logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2023
1h 20m

It's All Right, It's All True, It All Ha...

Spencer Klavan
About this episode

Is Christmas just a rebranded pagan holiday? Or does the rabbit hole go somewhat deeper? After last week's foray into hermeneutics, this week I take a closer look at the history of Christian allegory, and why this particular form of reading became so important to the early church--and why it's still essential for understanding the meaning of Christmas (and everything else).

Check out our sponsor, the Ancient Language Institute: https://ancientlanguage.com/youngheretics/

Sign up to be in the mailbag: https://rejoiceevermore.substack.com/

Pick up my book, How to Save the West: https://a.co/d/9S57cfh

Up next
Jul 17
Love, Lust, and Lancelot: Dante's Inferno, Canto 5
We're in hell for real now. Dante enters the circle of the lustful, where the sinister King Minos strips souls naked and condemns them to their proper place. What does that mean? What does it mean to be "evil-born," and what does Dante show us about the nature of lust? Not, it tu ... Show More
1h 10m
Jun 12
Dante's Inferno, Episode 5: Can Pagans Be Saved?
Hell is murky. Today we enter limbo, which is technically the least painful section of hell but actually leaves me with some of the toughest questions in the poem. What does Dante make--what do Christians in general make--of all the noble, wise, and humane people who apparently l ... Show More
1h 10m
May 22
Dante's Inferno, Episode 4: Nothing Is Very Strong
ABANDON ALL HOPE, YE WHO ENTER HERE: We've made it at last to the gates of hell, and we're on our way to the river of Acheron. On the way, we'll meet the "neutrals" and the cowards—those who never lived and have no names. From here on out, the poem becomes a horror movie. But in ... Show More
1h 10m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2021
Listener Mail: Ghost Stories, Santa Claus and the New Chronology
<p>What if part of known history never actually happened? What can Santa teach us about the power of language in folklore? Multiple Conspiracy Realists write in with their own otherworldly, sometimes disturbing experiences. All this and more in this week's Listener Mail.</p><p> < ... Show More
47m 38s
Dec 2023
#49 Christmas Special with Bart Ehrman - Did Christmas Really Happen?
<p>In this Christmas special of Within Reason, New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman explores the history and narrative of Jesus' birthday, and demonstrates where the accounts seem to contradict.</p> <p>Get Bart Erhman's courses <a href="https://www.bartehrman.com/alex/">here</a>.</p ... Show More
1h 3m
Dec 2020
Christmas Traditions
The roots of this festive holiday reach way back through history, with links to Nordic myths and the Roman Saturnalia. For colonists in 17th century America, celebrating Christmas was controversial… and in this telling, a despairing Puritan preacher goes so far as to try and canc ... Show More
30m 45s
Dec 2018
CLASSIC: The Mysterious Origins of Christmas
<p>Chances are that you've heard of the alleged war on Christmas, which some believe is an effort to distance the celebration from its origins. But what are those origins, exactly -- and where do modern Christmas traditions come from? Tune in to learn more. Join Ben and Matt as t ... Show More
21m 21s
Dec 2024
#92 Bart Ehrman - The Dark Side of Christmas
<p>Bart Ehrman is a New Testament scholar focusing on textual criticism of the New Testament, the historical Jesus, and the origins and development of early Christianity. Get Bart Ehrman's new course, <a href="https://cosmicskeptic--ehrman.thrivecart.com/dark-side-of-christmas/"> ... Show More
1h 1m
Dec 2024
The Story You're Telling Yourself
<p>Story is how we make sense of life, but when the narrative is shaped by loss, loneliness, or  disappointment, it can keep us stuck in an echo chamber of old assumptions. As we begin the holiday season, John and Allen ask what story we're telling ourselves about this Christmas ... Show More
46m 42s
Apr 2024
Look at Us, Late to the Ridiculous History of Easter
Easter! It's a big deal, all across the world. And just like earlier celebrations of spirituality, it's been commodified in the United States. In today's episode, Ben, Max, and Noel sneak into the Sunday service just a bit late to explore how the ancient commemorations of rebirth ... Show More
47m 7s
Dec 2021
Christmas Symbolism: Jesus Christ as a Pagan Myth, Elf on the Shelf Surveillance State & More!
**VIDEO VERSION WILL BE A YOUTUBE PREMIER! Watch the video with me interacting in the chats on YouTube (*the video will become unlisted after the Premier and only available with this private link for Tier 2+ supporters only). Date and time of YouTube Premier: Tuesday 12/21 at 2PM ... Show More
1h 1m
Dec 2021
Christian Atheism
We're talking Jesus Christ, Žižek's Christian Atheism, and Christmas. How do Christ and God figure in Žižek's work? Is God Dead? Also, the Big (m)Other. From the pod to you, merry Christmas—especially to the atheists. Thanks to all our listeners. https://www.patreon.com/zizekands ... Show More
1h 2m