logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2023
1h 4m

But I'm A Logan Girly!

Tara Llewellyn & Haley McIntosh
About this episode
tail spinning
Up next
Apr 30
Gilmore to Consider: Where was Richard Gilmore?
We went to LA and all we got was to be in a Gilmore Girls documentary!!! …and a harrowing experience at a hotel. This month’s April round-up, we’re telling y’all about our spontaneous LA experience to lend our Gilmore expertise to an upcoming doc and pouring over your responses a ... Show More
45m 43s
Apr 28
Gilmore to Consider: Dean and Lindsay/Chris and Sherry
How did YOU feel about the Dean/Lindsay vs Chris/Sherry comparison that came from our episode analysis a couple weeks ago? Y’all had some thoughts!!! Grab a cup of coffee and get comfortable because Tara and Haley have more to consider!Our newest podcast, A Marvelous Time: A Marv ... Show More
33m 48s
Apr 23
Super Cool Party People [Gilmore Revisited]
Besties, April 25th is the 20th anniversary of Gilmore Girls season 6 episode 20 Super Cool Party People, so to celebrate the namesake of one of our Patreon tiers, we're giving y'all the recap of the episode we did on Gilmore Revisited-- our spoiler-filled Gilmore recap podcast t ... Show More
1h 54m
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2023
I Am All In (S5 E3 "Written in the Stars”)
OMG. He said it and he meant it!  Luke and Lorelai are happening!  He held on to that horoscope for EIGHT years!   And, if that's not enough.  LOGAN!! Hellooooo Logan!  One of Scott's co-hosts admits they don't really like Logan.  WHAT!    Tara is friends with one of the backgrou ... Show More
1h 7m
Jul 2023
You Bet (S5 E17 "Pulp Friction”)
Immediately, we're discussing if Luke and Lorelai should have gotten back together so quickly or did they need time to sort through the conflict.   Rory and Robert vs. Rory and Logan.  Where do we stand?  How do we feel?   Scott has strong opinions about Logan in this episode.   ... Show More
1h 7m
Jul 2023
I've Gotta Go (S5 E14 "Say Something”)
Heartbroken.  Luke and Lorelai... ugh.  We'll get to that, of course.  But first, Logan and Rory... we're in to it!   Taylor and his ribbons.  We've made our choices... three of us are blue and one of us is pink.   Now, Luke and Lorelai.  We have some serious thoughts and disappo ... Show More
1 h
Aug 2021
I Thought you Were in the Congo or Philadelphia or Something (S1 E16, “Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers”)
tail spinning
1h 4m
Oct 2021
Do I Want to Know What You're Doing? (S1 E20, “P.S. I Lo…”)
<p>After the intense debate of which boy band is the superior choice, we go straight to the source. Joining Scott is none other than 98 Degrees! Find out which 98 Degrees Member credits Gilmore Girls for getting his wife and daughter through quarantine. What did they think when t ... Show More
59m 16s
Aug 2023
You Are Not Getting That House Part 1 (S5 E21 "Blame Booze and Melville")
<p>So much to discuss!  As we approach the Season 5 Finale we are discussing, debating, and disagreeing!<br>First, are you kidding me??  No one just gets a vasectomy sprung on them the day of their child's birth!  We really have a bone to pick on this same day vasectomy with no w ... Show More
1h 1m
Jan 2022
Rory, How Much Do you Like this Person? Part 1 (S2, E12 "Richard in Stars Hollow")
<p>Scott describes this episode as "perfect" but find out why he didn't ultimately give it a "thumbs up".</p><p>The answer may surprise you.</p><p>Richard Gilmore is visiting Stars Hollow and there is a lot to unpack. How do we feel about his harsh criticism of Lorelai? Even thou ... Show More
57m 23s
Jan 2022
I’ll Be The One with the Coffee (S2 E11, "Secrets and Loans")
tail spinning
59m 43s
Sep 2022
I Failed Him (S3 E21 "Here Comes the Son”)
The spin-off that never was.  The question is… was that the right decision?  Should Jess (Milo Ventimiglia), Jimmy (Rob Estes), and Sasha (Sherilyn Fenn) been given their own series.   Scott has thoughts about Jimmy… will you agree?!??!?!   Back in Stars Hollow, should Lorelai ha ... Show More
1h 22m