Late one night in September 1916, a cottage in New Hampshire burst into flames. Florence Small’s body was eventually found in the cellar — but it was clear she’d suffered more than just burns. Less than 24 hours later, police had a suspect. There was only one problem: he had an alibi.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Jan 2024
S2 E18: Held his Victims in a Tree: The Treehouse Murders
In Apple Valley, Ohio, 32 y/o Tina Herman never showed up for her 4 o’clock shift shift at dairy queen. When she no call no showed, her employees tried calling and texting to see if Tina was okay but was met with no answer. Tina’s manager, Valarie Haythorn, drove to TIna’s house ... Show More
30m 20s
Jul 2025
Ep. 60 | The Most Puzzling & Disturbing Disappearance Case
When Christine Collins' 9-year-old son vanished in 1928, she never gave up hope. But months later, the LAPD claimed to have found him—except Christine knew the boy wasn’t hers. In this episode, we follow along her fight for the truth against a system determined to silence her, an ... Show More
1h 4m
Aug 2023
6: MURDER: Thomas Dorr Sr.
On January 7, 1996, a historic blizzard hit eastern New York, covering the area with over two feet of snow. That evening, Thomas Dorr Sr., a volunteer firefighter, received a call asking him to come to the station and help with any emergencies that might occur. Tom agreed to go, ... Show More
38m 13s
Sep 2021
Deathbed Survivor: Jeffrey Gafoor
In 1988, British police found the remains of a gruesomely murdered woman in a flat in Cardiff, UK. The woman had over 50 stab wounds on her body. The murder went unsolved until 2003, when a man named Jeffrey Gafoor confessed after taking a lethal dose of paracetemol tablets…
Lear ... Show More
51m 45s
Aug 6
Ep. 64 | The BRUTAL Unsolved Hinterkaifeck Massacre
Get better sleep, hair and skin with Blissy and use CCCM to get an additional 30% off at blissy.com/CCCM In 1922, six people were brutally murdered on a remote German farm—and the killer may have stayed in the house afterward. With bizarre clues and no clear suspects, the Hinterk ... Show More
1h 2m
Nov 14
The Last Hours of John O’Keefe: What Really Happened?
On a snowy January night, Boston police officer John O’Keefe ended up dead in the front yard of a house he never walked into — and his girlfriend, Karen Read, became the center of a case that tore an entire community apart. In this episode, we break down the investigation, the ru ... Show More
34m 46s