logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2024
44m 8s

How Usher, Beyoncé, and Taylor Swift Bui...

The New Yorker
About this episode

At this year’s Super Bowl halftime show, Usher Raymond sang through decades of hits while twirling on roller skates, making a case for himself as one of the great R. & B. artists of our time. The performance illuminates a key aspect of modern pop stardom: the fashioning of one’s legacy in real time. In this episode of Critics at Large, the staff writers Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz discuss how musicians’ images take shape independent of their music. They consider “Bob Marley: One Love,” a new bio-pic made with the support of the Marley estate that deliberately smooths the rough edges of the singer’s life. Today’s performers take a more active role in their own reputation management, using high-profile appearances to stake a claim or reinforce their persona. At this year’s Grammy Awards, the question of legacy came to the fore when Jay-Z took issue with the fact that his wife, Beyoncé, has never won the coveted Album of the Year award. But the most indelible moments from the ceremony involved songs from decades prior—a reminder that the music itself is often more enduring than any formal accolade. “Rather than legacy in corporate terms or in institutional terms,” says Fry, there’s also “the legacy of the heart.”

Read, watch, and listen with the critics:

“Bob Marley: One Love” (2024)

“Both Sides Now” by Joni Mitchell, as performed at the 2024 Grammys 

“If I Ain't Got You” by Alicia Keys

Luke Combs’s cover of “Fast Car” by Tracy Chapman

Twins react to “In the Air Tonight” by Phil Collins

“Walk the Line” (2005)

“You Make Me Wanna . . .” by Usher


New episodes drop every Thursday. Follow Critics at Large wherever you get your podcasts.

Up next
Jul 3
Why We Travel
It’s a confusing time to travel. Tourism is projected to hit record-breaking levels this year, and its toll on the culture and ecosystems of popular vacation spots is increasingly hard to ignore. Social media pushes hoards to places unable to withstand the traffic, while the rise ... Show More
46m 33s
Jun 26
The Diva Is Dead, Long Live the Diva
The word “diva” comes from the world of opera, where divinely talented singers have enraptured audiences for centuries. But preternatural gifts often go hand in hand with bad behavior—as in the case of Patti LuPone, the blunt Broadway dame whose remarks about fellow-actresses in ... Show More
49m 24s
Jun 19
Why We Turn Grief Into Art
Yiyun Li’s “Things in Nature Merely Grow” is a bracingly candid memoir of profound loss: one written in the wake of her son James’s death by suicide, seven years after her older son Vincent died in the same way. On this episode of Critics at Large, Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, a ... Show More
45m 23s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2024
Pharrell Williams
Pharrell Williams is a Grammy-winning songwriter, producer, and performer. Getting his start in music alongside Chad Hugo as the production duo known as The Neptunes in 1992, Pharrell has produced chart-topping hits for artists including Britney Spears, Justin Timberlake, and Sno ... Show More
54m 53s
May 26
Britney Spears et Justin Timberlake (1/4) : amour d'enfance
Britney Spears et Justin Timberlake se connaissent depuis l'âge de 12 ans. Lorsque leurs chemins se croisent à la télévision alors qu'ils sont encore enfants, c'est le début d'une grande complicité. Mais comment leur relation va-t-elle évoluer dans un contexte aussi particulier q ... Show More
16m 7s
Apr 2023
Annie Zaleski, "Lady Gaga: Applause" (Palazzo Editions, 2022)
As one of the world's best-selling musicians, Lady Gaga has set the musical bar high. Since her debut album, The Fame (2008), she has sold more than 124 million records and scooped numerous awards, including twelve Grammy Awards and eighteen MTV Music Video Awards.Yet she is much ... Show More
52m 16s
Apr 2024
Angie Harmon's Dog Shot & Killed By Instacart Driver: New Details
Angie Harmon revealed in a heartbreaking post that her Instacart driver shot and killed their family dog. The iHeartRadio Music Awards was a star-studded night, with Beyonce & Taylor Swift both giving speeches following their wins. JoJo Siwa debuted a unrecognizable look at the a ... Show More
18m 44s
Sep 2024
A Taylor Swift Plot Twist & Beyonce’s Big Disappointment
Everyone is celebrating Anna Delvey's casting on Dancing With The Stars, but one key piece of information has been missed. And after releasing her album Cowboy Carter, Beyonce has now been snubbed from an important awards ceremony, and it’s all to do with a bigger plot against he ... Show More
25m 3s
Feb 2025
109. Not for Thanking Beyoncé + The Misogynistic Trap of Relatability
Get up to 10 FREE meals and a free high protein item for life at⁠⁠https://hellofresh.com/notforeveryone10fm⁠⁠.This show is sponsored by Skims. Check them out athttps://www.skims.com/notforeveryone #skimspartner__Look, the Grammys came and went, but don’t think for one minute Jess ... Show More
1h 24m
Jun 2024
Generational Gap in Hip-Hop
Can commercial success ever truly reflect artistic quality? We tackle this burning question as The Culture's Jeff, along with Lindsey from ReeVolt Records, analyze Apple Music's Top 100 Best Albums of All Time. We passionately scrutinize the ranking of "The Miseducation of Lauryn ... Show More
42m 31s
Feb 2025
2025 GRAMMYs Review: Please Be Seated For The Diva Parade
GET TICKETS TO THE SNERAS TOUR: https://www.evolutionofasnake.com Today's episode contains the Snake Nation's favorite cosmic occurrence: supreme diva behavior. From Chappell Roan, to Doechii, Sabrina Carpenter, Beyonce, Shakira, and Charli XCXThis year, the Grammy Awards were st ... Show More
1h 25m
May 2020
Whitney Houston: Whitney's Billboard Run Contains Multitudes
It's hard to underestimate Whitney Houston’s stardom. For better and for worse, the world knows so much more about the late diva than we do about most artists from her era. Houston's meteoric rise would eventually place her own personal life under a microscope, and it&#39 ... Show More
33m 8s
Jul 2024
Jennifer Hudson
Dreamgirl, American Idol finalist and EGOT winner Jennifer Hudson joins us for the last episode of the season. She takes us back to her early years in the Southside of Chicago where she and her siblings grew up in a kitchen filled with song and where she spent precious late night ... Show More
39m 31s