logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2022
15m 49s

REOPENED: The Punishment

A&E / PodcastOne
About this episode

Despite several mysterious and concerning clues, the drowning death of 6-year-old Sally Cheesboro is deemed a tragic accident. Over two decades later, Sally's sister is all grown up and determined to keep a promise she made to her baby sister.

Check out our great sponsors!

KiwiCo: Get your first month of ANY crate line FREE at kiwico.com/coldcase 

SimpliSafe: Get 40% off any new system at simplisafe.com/coldcase  

Progressive: Quote your car insurance at Progressive.com to join the over 27 million drivers who trust Progressive!

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Today
Baby For Sale / The Barrel
When a Nevada couple demands the return of a baby they had sold to another couple, the burned body of the baby turns up in Arizona. Then, a man discovers a barrel in his crawlspace that contains the body of a woman who has been dead for decades.This Episode is sponsored by Better ... Show More
40m 12s
Aug 23
I SURVIVED: I Had Blood Shooting Out Both Sides of Me
Harold, store manager, and his staff are held up and shot by two killers. John is 18-years-old when he has both his arms torn off in an accident on the family farm. At 17-years-olds Lisa is kidnapped and assaulted by a serial killer.Apartments.com - To find whatever you’re search ... Show More
35m 15s
Aug 21
REOPENED: The Punishment
Despite several mysterious and concerning clues, the drowning death of 6-year-old Sally Cheesboro is deemed a tragic accident. Over two decades later, Sally's sister is all grown up and determined to keep a promise she made to her baby sister. goPure: head to gopurebeauty.com and ... Show More
18m 52s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2023
I Could See Beneath The Blindfold
In November of 1984, 17-year-old Lisa McVey Noland was biking home from her job working the night shift at a local Tampa doughnut shop, when she was suddenly snatched off her bike and abducted. Being abducted was one of the worst things that happened to her but also saved her lif ... Show More
37m 35s
Jan 2024
I Felt Less Than Human
Vanessa Gay recounts her escape from Anthony Sowell in Cleveland, Ohio. Her mistrust of the police makes her reluctant to report her attack for many years. But eventually, her testimony would put her attacker behind bars. Sponsors: Progressive: Multitask right now. Quote your car ... Show More
34m 40s
Nov 2020
#282: American Murder: The Family Next Door, Part 5
Laura, Jim and Lisa continue their conversation with special guest Jenny Popplewell, the Director of the #1 Netflix show American Murder: The Family Next Door.Warning: This is an extremely upsetting watch and case and this series is a tough listen.Our thoughts are with Shanann's, ... Show More
30m 2s
Oct 2020
#279: American Murder: The Family Next Door, Part 2
Laura, Jim and Lisa continue to discuss the #1 Netflix show about ther murders of Shanann, Bella, Celeste and Nico Watts.Jim and Laura continue to deconstruct Chris Watt's behaviour and break down the police interview and strategy and Watt's confession.Warning: This is an extreme ... Show More
52m 19s
Oct 2020
#278: American Murder: The Family Next Door
Laura, Jim and Lisa deconstruct the number one Netflix show 'American Murder: The Family Next Door' about the murders of Shanann, Bella, Celeste and Nico Watts committed by husband and father, Chris Watts.Warning: this is an extremely distressing watch and our breakdown is a toug ... Show More
53m 57s
Oct 2020
#281: American Murder: The Family Next Door, Part 4
Laura, Jim and Lisa are joined by special guest Jenny Popplewell, the Director of the #1 Netflix show American Murder: The Family Next Door.Jenny takes us behind the scenes and explains why this case spoke to her as well as the gender bias in the media on reporting on domestic vi ... Show More
36m 24s
Oct 2023
JANA KRAMER RETURNS!
The country star, podcast host, and NYT Best-selling author Jana Kramer returns to the Ladygang to discuss her new book "The Next Chapter: Making Peace with Hard Memories, Finding Hope All Around Me, and Clearing Space of Good Things to Come." Check out our amazing sponsors!!! La ... Show More
47m 54s
Jan 2024
Reddit Haters!
Jax & Brittany share how they rang in the new year, Cruz's first day of preschool, why Brittany's family loves Pioneer Woman, J&B debate if Ross and Rachel REALLY on a break, and Brittany GOES OFF on the reddit critics!! PLUS: Kyle Richards, Mauricio Umansky, Lindsay Hubbard, Car ... Show More
47m 2s
Aug 2021
179: The Death of Tamla Horsford
On November 3, 2018, 40-year-old Tamla Horsford spent the evening and late night drinking with her girlfriends and celebrating one of the friend’s birthdays at a home in Cumming, Georgia. Despite the night of good food, friends, and drinking, the party ultimately ended in tragedy ... Show More
1h 5m
Dec 2016
Melissa Huckaby
8 year old Sandra Cantu went missing from the mobile home park she lived at on March 27, 2009. A massive search would begin immediately for the little girl. Suspicion would soon fall on the most unlikeliest of suspects, a 28 year old woman who lived in the same mobile home park a ... Show More
1h 8m