logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2018
24m 2s

Burton-on-Trent: The Headmistress

Crime+Investigation
About this episode

In 1951, headmistress of the Burton-On-Trent High School, Winifred Mulley had dismissed six hundred girls for the Summer. Winifred lived in a house on the grounds of the school. She was signing off on a new home she had just purchased in Burton and was preparing to leave for her Summer holiday. She wasn’t feeling very well and so rather than leave that day for her trip; she decided to postpone it and get some rest. The following day when the domestic helper Mrs. Plummer knocked on the door, Winifred didn’t answer. Her bedroom door was locked and a cup of tea with a spoon— which Winifred never used, was sitting on the kitchen table. When the door was finally opened, what Mrs. Plummer saw would haunt her forever. 


Following each episode of Katherine Kelly's brand new TV series Murdertown, Benjamin Fitton from They Walk Among Us unpicks a new case from each location. Watch Murdertown exclusively on Crime+Investigation in the UK every Monday at 9pm from 3rd September and then straight after listen to a brand new story right here with the Murdertown podcast. You can get in touch using #Murdertown on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram.


Crime+Investigation's Murdertown podcast is hosted by Benjamin Fitton, written by Anna Priestland, produced by Sam Pearson and Chloe Frost, and edited by James Collopy.


SOURCES

Selection of Historical Newspaper Articles 1951 - 1964:

The Daily Mirror

The Courier & Advertiser, Scotland

The Yorkshire Post

The Birmingham Gazette

The Coventry Evening Telegraph

The Manchester Guardian


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Sep 2022
Southampton: The Murder of Teresa De Simone
In August 2009, the body of David Lace was exhumed from Kingston Cemetery in Portsmouth more than twenty years after he had died. Residents peered out from behind curtains as police stood guard. A blue and white tent covered the empty grave, and hessian sacks hid the names of nea ... Show More
31m 5s
Sep 2022
New Season Trailer
Every place we live has a story to tell. The Murdertown podcast returns for a brand new season of eight episodes this September with Benjamin Fitton from They Walk Among Us.Sign up now to Crime+Investigation Play, the only dedicated true crime streaming service to watch brand new ... Show More
1m 19s
Feb 2020
Introducing... Making a Monster: The Tapes
Crime+Investigation's brand new podcast series Making a Monster: The Tapes features exclusive interviews with some of the top minds in criminology. Hosted by Cherry Healey, the podcast series utilises exclusive, extra interviews with the expert forensic psychiatrists, psychologis ... Show More
52s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2024
The Murder of Patricia Scoville (Vermont)
On a crisp fall day in October of 1991, Patricia Scoville set out for a bike ride on the scenic Moss Glen Falls trails in Stowe, Vermont. When she hadn’t returned home more than two days later, Patty’s roommate reported her missing, triggering a search and rescue effort that soon ... Show More
37m 56s
Mar 2023
The Murders of Diane Compagna & Anne Psaradelis (New Hampshire)
NEW HAMPSHIRE, 1973: On July 11, 1973, 15-year old Diane Compagna swung her beach bag over her shoulder and headed out the door of her house in Merrimack, New Hampshire. She was off to a nearby lake to swim with her friend, 15-year old Anne Psaradelis. At least, that was the stor ... Show More
30m 20s
Mar 2024
Case 276: Claire Acocks & Margaret Penny
May 3 1991, was a typical Friday for 58-year-old Margaret Penny. In the afternoon, she visited the Old London Coiffure in the heart of Portland, Victoria, for her weekly hair appointment with 49-year-old Claire Acocks. But when the two women are found stabbed to death in the salo ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2024
The Murders of Malcolm, Elizabeth, and Page Jennings Part 1 (New Hampshire)
When a fire destroyed the home of respected local innkeepers, leaving it in ruins and revealing the horrifying aftermath of a double murder, the close-knit community of Jackson, New Hampshire faced an unthinkable tragedy. As detectives looked into the lives of the victims, they d ... Show More
41m 44s
Sep 2019
Mrs. Sherlock Holmes
In 1917, 18-year-old Ruth Cruger disappeared. She’d last been seen getting her ice skates sharpened in the motorcycle shop of a man named Alfredo Cocchi. Newspapers reported that she probably ran off with a boyfriend, and New York police said that there were no clues to go on. Bu ... Show More
30m 31s
Aug 2020
How to Sell A Haunted House
In 1989, Helen Ackley decided to sell her old Victorian house in Nyack, New York at 1 Laveta Place. It didn’t go as planned. There were stories of ghosts, and the house became the center of a case that’s referred to as “The Ghostbusters ruling.” The judicial opinion read: “as a m ... Show More
33m 35s
Jun 2024
The Murder of Shari Lynn Roth (New Hampshire)
When Shari Lynn Roth left her apartment in North Conway, New Hampshire for a short afternoon hike to one of her favorite spots among the White Mountain National Forest, what should’ve been a peaceful retreat turned into a fateful encounter with a still unknown predator. Several t ... Show More
33m 43s
Apr 2016
Open Case
Since 1965, there's been an unsolved murder in Houston, Texas. The main suspect, Charles Rogers, managed to disappear and police were never able to find him. The case is still considered open. In 1997, a couple of forensic accountants named Hugh and Martha Gardenier decided to lo ... Show More
27m 18s