logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2023
36m 57s

Alone in Ossipee: Florence Small Pt. 2

SPOTIFY STUDIOS
About this episode

Prosecutors Walter Hill and James P. Tuttle were faced with a difficult task. They had to convince a jury that Frederick Small could burn down a cottage from a hundred miles away. They would get their chance with the help of an electrician who was ready to testify. 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Sep 2023
Irene Garza Pt. 1
On the evening of April 16, 1960, Irene Garza went to church in the peaceful town of McAllen, Texas but never came home. Less than a week later, her body was found in a canal. Residents were terrified. Had a predator come to town to prey on them, or was one of their own a murdere ... Show More
37m 30s
Aug 2023
Party Fouls: House Party Horror
In 2011, 17-year-old Tyler Hadley threw a wild house party in Port St. Lucie, Florida. What his guests didn’t know was that on the other side of a locked door, dead bodies lay hidden. A jarring confession ignited a race against time to end the revelry for good. This episode origi ... Show More
34m 17s
Aug 2023
The Clutter Family Pt. 2
After the massacre of the Clutter Family on November 15th, 1959, the Kansas Bureau of Investigation began an intensive probe into the crime. Their search for the killers would result in one of the greatest true crime stories of all time. This episode originally aired in June 2019 ... Show More
47m 56s
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2022
The Atlanta Lawyer Who Killed His Wife | Fred Tokars
Fred Tokars was, at best, an unlikely criminal. As a one-time prosecutor and defense attorney, Tokars had seen both sides of the process and what happens to those convicted of crimes. Yet Tokars was faced with exposure of exactly what he was (a felon with ongoing criminal enterpr ... Show More
33m 43s
Aug 2022
The Dark Side of Dr. Dale, Pt. 2
After the death of his son Sean, Dr. John Dale Cavaness was forced to go head-to-head with detectives. It quickly became apparent that even though he was a beloved member of the community, it didn't mean he could get away with murder. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podca ... Show More
50m 52s
Apr 2021
EP. 13 MINNESOTA: A Mother's Murder: The Needless Killing of Carol Thompson
This murder was the inspiration for the movie "FARGO". Our story takes place in St. Paul, Minnesota, in a neighborhood called Highland Park. It’s March of 1963, and the homes within this neighborhood are filled with members of the upper-middle class. It was a neighborhood that a ... Show More
27m 47s
Jan 2022
Sam Sheppard Pt. 2
In the aftermath of Marilyn Sheppard’s murder, media speculation drove the narrative against her husband Sam. He was convicted and imprisoned for a decade before getting a second chance at freedom. Sam Sheppard finally had a new lease on life — but his reinvention would come at a ... Show More
55m 1s
May 9
Bad Rap: A "Good Juror"
As the jury pool for Sean Combs' trial is narrowed down, Brian Buckmire does a deep dive into the process. Jury experts say it’s more like jury “de-selection” than selection. Picking a jury is about trying to eliminate potential jurors who might be bad for your side, while leavin ... Show More
26 m
May 26
Episode 1020: (Day 17) The body under the staircase - Richard Satchwell murder trial
The jury at the murder trial of Richard Satchwell has been told that they will have three options: to convict him of murder, of manslaughter, or to acquit him.Justice Paul McDermott in his charge to the jury told them they will enter their deliberations as independent people with ... Show More
26m 30s
May 8
Chapter 14 | A Town on Trial
Unpacking the trial of Delbert Tallman and making the case that Tallman is NOT Heidi Martin’s likely killer.Special thank you to the following Dark Valley listeners for their dedicated support of the show: M Charles, Tara F, Debie Burton, Sandi C. W., Parker D. and Brian Denman.  ... Show More
1 h
Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami