logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2023
39m 45s

Active Stock Picking Is Getting Harder

PENSIONCRAFT
About this episode

Some people claim that active managers can capitalise on market crashes to beat the benchmark. But do they really save us from being savaged by bears?

The analysts at S&P Dow Jones have been hard at work on their updated Index vs Active scorecard, and the numbers for 2022 are hot off the press.

The latest data reveals that UK active funds experienced their worst underperformance on record. We dig into the report to find out why.

And in today’s Dumb Question of the Week: Does passive investing work for Emerging Markets?

Selected links


---

Get in touch

📧 mhr@pensioncraft.com

🎧 many-happy-returns.captivate.fm

---

Join PensionCraft

🌐 Become a member at pensioncraft.com

▶️ Subscribe on YouTube

---

Disclaimer

This podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes and is not financial advice. We do not provide recommendations or endorse any decision to buy, sell or hold any security. We cannot be held responsible for any actions listeners may take and investors are encouraged to seek independent financial advice.


Copyright 2026 Many Happy Returns

Up next
Jun 10
Paws and Reflect: The Surprising Science of Who Wins at Investing
The best investors aren't necessarily the cleverest, the best-paid, or the most daring. In fact the evidence suggests they're closer to the opposite. We look at the backgrounds and temperaments that may outperform. And in the Dumb Question of the Week: Are cats better stockpicker ... Show More
47 m
Jun 3
Reserve Judgment: How To Run a Central Bank
The Powell era is over — a pandemic, two wars, and the worst inflation in four decades. We ask whether JPow did a good job, or just survived it. Now Kevin Warsh inherits the chair. But what actually changes? Beneath the handover lie bigger questions: what a central bank is really ... Show More
44m 26s
May 27
Space Oddity: Is the Biggest IPO in History a Problem for Index Funds?
The largest IPO in history is three weeks away. SpaceX is aiming for a valuation of almost $2 trillion despite reporting massive losses. We ask what happens when our beloved index funds are forced to buy the AI giants, whatever the price? And in the Dumb Question of the Week: Why ... Show More
40m 14s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2023
432: Hesitant to Invest? How to Avoid Running Out of Money During Retirement
Terrified of running out of money in retirement? Countless people share the same fear. With so much recent discourse surrounding inflation and a looming recession, you may have a tighter grip on your money than usual. Today’s guest is here to help cool some of your concerns. In t ... Show More
1h 1m
Apr 2017
Index Investing | How to buy VTSAX
What if everything you thought you knew about building wealth was holding you back from taking the simplest, most effective action? Jonathan and Brad dissect Jim Collins' stock series—the blueprint that reshaped how the FI community approaches index investing. Fresh off the birth ... Show More
52m 8s
Aug 2019
The Surprising Truth about Retirement
The Fed cuts interest rates for the first time since 2008. Procter & Gamble hits an all-time high. Apple gets a boost from services and wearables. Shopify rises. Pinterest pops. And Square stumbles. Analysts Ron Gross and Jason Moser discuss those stocks and weigh in on the lates ... Show More
40m 48s
Feb 2024
Active investors! Assemble
<p>Of course we all know that passive investing delivers superior returns. But what if everyone is investing passively? Is there a case for active investing then? Recent research has shown that the explosion in index funds has made equities slower to respond to news. And also, it ... Show More
17m 21s
May 2024
Short-Term Market Volatility Could Provide Long-Term Investing Opportunities
<p>Sarah Hansen, Morningstar Inc markets reporter, discusses how today’s market volatility could benefit investors who are focused on long-term investing. Mark Miller, Retirement Reboot author, calls the Medicare changes in 2024 at the pharmacy counter “the best news that few peo ... Show More
16m 38s
Jul 2022
320: Finance Friday: How to Invest When the 20-Year Grind Pays Off
Retirement strategies range from simple index fund investing all the way to full-on real estate development deals. What works for some investors won’t work for others. What’s most important to you is knowing what will or won’t work for your lifestyle. Some workers can easily do a ... Show More
1h 5m