logo
episode-header-image
May 2023
52m 26s

Florida's New Capital Punishment Regime

Robert Scavone Jr.
About this episode

Florida recently amended its death penalty statute to allow for a non-unanimous jury decision on whether to impose the death sentence. Governor DeSantis also signed into law a statute the permits the death penalty for aggravated sexual assault of the child under 12. Both statutes are certain to be challenged on constitutional grounds.

On this episode, Melanie Kalmanson joins me to discuss the new laws and how they they might play out when they reach the U.S. Supreme Court. 

Melanie is an associate at Quarles where she concentrates her practice on commercial litigation and appellate representation. She clerked for Justice Pariente on the Supreme Court of Florida for 2-1/2 years. Melanie has a fantastic substate called Tracking Florida’s Death Penalty. It is packed with information about capital sentencing in Florida. Her scholarship, which includes several law review articles, focuses on constitutional issues related to capital sentencing. Melanie has written for Slate and has op eds on the capital sentencing in the Orlando Sentinel, the Miami Herald, The Sun Sentinel, and other news publications.

Capital Sexual Battery Law
8-4 Law

DPIC: Laws permitting the death penalty for crimes other than murder by state.

Summarily is supported by The Law Office of Scott N. Richardson, P.A.

Send your questions, comments, and feedback to summarilypod@gmail.com.

Disclaimer: This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not an advertisement for legal services.  The information provided on this podcast is not intended to be legal advice.  You should not rely on what you hear on this podcast as legal advice. If you have a legal issue, please contact a lawyer.  The views and opinion expressed by the hosts and guests are solely those of the individuals and do not represent the views or opinions of the firms or organizations with which they are affiliated or the views or opinions of this podcast’s advertisers.  This podcast is available for private, non-commercial use only.  Any editing, reproduction, or redistribution of this podcast for commercial use or monetary gain without the expressed, written consent of the podcast’s creator is prohibited.

Up next
Apr 1
Goodbye
Hey folks. Robert here. I have decided to step away from the podcast for an indeterminate period of time. Thank you for listening and for your support. 🔗 Connect with the Hosts:Joni Mosely – TheMoselyFirm.comSpencer Charif – CharifLaw.com 
37s
Feb 2025
Capital Punishment and Immigration: The word "shall" is a problem.
Melanie Kalmanson, a partner at Quarlers & Brady, joined Robert to discuss a new Florida statute that requires judges to impose a sentence of death if an "unauthorized alien" commits a capital offense. Melanie and Robert examine potential constitutional issues the law faces under ... Show More
31m 47s
Feb 2025
The Great Debate: Tanenbaum vs. Scavone
On February 6, Robert debated Judge Adam Tanenbaum (First DCA) about whether the prior-panel rule applies in the DCAs. The rule requires 3-judge appellate panels to follow prior-panel precedent unless the court overrules the prior precedent en banc or the precedent has been overr ... Show More
1h 26m
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2023
COJ #21: Randy Murdaugh Hits the Reset Button and Russell Laffitte Has Bills to Pay
One week after Alex Murdaugh was sentenced to life for killing his wife and son, Murdaugh Murders Podcast co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell — and everyone’s favorite attorney Eric Bland — take a look at the questions surrounding a juror’s connections to a witness, the problem ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2023
75 - « Elle fait une lettre à la police comme quoi elle ne veut plus voir les enfants »
Parents séparés, enfants malmenés -  Affaire jugée au Tribunal correctionnel de Mont-de-Marsan.  À travers un tour de France des tribunaux, Justice en direct rend compte sans artifice, ni commentaire, au plus près de la réalité, du déroulement des audiences correctionnelles qui r ... Show More
24m 24s
Aug 2022
The Supreme Court's power grab
Sean Illing talks with Harvard Law professor Nikolas Bowie about the U.S. Supreme Court's recently-concluded term, which produced landmark opinions restricting the power of the EPA, expanding gun rights, and overturning Roe v. Wade. They discuss how the conservative court's argum ... Show More
1h 5m
Mar 2018
Introducing Felonious Florida
A true-crime podcast series that explores some of Florida’s most notorious and chilling crimes. Reported and hosted by Lisa Arthur and Juan Ortega, veteran reporters for the South Florida Sun Sentinel. Premieres April 3 with a look at the Casey's Nickelodeon Murders of 1994 and t ... Show More
1m 54s
Feb 2021
EXONERATED: Run This Man His MONEY $$$
Very little turns our stomachs like false accusations, false convictions, and false imprisonments. It’s time up for that sh*t. And we’re getting to the nitty and the gritty of it on this episode of Holding Court with Jimmy Dennis who was exonerated after spending 25 years on deat ... Show More
55m 55s
Aug 2022
Nikolas Cruz’s death penalty hearing; Kristin Smart murder trial delays — TCD Sidebar
In this episode of True Crime Daily The Sidebar Podcast: Dr. Tracy A. Pearson joins host Joshua Ritter to break down the biggest cases making headlines across the nation. They discuss new evidence in Nikolas Cruz’s sentencing hearing (2:30) and further delays in the trial of Paul ... Show More
48m 8s
May 2020
Criminal Minds
One place where law and morality are supposed to agree is that there should be no crime without a criminal mind, what is called “mens rea” in criminal law. But there have been a proliferation of crimes that do not require knowledge or intent, contributing to over-prosecution and ... Show More
56m 24s
Jun 2020
Episode 78 - The Whitaker Family
December 2003 was a special time for Kent and Tricia Whitaker. Their sons had returned home from University for the holidays, and they were happy to have the whole family back together again. Little did the Whitakers know it would be the last fond memory the family of 4 would sha ... Show More
50m 50s