Jan 23

From Classroom Crush to Contract Killing: Pamela Smart’s Secret

On a quiet New Hampshire street in 1990, a young husband was executed in his own home—what looked like a botched robbery quickly unraveled into something far darker. This episode explores the explosive case of Pamela Smart: a forbidden affair, teenage accomplices, a murder-for-hi ... Show More

1h 1m

Jan 16

The Most Prolific Serial Killer in U.S. History | Samuel Little

Listen ad-free with a 7-day FREE TRIAL of ⁠Crimehub Premium⁠. Cancel anytime. No commitment. 👉🏼 patreon.com/crimehub⁠. On New Year’s Eve 1970, a vulnerable woman named Mary Brosley was murdered after leaving a bar with a stranger—becoming the first known victim of Samuel Little ... Show More

32m 39s

Jan 9

The Genesee River Killer | Arthur Shawcross

In 1972, a friendly stranger named Art took two boys fishing in upstate New York—and only one ever came home. What followed was a catastrophic failure of justice that allowed a known child killer to walk free, reinvent himself, and go on to murder a dozen more victims as the Gene ... Show More

56m 29s

Nov 12

KIDNAPPED: Elizabeth Smart

In 2002, 14 year-old Elizabeth Smart was kidnapped from her Salt Lake City home in the middle of the night, sparking one of America’s most intense true crime investigations. For nine months, she was held captive by a self-proclaimed prophet and his wife: hidden in plain sight. Mo ... Show More

1h 33m

Jun 2025

Deadly Attraction

Thomas Capano was a successful Delaware lawyer who was living a double life. He was a devoted family man while having affairs with numerous women. When 30-year-old Anne Marie Fahey disappeared in June 1996, investigators believed Capano killed Anne Marie when she tried to break o ... Show More

44m 53s

Feb 2021

EP. 5 IDAHO - The Shasta Groene Story

This story contains descriptions of physical and sexual abuse against children. listener discretion is heavily advised. In 2005, a family was found brutally murdered after a random home invasion in Idaho, and the two youngest children from the clan went missing. What happened ... Show More

33m 35s

Oct 2024

Patricia Barrett (2 of Hearts, Utah)

<p>Our card this week is Patricia "Patti" Barrett, the 2 of Hearts from Utah.</p><p>When Patricia “Patti” Barrett got on a bus from Dallas to Salt Lake City in 1978, her family had no way of knowing they’d never see her again. For over 30 years they were left wondering what happe ... Show More

26m 21s

Mar 2025

Without a Trace

Esther Reed was a small-town girl from Montana, but from 1999-2008, she lived a double life. She assumed at least four different identities and went by the names Natalie Fisher, Natalie Bowman, Brook Henson and Jennifer Myers. She conned her way into Harvard and Columbia universi ... Show More

45m 28s

Oct 2022

S1 E21: Kids Who Kill Kids: Elizabeth Olten

Elizabeth Olten was a 9-year-old girl, from St.Martins, Missouri, that was like any other little girl. She loved to play dress up, sing Hannah Montana, and play with her neighbors, Emma and Alyssa Bustamante. Until one day, Elizabeth goes out to play with Emma but never returns h ... Show More

1h 2m

Jun 2019

Trust the Process | 1

On February 26th, 2014, the Andreacchio family suffered a tragic loss, the death of 21-year-old Christian Andreacchio. Host Dennis Cooper travels to Lauderdale, Mississippi to visit Christian's mother Rae and the rest of his family. Rae, laments the time lost with her son as thei ... Show More

34m 37s

Feb 2025

Valentine's Special: "A Couple of Kidnappers" - Wanda Barzee and Brian David Mitchell

For Valentine’s Day we’re going back into the archives to bring you some of the most infamous couples in true crime history. All Wanda Barzee wanted in life was for someone to take care of her, and in return she promised complete devotion. So when her paramour, self-styled prophe ... Show More

1h 15m

Elizabeth Smart | A Story of Survival