logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2023
44m 10s

S2 E1: Had to choose to Kill Mom or Dad ...

We Are Verified
About this episode

In the fall of 2017 in upstate New York, lived the Neurauter family. 46 year-old Michele, was a college professor and her husband Lloyd was a senior engineer for a large company. The couple had 3 daughters and seemed to live the perfect life. They were financially stable, owned a home, and had successful jobs. But on August 27th, 2017 that would all change when a friend of Michele shows up to her house to find her hanging from the stair banister. From first glance it looked like a suicide, but police would later uncover the truth of this staged suicide and the dark string of the family affairs going on behind closed doors.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Jun 30
How did This Group of "Millionaires" Frame Karen Read of Murder?: Case of John O' Keefe
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices 
1h 25m
Jun 18
Woman Steals Baby out of Mothers Stomach: Case of Reagan- Simmons Hancock
Taylor Morton was described as a con-artist and a pathological liar to a lot of people who knew her. Taylor would tell a lot of fake stories about herself to many people including being a billionaire family heiress, a nurse, a surgeon, an OBGYN, and has million dollar contracts w ... Show More
1h 12m
Jun 18
Woman Steals Baby out of Mothers Stomach: Case of Reagan- Simmons Hancock
Taylor Morton was described as a con-artist and a pathological liar to a lot of people who knew her. Taylor would tell a lot of fake stories about herself to many people including being a billionaire family heiress, a nurse, a surgeon, an OBGYN, and has million dollar contracts w ... Show More
1h 15m
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2018
Dad daughter duo in mom’s ‘suicide’ Plus: Gorgeous Alabama mom's sexy double life leads to murder?
A college student and her father are accused of teaming up to kill the mother and staging it to look like a suicide. Karrie Neurauter, who is studying computer engineering at the Rochester Institute of Technology, and her father, Lloyd, are charged with 2nd-degree murder for Mich ... Show More
1 h
Jul 2023
Episode 478: Michele Neurauter
On August 28, 2017, police in Corning, NY responded to a call about “suspicious circumstances” at the home of forty-six-year-old mother of three Michele Neurauter. Upon entering the home, the scene appeared to be a fairly straightforward suicide; however, investigators were immed ... Show More
1h 1m
Jul 2021
16: #16- His Wife Was Murdered, He Spent 25 Years Planning The Perfect Revenge (The Secret in Their Eyes)
His life stopped when his newlywed wife was murdered in their home. He realized that nothing the police did would ever bring his wife back. Even death would be too easy for whoever did this.  For the next 25 years, he meticulously planned revenge- it had to be perfect. Nobody can ... Show More
45m 3s
Jun 2021
Introducing Paper Ghosts Season 2
During the 1981 Fourth of July weekend, four people were found dead inside a massive farmhouse that belonged to a wealthy Ohio family. Desperate to find answers, surviving family members reached out to M. William Phelps for help. After a years-long investigation, new developments ... Show More
2m 24s
Dec 2023
A Family Affair
On today's episode, Kate and Paul begin in Atlanta, Georgia in 1952 where a woman's husband is found dead shortly after the death of her child. Once she remarries and life insurance policies are taken out, can anything be done to keep her family safe? See Privacy Policy at https: ... Show More
51m 17s
Jun 2021
Wealthy South Carolina family's double-murder mystery; Sarah Lawrence College sex cult case
This week on True Crime Daily The Podcast: A mother and son from a prominent South Carolina family were shot and killed on their property while the son was awaiting trial in connection to a 2019 boat crash that left a 19-year-old woman dead. And an update to the Sarah Lawrence Co ... Show More
52m 53s
Oct 2022
Unsolved Quadruple Homicide: The Sharp Family
When a mom of five leaves an unhealthy marriage, she resettles in remote Keddie, California with her children, not knowing that their fresh start will soon come to a tragic end. Evil walks into Cabin #28 and modern-day investigators seek to rectify the mistakes of their predecess ... Show More
54m 57s
Aug 2020
5-year-old tot girl shot dead in suburban home. HELP CATCH ITALIA'S KILLER!
Little Italia Graham was running to her bedroom to get a toy to show to her family when shots rang out. The 5-year-old is killed, hit in the head by a bullet. Multiple bullets holes are found in the home. Shell casings little the street. Who killed Italia? Joining Nancy Grace Tod ... Show More
36m 37s