logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2024
1h 2m

Gilmore To Consider #35: Could Dean have...

Tara Llewellyn & Haley McIntosh
About this episode

Happy New Year besties! We're so glad to be starting another year discussing more Gilmore with y'all. This week, we're talking about the colors we assigned to our year (is this crazy or are you picking a color too?) and then we got three calls from three besties about Rory's three men.

Could Dean have been redeemed post-affair in the same way we saw Jess have a redemption arc? What would it have looked like if Rory was in Philly with Jess OR if maybe he worked with her? And would Rory have said yes to Logan if Lorelai helped him and/or Rory had more time to think about it?

As always if you have more to say, call in at 860-578-4653. We love hearing from you!

And be sure to join our Patreon for our spoiler-FULL rewatch, Gilmore Revisited as we recap Season 4!

Now you can watch the girlies every week by subscribing to us on YouTube!

Where you lead I will follow... us @gilmoretosaypodcast

Or if you want gilmore to read, join our book clubs on Fable! We're reading Woke Up Like This by Amy Lea and Franny and Zooey by JD Salinger.

Up next
Jul 8
Gilmore to Consider #49: Rory Gilmore takes Lorelai’s Partings Plot
Where you call, we will answer! This week, we’re revisiting our June 3rd episode and implementing some of your ideas! What if Luke and Lorelai get married but Rory took Lorelai’s plotline in “Partings”?? Or if Jess was revealed to be a foil to Christopher all along? Grab a cup of ... Show More
32m 9s
Jul 1
Take the Gilmore Girls out of Stars Hollow
A roadtrip to Harvard? A cross-country bus ride to California? Playing hooky in New York City to visit the boy who isn’t your boyfriend?! It’s officially Gilmore Girls Summer and nothing says “summer” quite like a lil vacation. This week, we’re leaving Stars Hollow and breaking d ... Show More
1h 7m
Jun 26
Gilmore to Say Revisited: Tara as the Stars Hollow Bachelorette
Did we manifest Hannah Brown coming on the podcast back in 2022??? One of our listeners, Hannah, called in three years ago and asked Tara to come up with a season of the Bachelorette using Rory's men on Gilmore Girls and it was VERY silly. In the following GTC, Haley challenges T ... Show More
35m 32s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2022
Rory, How Much Do you Like this Person? Part 1 (S2, E12 "Richard in Stars Hollow")
Scott describes this episode as "perfect" but find out why he didn't ultimately give it a "thumbs up".The answer may surprise you.Richard Gilmore is visiting Stars Hollow and there is a lot to unpack. How do we feel about his harsh criticism of Lorelai? Even though they went toe ... Show More
57m 23s
Sep 2023
What????? Part 2 (S5 E22 "A House Is Not a Home”)
It's the Season 5 Finale and WE ARE ALL IN!   Is Lorelai right?  Is Rory making a huge mistake? Have Emily and Richard betrayed Lorelai more than ever this time?   Should Rory pick herself up, forget Mitchum's comments, and get back to Yale?   Did Mrs. Kim shock us!?   What do we ... Show More
47m 26s
Sep 2023
What about the Kids?!? Part 1 (S5 E22 "A House Is Not a Home”)
It's the Season 5 Finale and WE ARE ALL IN!   Is Lorelai right?  Is Rory making a huge mistake? Have Emily and Richard betrayed Lorelai more than ever this time?   Should Rory pick herself up, forget Mitchum's comments, and get back to Yale?   Did Mrs. Kim shock us!?   What do we ... Show More
45m 7s
Jul 2023
You Bet (S5 E17 "Pulp Friction”)
Immediately, we're discussing if Luke and Lorelai should have gotten back together so quickly or did they need time to sort through the conflict.   Rory and Robert vs. Rory and Logan.  Where do we stand?  How do we feel?   Scott has strong opinions about Logan in this episode.   ... Show More
1h 7m
Jan 2022
I’ll Be The One with the Coffee (S2 E11, "Secrets and Loans")
We’re back!!The Gilmore Girls house is falling apart and we might be too. Scott reveals why this is his least favorite episode so far. We need to know if you feel the same or if he is way off! Has Kirk finally found his calling and what’s up with Sookie’s freezer?? Did Rory go to ... Show More
59m 43s
May 2022
It's a Big Fat Happy Sunshine Day for Me (S3 E5, “Eight O’Clock at The Oasis”)
Jess comes to Rory's rescue and fixes the sprinklers turning them off only to turn them right back on again to really help Rory.  Did you see the same deeper meaning in this gesture that we did?   Hello, Jon Hamm... Should Lorelai have gone to see David Bowie even if Peyton was b ... Show More
55m 36s
Jul 2023
I've Gotta Go (S5 E14 "Say Something”)
Heartbroken.  Luke and Lorelai... ugh.  We'll get to that, of course.  But first, Logan and Rory... we're in to it!   Taylor and his ribbons.  We've made our choices... three of us are blue and one of us is pink.   Now, Luke and Lorelai.  We have some serious thoughts and disappo ... Show More
1 h
Feb 2023
The Future of TV with Ashley Ray, Weaponizing Therapy and Where We Grew Up
Transcription: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ah8FEYFpKTjQl_0NhbFJCAYRwDZL6Spf1QDMX738qiM/edit?usp=sharing We're going back in time to another episode without Gabe! (Recorded before their name change.) Allison and Melisa start off with a discussion of Allison's new m ... Show More
1h 19m
Oct 2021
Do I Want to Know What You're Doing? (S1 E20, “P.S. I Lo…”)
After the intense debate of which boy band is the superior choice, we go straight to the source. Joining Scott is none other than 98 Degrees! Find out which 98 Degrees Member credits Gilmore Girls for getting his wife and daughter through quarantine. What did they think when they ... Show More
59m 16s
Jun 2024
I just had to tell you. I won. (S7 E12 “To Whom It May Concern”)
We’re more than halfway through Season 7, and we hope you agree these episodes are getting better and better!   París proves she really is a good friend to Rory.  And, happy to see Lucy’s conflict with Rory resolved.   The vasectomy stuff has us all saying hmmmmmm.   Luke deserve ... Show More
1h 3m