logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2023
1h 1m

819: What Caused 2023’s WILD Insurance M...

BIGGERPOCKETS
About this episode

2023’s insurance market is bad. Really bad. “As bad as I’ve ever seen,” says Insurance Office of America’s Robert J. Hamilton. He’s never seen home and multifamily insurance prices as high as today. But, he has good reason to believe that a better insurance market could be upon us soon, especially as prices continue to ramp up and providers get priced out of the market. 

If you’re a property owner, there’s a good chance your insurance premium increased significantly in price last year and the year before. After several unprecedented natural disasters, states like Texas, Florida, and California have seen carriers massively raise rates or leave their markets entirely. But why now? And how long will this last? Robert walks us through exactly what’s caused the higher insurance rates, why so many carriers have given up or died out, and “the beginning of a reset” that could be on the horizon.

Andrew Cushman, long-time friend of the show and multifamily investor, gives his seven quick tips on finding a better rate and protecting your property if and when disaster strikes. DO NOT analyze another deal before you watch this episode because, by the time you finish, your new insurance rate could ruin the profit potential. 

In This Episode We Cover:

The wild 2023 insurance crisis explained and why rates have gone up so dramatically

The “capacity crunch” forcing insurance carriers to leave risky markets 

What’s causing rates to rise and the “reinsurance” problem carriers face 

Underwriting your next rental/multifamily and how to properly predict property insurance costs 

The safest states/areas to invest in that carriers are flocking to 

The “percentage deductible” trap that could bankrupt your deal if you aren’t careful 

And So Much More!

Links from the Show

Find an Agent

Find a Lender

BiggerPockets Youtube Channel

BiggerPockets Forums

BiggerPockets Pro Membership

BiggerPockets Bookstore

BiggerPockets Bootcamps

BiggerPockets Podcast

BiggerPockets Merch

Listen to All Your Favorite BiggerPockets Podcasts in One Place

Learn About Real Estate, The Housing Market, and Money Management with The BiggerPockets Podcasts

Get More Deals Done with The BiggerPockets Investing Tools

Find a BiggerPockets Real Estate Meetup in Your Area

Davids's BiggerPockets Profile

David's Instagram

Network with Other Investors on the BiggerPockets Forums

How to Protect Your Rental from Fires, Floods, Lawsuits, and Liability

What Is Rental Property Insurance & Do Landlords Need It?

Book Mentioned in the Show:

SCALE by David Greene

Connect with Andrew:

Andrew's BiggerPockets Profile

Andrew's LinkedIn

Andrew's Website

Connect with Robert:

Robert's Email


Click here to listen to the full episode: https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/real-estate-819

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email advertise@biggerpockets.com.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Yesterday
2025 Long-Distance Investing Blueprint (Listen Before Buying)
Can’t make the numbers work in your local market? No worries—long-distance real estate investing is the natural next step. We’ve done it before, many times, and made the beginner mistakes, so you don’t have to. Now, we’re gearing up to do it again. Dave and Henry are heading out ... Show More
41m 2s
Jul 7
Replacing His Income with Rentals (in 3 Years!) by “Recycling” Money
In just three years, this investor scaled up to making over $100,000 per year thanks to real estate. He did it all starting in 2022 when interest rates were beginning to rise, the market was turning, and many investors decided to sit on their hands. Thanks to a strategy that allo ... Show More
40m 2s
Jul 4
How to Buy Real Estate Without Banks (Private Money Lending)
Can’t (or don’t want to) get a bank loan? We have another option for funding your real estate investments: private money lending! If your DTI (debt-to-income) is too high, you’ve maxed out how many mortgages you can get, or you need quick cash to finance a renovation, house flip, ... Show More
40m 14s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2022
171: The 2022 Housing Market Explained: Is Now a Good Time to Buy? w/Dave Meyer
The 2022 housing market is off to a wild start. We’ve seen home inventory at decade lows, interest rates have finally started to rise, and more homebuyers are looking at fewer houses. As a real estate investor, it can be tough to navigate a market like this, especially when you’v ... Show More
1 h
Sep 2021
Everything You Need to Know About Homeowner's & Renter's Insurance
This episode is your masterclass in everything you need to know about home owner's and renter's insurance. Steve Lekas, co-founder and CEO of Branch Insurance, is here to educate and demystify all things homeowner’s insurance.  We talk about it all, how much insurance should you ... Show More
39m 47s
Nov 2022
53: 5 Ways to Win During a Down Housing Market
Knowing how to invest during a recession is what separates the good from the great investors. Most veteran real estate investors know that during downtimes, the lucky landlords get swept away while the intelligent investors start to pad their pockets with deals others are too sca ... Show More
57m 30s
Mar 2024
203: Compass Settles for $57.5 Million, Inventory Jumps, Fed Talks Rate Cuts
Compass is the latest brokerage to settle after the recent NAR lawsuit made sweeping changes to agent commission payments. With NAR, Keller Williams, Compass, and more associations and brokerages paying out massive settlement fees and rewriting their agent agreements, could we be ... Show More
40m 54s
Jun 2023
113: ‘08 Crash Predictor Ivy Zelman on The Biggest Danger Facing Real Estate Today
The housing market is stuck. Stubborn homeowners with low rates refuse to move, even as demand starts to pick back up. Homebuilders are driving ahead with more new construction homes, but is it too late to deliver the supply we so desperately needed only a year or two ago? Where ... Show More
52m 54s
Dec 2022
58: The iBuyer Massacre and Why Most Will Never Survive w/Mike DelPrete
Zillow, Opendoor, and other iBuyers made quite a name for themselves over the past two years. By buying up every house on the block, iBuyers quickly became the “no work, best price, all cash” alternative to selling through an agent or a wholesaler. These huge, wall-street funded ... Show More
1h 1m
Aug 2023
1022 - “This Is The Hardest Property Insurance Market Ever”—What’s Forcing Carriers To Pull Out In Droves? by Datha Santomieri
Your offer was just accepted on a beautiful property in Central Florida just a few miles from the coast. The income you will make from this short-term rental will fund your early retirement plans. Everything is humming along relatively smoothly—until you get your quote back for t ... Show More
11m 12s
Mar 2020
3: Coronavirus Crash? Do's and Don'ts from Recession Veterans Joe Asamoah and Steve Rozenberg
It's a new week... and, seemingly, a new world.So -- we've got a new (and very fresh) episode for you... with a twist on our usual format.On Tuesday, March 17, Ashley and Felipe sat down with Joe Asamoah and Steve Rozenberg to discuss the topic on everyone's mind: the COVID-19 ou ... Show More
1h 2m
Jul 2022
15: Renting vs. Buying a House: Which Makes More Sense in 2022? w/Ken Johnson
Renting vs buying a house. It’s an easy decision. If you have the option to buy, you should buy. Shouldn’t you? That line of thinking, according to Ken Johnson, real estate economics expert, can cost you a lot of money. His team at Florida Atlantic University, along with other da ... Show More
1h 12m
Jun 2023
118: The Next “Wave” of Foreclosures and Markets With the Deepest Discounts w/Auction.com’s Daren Blomquist
The next foreclosure wave is already brewing. Over the past few years, monetary moves and rash home buying decisions were made that could cause even more foreclosures to hit the market. The question is, which markets will face the most foreclosures, and how low will prices go? Bu ... Show More
42m 56s