logo
episode-header-image
May 2021
41m 38s

"Mall Santa" Bruce McArthur Pt. 1

SPOTIFY STUDIOS
About this episode

For most of his life, Bruce McArthur led an unremarkable existence. But in the 1990s, he split from his wife and moved to Toronto's gay village — free to be his true self. Unfortunately, McArthur's true self was violent, bloodthirsty... and murderous.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Oct 6
The Doomsday Murders
This episode first aired on April 14, 2025. The sordid story of Chad and Lori Daybell hit national news in 2020: missing children, suspicious deaths, and a trail of fringe religious beliefs. We’re diving in with author and former criminal defense attorney Lori Hellis, whose book ... Show More
40m 37s
Sep 29
Albert Fish
This episode first aired on August 19, 2024. He’s been called many names: the Boogeyman, the Thrill Vulture, the Moon Maniac, the Werewolf of Wysteria… But in life, he was known as Albert Fish and his gruesome crimes redefined the limits of human depravity. Stay up to date with c ... Show More
37m 12s
Sep 22
Jolly Jane Toppan (And an Announcement!)
This episode first aired on January 15, 2018. On the outside, Jane Toppan seemed like a loving nurse who cared deeply for her patients. But for years, she used her nursing skills to experiment with medicines…and kill the people who trusted her the most. Stay up to date with chang ... Show More
49m 20s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2020
“Part of the Family” Pt. 1: Karen Severson and Laura Doyle
A revenge plot turned deadly in 1985 after two teenage girls unleashed their jealous rage on their former friend, Missy Avila. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
44m 43s
Jan 2021
Brittany Murphy’s Death Pt. 1
Her breakout role in 1995’s “Clueless” made her America’s sweetheart. But was Brittany Murphy also a murder victim? The 32-year-old died under mysterious circumstances in 2009, and when her widower died of the exact cause just months later, Murphy’s mobster father cried “murder.” ... Show More
49m 15s
Mar 2022
Barbara Graham Pt. 1
After a botched burglary led to the murder of 64-year-old Mabel Monahan in Burbank, California, an anonymous tipster gave police their first big break in the case. But was 29-year-old Barbara Graham pinned for a crime she never committed? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit p ... Show More
43m 53s
Jul 2019
Michael Skakel Pt. 1: The Murder of Martha Moxley
On October 30th, 1975, 15-year-old Martha Moxley was murdered less than a 100 yards from her front door. The police felt certain of the identity of her killer, but wouldn't be able to press charges for over twenty years. Sponsors! Gabi - Take 2 minutes and see if you can save up ... Show More
48m 11s
Jul 2021
"The Murder Farm" Belle Gunness Pt. 2
There's still so much mystery surrounding the fate of Belle Gunness, and what exactly happened on her now-infamous murder farm. The truth may be just as terrifying as the rumors… Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
43m 53s
Oct 2020
Daedalus and Icarus Pt. 1
After committing a terrible crime, a cocky young inventor flees to Crete and finds himself in the service of the mad king Minos. There, he becomes the world’s greatest creator… and the world’s worst father to his teenage son, Icarus. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcas ... Show More
50m 41s
Oct 2020
Stacey Lannert Pt. 1
In 1990, after a decade of abuse at her father’s hands—and a devastating incident involving her younger sister—18-year-old Stacey Lannert reached a tipping point. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
47m 28s
Sep 13
Part 6: Roen
Seventeen years after the Wild Boys turned host Sam Mullins’s hometown upside down, he sets out to find the brothers and their family, and get the full story for the first time. Wild Boys is part of The Binge. Hooked on Wild Boys? You’ll love The Binge — Subscribers unlock an ent ... Show More
36m 33s
Jan 2022
The Brides in the Bath Murders Pt. 2
In 1915, Scotland Yard detective Arthur Neil had three deceased brides, one suspect, and tons of circumstantial evidence. But he needed something more concrete. Luckily for him, that something walked right through the door. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.c ... Show More
45m 49s