpredictable world. She kept falling for all of the wrong men. Until she met one who wasn’t just a bad match, he was a vulture who preyed on her children.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Apr 2024
CHAPTER THIRTEEN: Mark Yancey On Floyd's Trial
How was Franklin Floyd able to evade justice and hide from authorities for so long? In this second bonus episode, we spoke with Mark Yancey who prosecuted Floyd for the kidnapping charge that finally put him behind bars. Yancey also explained how Floyd ended up on death row in th ... Show More
23m 32s
Apr 2024
CHAPTER TWELVE: Dr. Amanda Baden On Adoption
Only finding out as an adult that you were adopted can throw you into a tailspin, forcing you to reconsider long-held truths. In this bonus episode, we hear from Dr. Amanda Baden, an expert on the experiences of late discovery adoptees. Research has shown the later an adoptee fin ... Show More
24m 34s
Apr 2024
CHAPTER ELEVEN: This One’s for Todd
In our first bonus episode, we try to make sense of an unimaginable loss. In early January 2024, our “Hello, John Doe” host Todd Matthews died, suddenly. This episode memorializes Todd, a pioneer and an original. We couldn’t let him go to the other side of the veil without a prop ... Show More
31m 22s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2023
74. Everyone she hates mysteriously dies, and she can’t remember parts of her day
Sani found out that her dad wasn’t actually dead. Well, he was now. But he just died. He didn’t die when she was 5 years old like her mom had said. For 20 years, Sani believed that her dad was dead, but he had been a very healthy folklore professor at a local college.  That’s how ... Show More
1h 27m
Apr 2022
S1: E2 - The Aftermath
Through his social media and texts, Jenifer learns devastating details about her husband’s double life. The arrest was the tip of the iceberg. She was living with and loving a man with addictions, fantasies, and predilections he kept hidden the entire time they were together. She ... Show More
27m 31s
May 2023
S2: Betrayal Season 2 Trailer
Ashley Lytton was a typical mom and wife in suburban Utah with three children until she discovered her husband’s horrifying secret. It was a shocking crime that would alter Ashley’s life and jeopardize the safety of her children. This season of Betrayal will focus on one mother’s ... Show More
2m 5s
May 2024
#355: Man Kept A 9-Year-Old Girl In His Room For 10 Years Without His Mom Noticing
That was it. He was going to kill her. Sato, a bachelor, a young man who still lived with his mother terrorized her within the walls of her own home.Sure, she could still go out, enjoy her life, but Sato had control over the household in a way that made her feel suffocated. Trapp ... Show More
47m 6s
Sep 2021
46. Amanda & Lily Levitt Share What It’s Like to be Steve’s Daughters
Steve shows a different side of himself in very personal interviews with his two oldest daughters. Amanda talks about growing up with social anxiety and her decision to not go to college, while Lily speaks candidly about her battle with anorexia and the conversation she had with ... Show More
47m 53s
May 2021
Secret Garden
As a kid, Liza Rodman spent her summers in Provincetown, trying her best to stay out of her volatile mother’s way. Her favorite escape: running errands with family friend Tony, who soon became her de facto babysitter. One summer, Tony stopped coming around—something Liza didn’t q ... Show More
35m 34s
Nov 2021
#114: The Creepy Father In Law Diaries (Case of Susan & Josh Powell)
He wrote in his diary everyday about his love and desire for Susan.He took hundreds of pictures of Susan - of her getting dressed, eating cereal, using the restroom, even shopping at Costco.Her husband was no good for her. They were not in love. Not like the way he and Susan were ... Show More
1h 38m
Dec 2023
#320: Twin Police officers accused of “inappropriate relationship” with 15-yr-old girl, later found dead while pregnant
It’s normal to cringe when you think back to your middle school crush. Jane hated thinking about Robert. She had an obsession with him when she was 12 years old. She remembered everyone in the class would fight over him, try to get alone time with him, and he seemed to love all t ... Show More
1h 32m