logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2024
1h 2m

503: What Colleges Want (Part 3): "Posit...

ETHAN SAWYER
About this episode

In today’s two-part episode, we’re delving into one of the potentially more confusing aspects of what colleges want — “positive character attributes” — which 65.8% of colleges give considerable or moderate importance. 

In part 1, I’m joined by Tom Bear (VP for Enrollment at Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology) and Bob Massa (former chief admissions/enrollment officer at Johns Hopkins University, Dickinson College and Drew University) to discuss:

  • What are these positive character attributes?
  • Why are they important to colleges?
  • How do colleges decide which qualities to seek and how to evaluate for them?
  • How do students show these qualities in their application? 

Part 2 is with Trisha Ross Anderson, from the Harvard Graduate School of Education’s Making Caring Common Project, and we get into:

  • How Making Caring Common helps colleges figure out what they are looking for
  • How some colleges are working to increase access and equity in admissions
  • Advice to parents as they navigate this process with their students

Tom Bear has been working in college enrollment since 1987 at a variety of institutions, including as VP for Enrollment at University of Evansville, Senior Director of Enrollment at Notre Dame and now as the VP for Enrollment at Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology. He joined the Character Collaborative in 2017, served as Board Chair and will chair NACAC’s Character Focus Initiative.

Bob Massa got his Doctorate in Higher Education from Columbia, served as the chief admissions/enrollment officer at Johns Hopkins University, Dickinson College and Drew University and Co- founded the Character Collaborative in 2016. Although he has retired from full-time work after 45 years of campus-based work, he is an adjunct professor at the University of Southern California’s online masters program in enrollment management.

Trisha Ross Anderson has served on research teams at the Harvard Graduate School of Education for the past 13 years. She’s worked with the Making Caring Common (MCC) Project to help write reports including one called Turning the Tide that focuses on reform of the college admission process. She leads MCC’s college admissions initiatives with Richard Weissbourd and currently serves on NACAC’s Character Focus Initiative Advisory Council. 

 

Play-by-Play

  • 0:00 - Meet Tom Bear and Bob Massa (Part 1)
  • 2:12 - What do colleges mean by “positive character attributes”? 
  • 3:55 - What are some examples of these “positive character attributes”?  
  • 4:58 - Why is it important for students, parents, and counselors to think about these qualities?
  • 7:16 - How do colleges decide what qualities they’re looking for?
  • 12:04 - How do colleges evaluate students for these qualities?
  • 13:09 - Example of a rubric on extraordinary commitment to others
  • 19:10 - Why don’t colleges share their rubrics for what they’re looking for?
  • 21:18 - What can students do to better understand what a particular school is looking for?
  • 24:08 - How do colleges evaluate “character” in an applicant? 
  • 29:58 - What is the high school profile and how is it used in a student’s evaluation?
  • 31:20 - Why is it important to think about positive character attributes now?
  • 35:56 - How can students demonstrate these qualities in their college applications? 
  • 40:00 - What can parents do to help their students in this process? 
  • 42:01 - Meet Trisha Ross Anderson (Part 2)
  • 43:09 - What is the Making Caring Common (MCC) project?
  • 44:37 - How is MCC working with colleges? 
  • 46:17 - Why is it difficult to create a rubric for these qualities?
  • 48:16 - How is MCC helping colleges decide on what they are looking for? 
  • 52:45 - How is MCC helping colleges to increase equity and access in the college admissions process?
  • 57:33 - Advice for parents on navigating this process with their students
  • 1:01:31 - Closing thoughts 

 

Resources

Ideas from Ethan for finding what you care about + finding content for your application: 

Up next
Sep 30
616: Authoring Your Life: Why the Personal Statement Is About (Much) More Than Getting into College
In today’s episode, I’m joined by my long-time colleague, and our Chief People Officer here at CEG, Sandy Longworth. Sandy has worked as a therapist, a researcher, college counselor — among other things — and has spent years studying the role that narrative storytelling plays in ... Show More
1h 16m
Sep 16
615: Rethinking “Best” Colleges: Tools, Tips, and Mindset Shifts for a Better College List with Jay McCann and Dr. Steven Antonoff, Co-Authors of The College Finder
Hi friends, and welcome back to the podcast. In today’s episode, I’m joined by two special guests: Dr. Steven Antonoff and Jay McCann, co-authors of the newly updated 5th edition of The College Finder: Your comprehensive guide to finding colleges that fit YOUR unique path. In thi ... Show More
52 m
Sep 3
614: 13 Mistakes High School Students Make When Creating Their College List
Welcome back to the podcast. It’s September, which means many students are building the list of colleges they’re applying to. Today I’m joined by New York Times Bestselling Author, Harlan Cohen, who walks us through his 13 most common mistakes students make when they’re creating ... Show More
56m 23s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2024
S3E14: How to Answer the Yale Supplement (2024)
In this episode of the "Admittedly" podcast, host Thomas Caleel breaks down the Yale University supplement, guiding applicants through the nuances of both the short and longer essay questions. He emphasizes the importance of research, personal reflection, and thoughtful responses ... Show More
6m 33s
Aug 2018
EP030: How to Get in to Stanford, Harvard, Berkeley or Yale Ft. Marcella De Laurentiis
Episode 030: How to Get in to Stanford, Harvard, Berkeley or Yale Ft. Marcella De Laurentiis Featuring: Marcella De Laurentiis, College Admissions Specialist Mentor Bio: Marcella started her career working in the admissions office at the University of Chicago, her alma mater. Lat ... Show More
38m 11s
Sep 2024
S3E17: How to Get into Brown University (2024)
In this episode of the "Admittedly" podcast, host Thomas Caleel provides an in-depth analysis of the Brown University supplement. He highlights the unique aspects of Brown's educational philosophy, particularly the open curriculum, and offers advice on how to approach each of the ... Show More
6m 42s
Sep 2021
Semester 3: Episode 5: Why are recommendation letters important?
Most universities require recommendation letters for admission, but many students wait until the last minute to gather this essential piece of the college application puzzle. In this episode, IvyWise college admissions experts Christine (Former Assistant Director of Admissions at ... Show More
41m 55s
Sep 2024
S3E12: How to Succeed with the Penn Supplement (2024)
In this episode of the "Admittedly" podcast, host Thomas Caleel dives into the Penn Supplement, focusing on the two required essays for all applicants: the thank you letter and the community essay. He also provides tips for navigating the school-specific essays depending on the p ... Show More
6m 20s
Jun 2025
117. Pulitzer Prize-Winning Journalist Shares How to Write College Essays That Get You In
To set up a complimentary strategy call, CLICK HERE. What makes a college essay stand out at top schools like Harvard, Stanford, or Yale? In this episode, we sit down with Dave Marcus, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, bestselling author of Acceptance, and former high school tea ... Show More
19m 19s
Feb 2024
88. How to Find Your Unique Voice in College Application Essays
How do you capture an Admissions Officer’s attention through your college essays? On today’s episode, Nivanthi Karunaratne, a Graduate Coach at InGenius Prep, shares her personal journey of self-discovery through music and how it has influenced her approach in helping students fi ... Show More
24m 52s
Jan 2025
S3E24: Managing Stress in College Admissions
In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, Thomas Caleel addresses the growing pressures high school students feel during the college admissions process. Exploring the sources of this stress—whether self-imposed or external—Thomas emphasizes the importance of intentionality and c ... Show More
17m 27s
Aug 2021
Season 3: Episode 2: How do I write a great personal statement and supplemental essays?
Besides, grades and test scores, one of the most important elements of the college admissions rubric is the essay. While the Common App has the required personal statement essay, many universities also ask supplemental questions, which give admissions officers the chance to get t ... Show More
46m 9s
Aug 12
What Is Demonstrated Interest And How Does It Impact College Admisssions?
Demonstrated interest refers to the ways a student indicates interest in a specific school. This includes visiting campuses, reaching out to admissions officers, participating in prospective student events, and even interacting with the school’s online resources.Let’s face it: th ... Show More
10m 29s