logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2023
49m 19s

‘Long Island Lolita’ (Pt 1): Amy Fisher ...

iHeartPodcasts and The Meteor
About this episode

In 1992, Amy Fisher, a teen girl from Long Island became a tabloid sensation almost overnight – when she shot Mary Jo Buttafuoco, the wife of her much older “boyfriend” Joey Buttafuoco. Within days, the New York Daily News would splash a picture of Amy across its front page with a headline that would follow her forever: The Long Island Lolita. In this episode, Susie and Jess interrogate the way Amy Fisher was covered and examine why her story gripped the nation.

Guests:

  • Amy Pagnozzi, former and longtime New York Post columnist who covered the Amy Fisher trial

FOR MORE:

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Oct 2024
Update: Why the Menendez Brothers May Go Free
Since we originally published this episode in May 2024, there has been significant developments for Lyle and Erik Menendez, brothers who were convicted of killing their parents in the early 1990s. On October 24th, Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascón requested that the bro ... Show More
49m 14s
Jun 2024
Madonna and the Making of a Cultural Icon (Pt 2)
When Madonna performed “Like A Virgin'' at the first MTV Video Music Awards in 1984, she scandalized the audience and her own team. But she also stole the show, cementing MTV’s place in cultural history. In this episode, Susie and Jess look back at Madonna’s early years in New Yo ... Show More
40m 15s
May 2024
Madonna And The MTV Moment (Pt 1)
In 1984, a relatively unknown 26-year old Madonna appeared at the first MTV Video Music Awards. Dressed like a rock and roll bride, Madonna sang “Like a Virgin.” The performance was considered so risque, so scandalous that many – including her own manager – predicted it would end ... Show More
47m 39s
Recommended Episodes
May 2021
Exclusive: The Amy Fisher Story
From September 27, 2004: Oprah interviews Amy Elizabeth Fisher known as "the Long Island Lolita". In 1992, at the age of 17, Amy shot and severely wounded Mary Jo Buttafuoco. At the time Amy was having an affair with Mary’s Jo’s husband, Joey Buttafuoco. Amy served seven years in ... Show More
34m 30s
Feb 2024
TOWS Special: Exclusive: The Amy Fisher Story
Original Air Date: September 27, 2004Oprah interviews Amy Elizabeth Fisher known as "The Long Island Lolita". In 1992, at the age of 17, Amy shot and severely wounded Mary Jo Buttafuoco. At the time Amy was having an affair with Mary’s Jo’s husband, Joey Buttafuoco. Amy served se ... Show More
34m 30s
Jul 2019
Tabloid Decade and the Long Island Lolita | 1
On this episode Host Kathy Kenzora is looking back at how tabloid media had a feeding frenzy on the Long Island Lolita. In May 1992, a high school senior on Long Island, New York, went to the home of her much older ex-lover and shot his wife in the face. 17 year old Amy Fisher ha ... Show More
40m 4s
Oct 2023
Amy Schumer (Re-release)
In this flashback episode, Amy Schumer [Trainwreck, Snatched, I Feel Pretty, Inside Amy Schumer, Expecting Amy] joins Anna to talk about her documentary series Expecting Amy, the joys and fears of being a mother, how she met her husband, loving stand-up comedy, The Meisner Techni ... Show More
1h 23m
May 2023
90s Lolitas, volume 1: Drew Barrymore, Amy Fisher and Alicia Silverstone (Erotic 90’s, Part 8)
Culture in the 90s was obsessed with the sex lives of teenagers. This is a theme we will come back to several times throughout the season. In this episode, we’ll talk about Drew Barrymore, who became a massive star at age 7 in E.T., went to rehab at 13, became an emancipated mino ... Show More
1h 27m
Apr 2018
Amy Schumer: A Modern-Day Warrior Woman
Amy Schumer, the Peabody- and Emmy-winning comedian, actress and best-selling author, discusses one of Oprah's favorite life lessons: You become what you believe. This message of empowerment is the theme of Amy's latest romantic comedy, "I Feel Pretty." Amy's character in the fil ... Show More
1h 1m
Jun 2021
Episode 239: The Long Island Lolita Case with Special Guest Bailey Sarian
SURPRISE! Our very special guest this week is the magical Bailey Sarian of "Murder, Mystery and Makeup" on YouTube and now her brand new podcast, “Dark History.” We were stoked to have Bailey on to talk about Amy Fisher and Joey Buttafuoco of the infamous “Long Island Lolita” cas ... Show More
1h 25m
Mar 2023
Super Soul Special: Amy Schumer: A Modern-Day Warrior Woman
Original Air Date: April 23, 2018Amy Schumer, the Peabody- and Emmy-winning comedian, actress and best-selling author, discusses one of Oprah's favorite life lessons: You become what you believe. This message of empowerment is the theme of Amy's romantic comedy, "I Feel Pretty." ... Show More
1h 1m