logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2023
50m 8s

The Disappearance of Peggy McGuire

Not Your Mom Media
About this episode

This week we will be discussing the tumultuous relationship between Peggy McGuire and her husband Thomas McIntosh. Despite attempts to leave the relationship, including seeking a protective order, she tragically disappeared in November 2015 with her family still searching for answers. 

Thank you to Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research for your help in researching this episode!

Ways to get involved with Season of Justice:

* Go to givebutter.com/fallmoms to make a donation to Season of Justice. 

  • All donors will be entered into a raffle to win a COSMO JrTrack™ 2 SE Kids Smart Watch! Winner will be announced by Melissa and Mandy on Monday, September 18, 2023 on Instagram!
  • Shoutout donors who gave $25 or more on an upcoming episode of Moms and Mysteries!

OR

*Text MOMSOJ to 53555 to make a donation 

  • Email your receipt to momsandmysteries@gmail.com if you would like to enter in the raffle for a COSMO JrTrack 2 SE Kids Smart Watch! Winner will be announced by Melissa and Mandy on Monday, September 18, 2023 on Instagram!
  •  If you give over $25, email your receipt to momsandmysteries@gmail.com and we will give you a shout out in an upcoming episode! 

Thank you to this week’s sponsors!

Visit www.cosmotogether.com and enter code MYSTERIES at checkout for 30% off a new JrTrack watch just in time for back to school.

As a special offer for listeners, new customers GET $5 OFF a Lume Starter Pack with code MOMS at LumeDeodorant.com. That equates to over 40% off your Starter Pack when you visit LumeDeodorant.com and use code MOMS.

Join the more than 2 million families who have chosen K12, and empower your student to reach their full potential now. Go to K12.com/MOMS today to learn more and find a tuition-free K12-powered school near you.

New merch! Check out Moms and Mysteries Threadless! You can also get new episodes a day early and ad free, plus merch and more at Patreon.com/momsandmysteriespodcast

Listen and subscribe to Melissa’s other podcast, Criminality!! It’s the podcast for those who love reality TV, true crime, and want to hear all the juicy stories where the two genres intersect. Subscribe and listen here: www.pod.link/criminality 

Check-out Moms and Mysteries to find links to our tiktok, youtube, twitter, instagram and more!

Make sure you subscribe and rate our show to help others find us!

Sources can be found at momsandmysteries.com//episodes/the-disappearance-of-peggy-mcguire

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Today
MISSING: Jennifer Kesse
In this episode, we are sharing the heartbreaking and mysterious disappearance of Jennifer Kesse, a case that has haunted Orlando for nearly two decades, with little progress or answers for her family. Anyone with information about Jennifer Kesse’s disappearance is urged to conta ... Show More
36m 39s
Jul 8
MURDERED: Clara Phillips, Tiger Woman
In this episode, we dive into the shocking murder of Alberta Meadows by Clara Phillips, a glamorous showgirl whose jealous rage turned deadly. After killing Alberta with a hammer, Clara staged a sensational escape, fleeing 4,000 miles through Central America before her capture in ... Show More
54m 37s
Jul 3
UPDATE: Amy Bishop-Mad Scientist
In this updated episode, we're revisiting a case we covered back in 2020: the shocking story of Amy Bishop, who committed a mass shooting at the University of Alabama in Huntsville in 2010. Since we first discussed the case, there have been several important updates. Stick with u ... Show More
38m 34s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2022
Amy Lynn Bradley
Ep 79: A family’s Caribbean cruise was cut short when their 23-year-old daughter vanished while onboard.The desperate search across several borders left her family with few clues… and worried about a sinister fate.This is the Amy Lynn Bradley Story Sources for Today's Episode: Th ... Show More
43m 50s
Sep 2022
Maggie Long
Ep 94: A family’s frustration mounts as the murder of their teenage daughter goes unsolved. But would a new FBI classification help provide any answers?This is the Maggie Long story Sources for Today's Episode: The flume.com Court TV 9NEWS CPR.org Dateline NBC news Medium.com CBS ... Show More
46m 33s
Jun 2022
Mary Kay Letourneau
Ep 80: This teacher made national headlines when she was caught having an inappropriate and illegal relationship.But even after getting caught and being warned by the courts to stay away from her victim, could this woman keep apart from her claimed true love? This is the Mary Kay ... Show More
48m 38s
Sep 2023
Michelle Hadley
Ep 145: A U.S. Marshal’s new wife becomes the target of an online sexual predator scheme. Is his ex-girlfriend to blame, or is something more sinister going on? This is the Michelle Hadley Story Sources for Today's Episode: An Episode of Dateline Buzz Feed News NBC News The New Y ... Show More
40m 2s
Apr 2022
Kelly Cochran
Ep 74: A frantic 911 call from a wife brings paramedics to a home where her husband has died from an apparent drug overdose.But this woman was no stranger to the authorities and her husband’s death would prove key to unlocking a much bigger mystery This is the Kelly Cochran episo ... Show More
53m 44s
Nov 2021
Diane Schuler
Ep 61: A weekend camping trip with family and nieces ends in tragedy, when a 36-year-old mother of two turns heads as she drove erratically on the wrong side on the road, causing an accident that would expose secrets and cause a family divide. Sources for Today's Episode: CBS New ... Show More
44m 21s
Jun 2021
Kelly Ann Tinyes
Ep 52: On the afternoon of March 3, 1989, in Valley Stream, NY, a thirteen-year old girl watching her younger brother received a phone call. When she hung up, she told her brother that she was going to sneak out to a friend’s for a little while and would be back soon.But “a littl ... Show More
41m 22s
Apr 2019
Ep. 191 Something Bad Happened (true crime for sensitive people)
True crime is having a MOMENT, Awesomes, and it has been for a few years now! But for those of us who are Highly Sensitive People, it's easy to feel left out of this cultural conversation because some true crime stories are just too disturbing to tune into. However, Meg's sister ... Show More
1h 7m
Jun 2022
Wendy DiRodio: “Deadly Envy” | MURDERISH Ep. 112
At 61 years old, Wendy DiRodio’s life was just getting started. An accomplished author, therapist anddance instructor, she was ready to excel in the only part of life where success had escaped her: love.She’d begun dating a handsome younger man; there was even talk of marriage. S ... Show More
55m 4s
Dec 2016
Melissa Huckaby
8 year old Sandra Cantu went missing from the mobile home park she lived at on March 27, 2009. A massive search would begin immediately for the little girl. Suspicion would soon fall on the most unlikeliest of suspects, a 28 year old woman who lived in the same mobile home park a ... Show More
1h 8m