logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2023
59m 1s

Sexual Consent

ELLIE ANDERSON, PH.D. AND DAVID PEñA-GUZMáN, PH.D.
About this episode

This episode gets an enthusiastic yes from us. In episode 85 of Overthink, Ellie and David dive into the crux of sexual consent. They work through some of the earliest attempts on the part of American universities at developing a sexual consent policy, before unpacking the fiery debates surrounding consent today — ranging from complex legal cases as well as instances of “gray rape.” They probe the limits of popular understandings of consent with cases involving intense physical pain, and cases which undo the very stability of our idea of consent. (Can one meaningfully consent to one’s own murder?) They explore Ellie’s own proposal for rethinking our idea of consent. Is consent contractual? Performative? Magic? And, should it really be the central tenet of our sexual ethics?

Content warning: this episode contains graphic discussions of sexual violence and bodily harm.
Check out the episode's extended cut here!

Works Discussed

Linda Martín Alcoff, Rape and Resistance
Ellie Anderson, “A Phenomenological Approach to Sexual Consent” and “The Limits of Consent in Sexual Ethics”
Katherine Angel, Tomorrow Sex Will Be Good Again
Ann Cahill, Rethinking Rape
Heidi Hurd, “The Moral Magic of Consent”
Jonathan Ichikawa, “Presupposition and Consent”
Joseph Fischer, Screw Consent
Joan McGregor, Is it Rape?
Caleb Ward and Ellie Anderson, “The Ethical Significance of Being an Erotic Object”
Bari Weiss, “Aziz Ansari Is Guilty. Of Not Being a Mind Reader”
Is It Date Rape? (1991 SNL Skit)

Support the show

Patreon | patreon.com/overthinkpodcast
Website | overthinkpodcast.com
Instagram & Twitter | @overthink_pod
Email | dearoverthink@gmail.com
YouTube | Overthink podcast

Up next
Aug 12
Burnout
What makes burnout different from exhaustion or fatigue? In episode 136 of Overthink, Ellie and David look at the history of the term burnout and its surprising connection to social justice. They also explore Byung-Chul Han’s reading of burnout as a natural consequence of “achiev ... Show More
59m 38s
Jul 29
Travel
Aperol spritzes, ‘Euro summers’, and aesthetic beach pics. In episode 135 of Overthink, Ellie and David discuss all things travel. They discuss the differences how travel changes our relationship to the place where we're from, the difference between travel and tourism, and the pl ... Show More
58m 50s
Jul 15
Weirdness with Eric Schwitzgebel
All metaphysical theories are…really weird. In episode 134 of Overthink, Ellie and David chat with Eric Schwitzgebel about his book Weirdness of the World. They think through the difference between weirdness and bizarreness, the nonsensical nature of philosophical theories, and w ... Show More
56m 57s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2022
Consent and "Enthusiastic Maybe"
This week, Emily answers a question from her producer, Mo, about consent. Mo and her girlfriend are considering a new sexual experience but they’re not both an “enthusiastic yes” on the idea. Mo’s girlfriend joins the conversation, and they delve into the idea of “enthusiastic ma ... Show More
49m 49s
Mar 2018
Sexe sans consentement : le rôle des hommes
Elles ont cédé, ou capitulé. Ce rapport sexuel, elles n’en voulaient pas. Le garçon avec qui elles étaient n’a pas compris - ou pas voulu comprendre - leur “non”. La journaliste et réalisatrice Delphine Dhilly a rencontré des femmes qui ont eu des rapports sexuels non désirés au ... Show More
39m 7s
Oct 2020
Je te veux, moi non plus
Il est grand temps de redéfinir le consentement. Aujourd’hui, on le caractérise en opposition à un viol ou à une agression sexuelle. Pourtant, être en couple ne veut pas dire que toute relation sexuelle est consentie et désirée par les deux parties. La notion de consentement rest ... Show More
30m 58s
Oct 2023
Fucking Feelings: The Attunement Model of Consent
In Episode 56, we announce that Fucking Cancelled has moved to substack! Please follow us fuckingcancelled.substack.com if you haven’t already, and consider becoming a supporter of the pod for $5 Canadian a month. You’ll get a bunch of bonus content and help keep the podcast aliv ... Show More
1h 28m
May 2022
How To Make Sexual Consent Sexy
After experiencing multiple instances of sexual assault, Julia often feels sexually disconnected from her own body. She wants to be aware of her boundaries and find pleasure in new relationships going forward. On this episode of How To!, we bring on Jamila Dawson, licensed marria ... Show More
39m 22s
Apr 2024
Nous faire justice | Changer la loi sur le viol
Aujourd’hui en France, le viol est un crime quasiment impuni : seulement 1% des affaires de viol aboutissent à une condamnation des agresseurs. Ce chiffre s’explique en partie par la façon dont notre loi est écrite. Car pour condamner un viol, il ne suffit pas de prouver qu’on n’ ... Show More
1h 22m
Apr 2023
S15 E12: [Consent Awareness Network] Consent in Our Lives and Laws
*Content Warning: sexual assault, rape, coercive control, emotional violence, fraud, legal abuse.  ACTION ITEM - SIGN THE PETITION: http://bit.ly/BillPetition DONATE to CAN: https://consentawareness.net/donate/ CONTACT CAN: Info@ConsentAwareness.net Joyce’s TedX Talk:  http://bit ... Show More
44m 26s
Jul 2023
Sexualité et Consentement
Lorsque l’on aborde la question du “cul”, on réalise rapidement que l’éducation sexuelle est très limitée ! Ou pas hyper bien enseignée. Alors j’ai décidé, comme à mon habitude, de mettre les pieds dans le plat ! Dans cet épisode, nous allons parler de sexualité, et plus particul ... Show More
1h 23m
Nov 2023
How can you ensure sexual consent? - Согласие на секс: Как убедиться, что оно обоюдное и добровольное?
In Australia, non-consensual sexual activity is a criminal offence, whether it takes place in real life or online. In some jurisdictions, alleged perpetrators accused of sexual assault or rape must prove in court that they obtained consent before engaging in sexual activity. So, ... Show More
10m 9s
Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami