logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2023
2 m

Introducing: Why Can't We Talk About Ama...

ID
About this episode
In November 1993, a veteran discovers the body of a woman on a dirt road near Interstate-10 in Mobile, Alabama. She’s nude, drained of blood, and decapitated. But despite the horrific nature of the murder, it garners little sympathy in the press and detectives fail to close the case. Over the course of 8 episodes, host Sarah Cailean recounts her three-year investigation into this unsolved and perplexing murder that seems to leave more questions than answers. With the full support of the Mobile County Sheriff’s Office, she revisits the original investigation, digs up new evidence, and interviews new suspects - recording every step of the way. Cailean hopes to rectify the mistakes of the past and bring some answers to a family still struggling to make sense of what happened – and uncover just why it has been so hard to talk about.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Feb 2023
Ep.1: Renée - Why Can't We Talk About Amanda's Mom?
In November 1993, a veteran discovers the body of a woman on a little road near Interstate-10 in Mobile, Alabama. She’s nude, drained of blood, and decapitated. But despite the horrific nature of the murder, it garners little sympathy in the press and, worse, detectives fail to u ... Show More
45m 27s
Mar 2023
Ep.2: The Original Investigation - Why Can't We Talk About Amanda's Mom?
Sarah revisits the original 1993 investigation into the murder of Renee Bergeron and pretty quickly realizes that the detectives stumbled from the outset. Sarah tries to account for what - and who - they failed to understand in their original investigation. Hosted on Acast. See a ... Show More
45m 15s
Mar 2023
Ep.3: The Serial Killer’s Highway - Why Can't We Talk About Amanda's Mom?
Interstate-10 is known as the serial killer’s highway among criminologists. Given the brutal nature of her injuries and the fact that she was found dead on a service road running parallel to the highway, Sarah investigates the possibility that a serial killer might be responsible ... Show More
36m 16s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2024
Episode 2: “The Evidence of Things Not Seen”
As the search for Dana Stidham continues, her sudden disappearance baffles family, friends, and police, as everyone grows increasingly alarmed that Dana has met with foul play. Then, a break in the case comes as Paper Ghosts executive producer, host and investigative journalist M ... Show More
47m 51s
Jul 2025
Your Next Listen: Who Took Misty Copsey?
If you enjoyed listening to Disappeared: The Bradley Sisters, we have another podcast we think you'll like: Who Took Misty Copsey? Listen to Episode 1, "Misty is Missing" here.Cold case investigator Sarah Cailean takes on the 1992 disappearance of 14-year-old Misty Copsey, who va ... Show More
49m 32s
Mar 2024
Episode 4: “The Cave”
The investigation by the Benton County Sheriff’s Office heats up in Dana Stidham’s gruesome murder, zeroing in on one particular suspect.  Phelps digs deeper, speaking to the suspect and wonders if law enforcement has been chasing the wrong man. Just over the Missouri border, not ... Show More
38 m
Nov 14
The Last Hours of John O’Keefe: What Really Happened?
On a snowy January night, Boston police officer John O’Keefe ended up dead in the front yard of a house he never walked into — and his girlfriend, Karen Read, became the center of a case that tore an entire community apart. In this episode, we break down the investigation, the ru ... Show More
34m 46s
Oct 2020
Episode 7 - The Cops
A local woman’s evidence was dramatic and deeply disturbing - she was adamant that she saw Janine with her hands bound with baling twine and a look of grave distress on her face while in a small red car being driven by the town’s top cop. The woman had remained silent for four an ... Show More
1h 22m
Feb 2025
The Peggy Hettrick Case - Part 1
Part one of the investigation into the murder of 37-year-old Peggy Hettrick. In February 1987, her mutilated, half-naked body was discovered in a field near the Colorado home of Tim Masters, a 15-year-old boy. He told police he had seen the body on his way to school but, thinking ... Show More
45m 30s
Apr 2025
Girl Scouts Murdered at Summer Camp - The Unsolved Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders
On June 1977, three young Girl Scouts—Lori Farmer, Doris Milner, and Michelle Guse—were brutally murdered on their first night at Camp Scott in Oklahoma. The case shocked the nation, devastated their families, and despite decades of investigation… remains unsolved.In this weeks e ... Show More
30m 52s
Mar 2022
The Palmyra Island Murders Pt. 2
When human remains washed up on Palmyra Island, authorities confirmed they belonged to Muff Graham who had disappeared along with her husband seven years earlier. Immediately, the FBI had suspects in mind. But when they went to serve indictments, they learned some shocking news. ... Show More
42m 27s
Mar 2024
Shane and Sally | 3. An Open Investigation
In this episode, investigators Larry Counts and David Jones detail their initial steps in trying to solve the case—and share the story of how Shane and Sally started speaking with the authorities just months before they were killed. Then, officials at the Tom Green County Sheriff ... Show More
49m 8s