logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2023
54m 35s

The Sunday Read: ‘The Botched Hunt for t...

The New York Times
About this episode

The beginning of the story was strangely familiar, like the opening scene in a shopworn police procedural: A woman runs screaming down a street in Oak Beach, a secluded gated community on Long Island’s South Shore, only to vanish, it seems, into thin air. It was almost dawn on May 1, 2010. Hours earlier, Shannan Gilbert traveled from New Jersey to see a man who had hired her as an escort from a Craigslist ad. By the time the police arrived, she was gone. They talked to the neighbors, the john and her driver and came up with nothing. A few days later, they ordered a flyover of the area and, again, saw no sign of her. Then they essentially threw up their hands. She went into the ocean, they decided, either hysterical or on drugs.

None of this made the news, not at first. A missing sex worker rarely does. Not even when another woman advertising on Craigslist, Megan Waterman, was reported missing a month later.

This was, quite obviously, a serial-killer case. The only person not saying as much was the Suffolk County police commissioner, Richard Dormer. “I don’t want anyone to think we have a Jack the Ripper running around Suffolk County with blood dripping from a knife,” he said in a frenzied news conference. In fact, they had something almost exactly like that. All eyes were on the Suffolk Police now — wondering who killed these women, if they would ever find Gilbert and what it would take to solve the mystery.

This story was recorded by Audm. To hear more audio stories from publications like The New York Times, download Audm for iPhone or Android.

Up next
Yesterday
Trump’s Top Aides Spread the Epstein Conspiracy. Now They Are Trying to Kill It.
For months, President Trump and Attorney General Pam Bondi suggested that they would expose the hidden, potentially sinister truth about Jeffrey Epstein’s death in 2019.But over the past few days, the Trump administrationWhite House decided to shut down has poured cold water on t ... Show More
21m 47s
Jul 8
A Love Letter to Camp Mystic
On Monday evening, the death toll from the flooding in Central Texas rose past 100. A single place accounted for 27 of those deaths: Camp Mystic, a century-old Christian summer camp for girls.Erin Paisan, who attended Camp Mystic, explains what the place meant to generations of g ... Show More
25m 9s
Jul 7
A Dark Moment for Journalism — and Devastation in Texas
Last week, when Paramount, the parent company of CBS News, announced a $16 million settlement with President Trump over editing of a segment of “60 Minutes,” many of the network’s journalists were furious.The deal also raised questions about the independence of CBS’s journalism, ... Show More
34m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2021
Gorgeous flight attendant "disappears' off boyfriend's yacht
41-year-old Sarm Heslop has been living in the U.S. Virgin islands on a boat with her boyfriend Ryan Bane. the The former flight attendant, turned chef vanished in the middle of the night from the catamaran “Siren Song.” Police reports say Bane police that he and Heslop had gone ... Show More
40m 40s
Oct 2023
Man Kills Wife, Texts Friends About How It Felt
A Clay County man has been charged with murder for allegedly murdering his wife in Kansas City's Northland and fled to Nebraska on Friday after police discovered a number of disturbing communications that appeared to reference the death. John Wonder was charged with first-degree ... Show More
11m 3s
Jul 2023
Serial Killer Caught?
Rex Heuermann, a New York architect, pleaded not guilty Friday to six counts of murder in connection with the deaths of three of the four women known as the "Gilgo Four". The charges relate to the deaths of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costello. A fourth woman, M ... Show More
43m 40s
Mar 2020
S1 Ep1: Shannan - Part 1
24-year-old escort Shannan Gilbert disappeared in May, 2010, from the affluent Long Island community of Oak Beach without a trace. Months later, while police were conducting a routine training exercise in the neighboring Gilgo Beach area, officials discovered the skeletal remains ... Show More
38m 1s
Sep 2023
#293: Serial Killer Watched Podcasts About His Murders - CAUGHT After 13 Years
Shannon’s driver had a few roles. He would drive her to the client’s home, wait outside, and make sure she made it out of the house in one piece. He was security if you will and in this line of work (escorting) - security was everything.He wasn’t expecting the client to come rush ... Show More
1h 22m
Feb 2021
Narrowing in on a killer - The Kelly Cook Story |10
In the summer of 1981, a group of teenagers was out exploring the countryside in southeastern Alberta. They had stopped to scout a path around a lake when they came across something that would haunt them even four decades later. There was a body on the shoreline, and immediately ... Show More
46m 14s
Oct 2023
Author J Ruben Appleman Talks Early Days of Kohberger Investigation
In a recent episode of the podcast "Hidden Killers," Tony Brueski delves into a captivating and haunting criminal case that has gripped Moscow, Idaho since November of 2022. The alleged crime? Bryan Kohberger is accused of the first-degree murder of four college students. A trage ... Show More
11m 31s