Have you ever heard the phrase ‘once a cheater, always a cheater’ and wondered whether that phrase might apply to other things…..like murder? Drew Peterson had been married four different times and had cheated on nearly every woman he had ever dated. His third wife had died under suspicious circumstances, and when his fourth wife, Stacy Peterson, mysteriousl ... Show More
Aug 21
EP. 256 - FLORIDA: THE FAMILY IN THE VAN: THE MURDER OF CASEI JONES
In September of 2019, a sheriff’s deputy in rural Georgia walked down the desolate road, in the dark, ready to help whoever was behind the wheel of the minivan that had crashed into a concrete culvert. He thought it would be a routine call. He’d check in with the driver, call an ... Show More
1h 11m
Aug 14
EP. 255 - VIRGINIA: A COLD CASE SOLVED AFTER 29 YEARS: THE MURDER OF ROBIN WARR LAWRENCE
For two days, two-year-old Nicole didn’t understand why her mother wasn’t getting up. She was hungry. Lonely. And her doting mom was just lying there, unmoving, her eyes staring at nothing. Nicole had no idea that her mom, Robin Warr Lawrence, was gone. When her body was finally ... Show More
1h 8m
Aug 7
EP. 254 - MICHIGAN: When Jealousy Kills: The Senseless Murder of Tara Lynn Grant
At first, the officer tried to tell himself he was looking at a deer carcass. Everything told him it wasn’t. The black bra. The location. The missing woman, Tara Lynn Grant. He knew he was looking at her dismembered remains, tossed into a tote bin, forgotten like trash. But wrapp ... Show More
1h 40m
Aug 2020
146: Drew Peterson: American Murder Mystery
When Stacy Peterson, a 23-year-old mother of 4, vanishes without a trace, authorities look to her husband Drew, a man 30 YEARS HER SENIOR! Peterson, a cop, claims--we swear to Goddess, you guys--that Stacy grabbed $25,000, the deed to the house, AND HER BIKINI-- and took off with ... Show More
50m 18s
Dec 2021
Murder Made Me Famous: Drew Peterson
A Bolingbrook, Illinois police sergeant bathes in the media limelight after he becomes a suspect in the drowning murder of his third wife, Kathleen Savio and the disappearance of his fourth wife, Stacy Cales Peterson, in 2007 Like what you hear and want more true crime and myster ... Show More
44m 14s
Aug 2023
31. The Bad Guy in a Uniform
On this episode, Payton delves into the chilling account of how a police officer's obsession spiraled into a web of deception, ultimately leading to a tragic and deadly outcome.
https://linktr.ee/bingedpod
Episode Sources:
The Investigators, episode: “Badge of Dishonor,” aired ... Show More
36m 51s
Jun 2024
220. The Killer In The Attic
In this episode, Payton and Garrett dive into the case of Fred Oesterreich, a husband who was tragically shot by a home invader. As witnesses come forward, police realize this case is a lot stranger than it seems.
Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/themwmh
Instagram: https://www.in ... Show More
42m 41s
Oct 2025
MURDEROUS MINDS: The Sleepwalker Murder Pt. 1
Scott Falater went to bed next to his wife. Hours later, she was found stabbed and drowned...and all signs pointed to him. In Part 1, Killer Minds investigates the life and mind of a man who claimed he killed while sleepwalking, and the haunting question that followed: Was he con ... Show More
40m 51s