logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2024
55m 51s

Celina Mays

SARAH TURNEY
About this episode
12-year-old Celina Mays went missing from her home in Willingboro, New Jersey, on December 16, 1996. Celina was reported missing, but her disappearance wasn’t really treated as a potential crime by her family or local law enforcement. In fact, it took days for police to find out perhaps the most important detail – 12-year-old Celina was pregnant and due in o ... Show More
Up next
Today
Lilly and Jack Sullivan
Six-year-old Lilly and four-year-old Jack Sullivan vanished from their rural Nova Scotia home on May 2nd, 2025. Their disappearance sparked an immediate and massive search effort, involving hundreds of volunteer searchers, K9 units, helicopters, drones, and specialized RCMP units ... Show More
48m 45s
Jul 4
Kate Brown and Carnell Sledge
In the summer of 2019, two friends met up at a very popular park and within 14 minutes, they were both shot and killed in broad daylight. While it’s been 6 years since their murders, at the end of May 2025, their names were back in the news as investigators began looking into a m ... Show More
53m 36s
Jun 27
Mikelle Biggs
It was a quiet evening in Mesa, Arizona, January 2, 1999. Eleven-year-old Mikelle Biggs was just waiting outside her home for the sound of the ice cream truck. But in the span of just ninety seconds, she vanished without a trace. Her bicycle was left behind, one of the wheels sti ... Show More
46m 50s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2023
Celina Mays
Ep 130: A twelve year old girl ends up pregnant, but two weeks before she’s scheduled for a C-section, her family wakes up to find her gone.Did she run away, or did someone try to eliminate her? This is the Celina Mays story Center for Missing and Exploited Children 1800- THE-LOS ... Show More
40m 9s
Jul 2023
MURDERED: Pamela Butler and Marta Rodriguez
When a successful career woman goes missing in Washington, D.C., her family immediately knows something is wrong. And when the investigation’s winding path eventually leads detectives right back to the place they started, her family’s long fight for justice produces a stunning re ... Show More
45m 49s
May 2024
MURDERED: Lisa Norell
When a 15-year-old girl vanishes on her way home from a friend’s quinceañera rehearsal in 1998, a California community holds its breath and hopes it’s a one-off. But when other young women in the community are targeted one by one, investigators have to ask if there’s a serial kil ... Show More
36m 17s
Aug 2023
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Adrienne Salinas
When a promising young woman fails to show up for a Father’s Day celebration in 2013, her dad knows immediately that something is very wrong. And as investigators work to unravel the chaotic timeline of the night she went missing, they find no lack of viable persons of interest. ... Show More
50m 53s
Aug 2022
Crystal Faye Todd
Ep 86: On a Saturday evening, this 17-year-old girl hopped in her car to meet her friends for a fun night out, planning to make it home by her midnight curfew. But by 3 am when she hadn’t arrived home, her panicked mother called 911 reporting her daughter missingWhile the police ... Show More
56m 39s
May 2022
True Crime Revolution: Sarah Turney Part 2
We continue our fascinating discussion on ethics in true crime with Sarah Turney, on topics ranging from leaks in the Delphi case, parasocial relationships in true crime, web sleuthing, family-member creator content, and the future she envisions for true-crime media. Sarah Turney ... Show More
37m 49s
Mar 2024
MISSING: Angela Green
When Angela Green vanished from her home in a Kansas suburb in 2019, she left behind a web of her husband's lies and a mystery that’s been haunting her loved ones and baffling police.If you have any information about Angela’s disappearance, please contact the Prairie Village Poli ... Show More
52m 39s
May 2024
Reena Virk - Part 2 | 114
In November 1997, the shocking swarming murder of 14 year old Reena Virk, a BC teenager made international headlines and brought the issue of teen violence and bullying to the forefront. In this episode Caitlin and Graeme Duffy from the podcast True North True Crime join Kathy to ... Show More
37m 35s
Jan 2024
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Lauren Agee
A fun-filled wakeboarding festival turns tragic after a young woman’s body is found floating in the lake. Her family is told that it was an accident, but they begin to suspect that her friends may know more than what they are saying.Check out the Without Warning Podcast, hosted b ... Show More
37m 41s
Jun 2024
MISSING: Kristen Modafferi
A vibrant young woman from North Carolina decides to spend the summer between her freshman and sophomore years clear across the country, in the Bay Area. But alarm bells start going off when she leaves her job at a coffee shop… and is never seen again.If you know anything about t ... Show More
51m 33s