logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2022
58m 16s

127: A Date With Danger: The Disappearan...

I Think Not!
About this episode
Nancy Moyer disappears while her children are visiting their father. Police look into Moyer's background, finding a surprisingly complicated life. Then, a murder occurs nearby, prompting authorities to ask if the cases could be connected.

OBSESSED FEST YEAR 2 IS OFFICIALLY HAPPENING October 20th-22nd 2023 in Dallas, Texas. Tickets are on sale NOW at obsessedfest.com.

JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL BONUS EPISODES PER MONTH! Right now there are over 50 full ad-free bonus episode to download and binge right this second! Including our coverage of "I Almost Got Away With it", "Pink Collar Crimes", "Fear Thy Neighbor," "Who The Bleep Did I Marry," "See No Evil", "Evil Lives Here", and "Snapped".

Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

This week's sponsors:

SkyLight Frames - To get $15 off your purchase of a SkyLight Frame just got to SkylightFrame.com and enter code Disappeared at checkout.

Liquid I.V. - Grab your Liquid I.V. in bulk nationwide at Costco or get 20% off when you shop better hydration at LiquidIV.com and use code OWD at checkout.

Caraway - Visit Carawayhome.com to take advantage of their Cyber Season Event and score up to 20% off you next purchase of non-toxic cookware.

NextEvo Naturals - Get smarter CBD from NextEvo Naturals and get up to 25% off subscription orders of $40 or more at NextEvo.com/podcast using promo code OWD.

Rocket Money - Cancel your unnecessary subscriptions right now at RocketMoney.com/OWD.

Up next
Jul 9
269: The Centerfold and the Serial Killer (Playboy Murders)
Kerissa Fare is thrilled to be September 2000's Playmate of the Month; just as the magazine is about to hit newsstands, a mysterious man from her past becomes a suspect in multiple murders, and investigators want to talk to her. This Week’s Sponsors: Fay Nutrition - Listeners of ... Show More
1h 11m
Jul 3
268: True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 8
Detective Sergeant Anthony Rykowski joins Ellyn and Joey for a discussion about Karen Read, corruption in law enforcement, police ethics and more! We first met Anthony when we were recapping "Disappeared". He was featured on Episode 111 - Lost Angel: The Disappearance of Angel Ga ... Show More
40m 49s
Jul 2
267: Bonus from Patreon - Every Shot He Took, I Felt It (How I Caught My Killer)
As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon page and originally published on 2/27/25. Join now and get 9 episodes of How I Caught My Killer, plus a ton of other bonus content, at ... Show More
45m 28s
Recommended Episodes
May 2023
Episode 162 - Murder On The Farm - Uncovering The Dark Secrets Of An Oregon Pig Farmer
Join us as we take a look into the twisted tale of Susan Monica. You’ll hear a case so bizarre and heinous, that it might make you cancel that side order of bacon. How to support: For extra perks including extra content, early release, and ad-free episodes - Go to - Patreon How t ... Show More
1h 1m
Jun 2023
Episode 169 - Secrets In The Valley - The Murder Of Desiree Sunford
On April 13th, 2013, a devastating crime sent shockwaves through the picturesque valley of Yakima, nestled in the central part of Washington State. Desiree Sunford, a beloved art teacher, had been found murdered in her own home. As the investigation unfolded, secrets emerged, cas ... Show More
48m 7s
Sep 2019
Ep. 212 Something Bad Happened, Vol. 2
Guess who is back on Sorta Awesome this week? It's Meg's sister Emily, and she's bringing her undying fascination with all things true crime back to the show! This is Volume 2 of Something Bad Happened, a series on Sorta Awesome where Meg and Emily tell stories of true crime in a ... Show More
1h 13m
Jun 2021
167: Murder or Suicide? Christian Andreacchio- Part 2
Part 2 of 2- On February 26, 2014, Christian Andreacchio was found dead in the bathroom of his apartment. After a 45 minute investigation, the police on the scene ruled his death a suicide and closed the case. However, Christian’s family refused to believe that and their investig ... Show More
1h 10m
Aug 2023
The Disappearance of Peggy McGuire
This week we will be discussing the tumultuous relationship between Peggy McGuire and her husband Thomas McIntosh. Despite attempts to leave the relationship, including seeking a protective order, she tragically disappeared in November 2015 with her family still searching for ans ... Show More
50m 8s
Mar 2022
206: [Missing] Jennifer and Adrianna Wix
In middle Tennessee, about a half hour or so north of Nashville lies Robertson County. In March of 2004, Jennifer Wix and her two year old daughter Adrianna disappeared without a trace, and the story being told by her then boyfriend, Joseph “Joey” Benton, just doesn’t make sense ... Show More
1 h
Jun 2023
Episode 168 - Gumshoe. Hitman. Fraudster. Spy. - The Disappearance Of Rick Post
52-year-old Rick Post was bound to a chair, inside the shower stall of an abandoned house. His mouth was duct-taped shut. Even if he could scream, no one would hear him. His abductors paced back and forth flashing their instruments of torture. He’d been in this Tijuana dungeon fo ... Show More
51m 7s
Jun 2022
Wendy DiRodio: “Deadly Envy” | MURDERISH Ep. 112
At 61 years old, Wendy DiRodio’s life was just getting started. An accomplished author, therapist anddance instructor, she was ready to excel in the only part of life where success had escaped her: love.She’d begun dating a handsome younger man; there was even talk of marriage. S ... Show More
55m 4s
Jul 2021
171: Eastburn Family Murders
On Mother’s Day in 1985, Katie Eastburn and 2 of her daughters, 5-year-old Kara and 3-year-old Erin, were found dead in their Fayetteville, NC home. They had been brutally murdered 3 days before and the only survivor in the house was 21-month-old, Jana. Left in her crib for 3 day ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2023
Episode 165 - The Ohio Strangler - Part 2 of 2
Previously in Part 1 of the Ohio Strangler case, you heard the harrowing story of Jane. A woman who barely escaped being kidnapped, raped, and tortured at the hands of a local drifter named Shawn Grate in Ashland, Ohio. In the end, police found and raided the abandoned house she ... Show More
46m 1s