logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2023
58m 22s

Ep. 37 The Poisoning of the Carr Family

BELLA
About this episode
It all started when Peggy started to feel sick. It got worse and worse with no explanation. Soon, the youngest boys started feeling the same way. The Carr family's world was turned upside down when the doctors told them they were being poisoned and that was causing the illness. The final question, who was doing it?    For case suggestions or personal stories ... Show More
Up next
Aug 2025
Ep. 45 Supposed to be the Perfect Wife
In the episode I talk with B from Arbitrary Advice about 2 different documentaries on the same case. Those cases are "The Perfect Wife" and "Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie". I give go through her case and we give our thoughts on everything. This case has no true ending and we s ... Show More
1h 27m
Jul 2025
Ep. 44 Our Predator Problem
Hey everyone, I made it back after a long break. I wanted to come back with an episode that is a very important topic. This is a case about a man who preyed on young women. Was able to have a social media platform, post creepy videos and just be a terrible human. This topic is so ... Show More
28m 44s
May 2024
Ep. 43 The Murders of Billie-Jo Jenkins
Billie-Jo Jenkins was a beautiful young girl who had so much potential ahead of her, but unfortunately it was all taken away. While doing simple outside chores, some animal brutally took her life. Police tried to piece together what they could, but it is still unsolved. This is h ... Show More
35m 45s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2023
Case 239: Peggy Carr
<div>When 41-year-old waitress Peggy Carr succumbed to a mysterious illness in October 1988, doctors in Alturas, Florida struggled to figure out what was wrong with her. As other members of Peggy’s family became sick too, one neurologist came to suspect they were dealing with a c ... Show More
1h 2m
May 2023
192. The Murder of Peggy Carr -- That Girl is Poison
When Peggy Carr fell mysteriously ill, all eyes were on her husband. But then Mensa got involved, and things got weird. Sponsors: Angi: angi.com Hello Fresh: HelloFresh.com/tp16 and use code tp16 for 16 free meals plus free shipping Babbel: BABBEL.com/PROSECUTE for up to 55% off ... Show More
1h 8m
Feb 2020
Bad Medicine
A young woman suddenly becomes critically ill; her symptoms worsen over time, eventually leaving her unable to walk. Then a bone marrow test reveals the cause; arsenic. Investigators now had to determine if the poisoning was caused by groundwater contamination or something much m ... Show More
20m 11s
Nov 2023
56: Mensa 'Genius' Murderer Exposed His Own Crime
Today, we are talking about the murder of Peggy Carr, and the attempted murder of the rest of her family. When disputes with her neighbour George Trepal and his wife had escalated, nobody could have anticipated what came next. As Peggy and her children fell mysteriously ill, unde ... Show More
42m 33s
Mar 2024
209. The Poisonous Blame Game - Mary Yoder
In this case, Payton and Garrett dive into the case of Mary Yoder. When Mary suddenly falls gravely ill, suspicion casts a shadow over every member of the family. The question looms: Who is responsible for poisoning Mary Yoder? Live Show Tickets: https://www.murderwithmyhusband.c ... Show More
41m 6s
Dec 2024
Medical Mysteries - "A Change in Fortune"
<p>This story is a fan favorite from MrBallen's Medical Mysteries.</p><p>On a hot September day in 1986, a family in Goiania, Brazil, suddenly begin feeling sick after a celebration. The symptoms are horrific: vomiting, diarrhea, and bleeding. But one family member suspects somet ... Show More
29m 30s
Oct 2022
Toxic Environment
When a 23-year-old Marine collapses and dies, doctors initially believe a heart attack is to blame. But when arsenic is found in some of his organs, prosecutors charge his wife with murder. A quick-thinking attorney and toxicology testing uncover the truth and ensure that justice ... Show More
25m 47s
Oct 2023
Joel Guy Jr
In this gripping episode, we delve deep into the disturbing and mysterious story of the Guy family. What initially seems like an ordinary family harbors dark secrets and an unimaginable tragedy. Discover the chilling events that unfolded in their Knoxville home, leaving everyone ... Show More
55m 32s