In March of 2017, a 21-year-old woman headed back to her old West Palm Beach home to gather her belongings and move up to Buffalo, New York. But after having a conversation with her former roommate, they stabbed her to death, claiming to have been sleepwalking. But was that truly the case? Or was this premeditated murder? This is the story of Brooke Preston. ... Show More
Feb 10
Hailey Buzbee: Lured by an Online Predator (Happening Now) // 581
In January of 2026, a 17-year-old girl left her Indiana home late at night after connecting with someone she met online. But when she suddenly stopped communicating, her family knew something was terribly wrong. Within days, investigators uncovered a trail of evidence stretching ... Show More
44m 9s
Feb 6
Sheree Magaro: Blood in the Snow // 580
In February of 1987, a 30-year-old woman left her boyfriend’s home in Maryland during the onset of a severe snowstorm, planning to beat the weather in time to make it back to her Pennsylvania home. But the next morning, her car was found abandoned off a highway, and the only sign ... Show More
47m 31s
Oct 2018
Huddersfield: The Murder of Dorothy Wood
In May 1996, ninety-four year old Dorothy Wood said goodnight to her care worker who had come by to get her ready for bed. Profoundly deaf and crippled by arthritis, Dorothy struggled to complete even the most simplest of household tasks, but she was adamant she would keep her in ... Show More
25m 53s
Jan 2024
198. The Deadly Sleepwalker
In this episode, Payton tells Garrett about the case of Scott Falater, a man who committed a crime while sleepwalking. Was he telling the truth, or was he responsible for his actions
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murderwithmyhusband/
Listen on apple: https://apple.co/3s ... Show More
44m 46s
Sep 2022
Bathroom Man (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
<p>In the fall of 1994, a 52 year old woman pulled into the driveway of her home in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, and then turned her car off. As she sat there for a minute, chatting with her daughter on her car phone, she was suddenly startled by someone running up and knocking on he ... Show More
51m 54s
Feb 2024
205. Murder in Paradise - Chris Farmer and Peta Frampton
In this episode, Payton and Garrett delve into the tragic case of Chris Farmer and Peta Frampton, two college students in search of adventure. However, their quest takes a devastating turn when they encounter the wrong individual, leading to the loss of their lives.
NEW MERCH!htt ... Show More
44m 46s