logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2022
1h 3m

Victim or Villain: The Story of Dale Ker...

MEGAN
About this episode

September 12, 1987 seemed to start off normally for 50-year old Dale Kerstetter. He was a maintenance man and security guard working the overnight shift at Corning Glass Works. He had worked at the plant for 27 years. 

When another employee showed up to relieve Dale at 7 AM the next morning, he was puzzled to find the seat which Dale normally occupied empty. When Dale's truck was found in the parking lot with the keys inside, and his lunch pail still filled with food was found in the cafeteria, police were called and came out to investigate. 

A review of the plant's security tapes would reveal a disturbing occurrence. Shortly after Dale's shift, a masked intruder appeared walking through the plant. Dale is seen speaking to this personal briefly, then they are seen walking down the corridor together. Dale glances directly into the camera, and the vanishes, never to be seen again. 

That night, a quarter of a million dollars of platinum was stolen from the plant. Family, colleagues, friend's and Dale's employers have disputed the same question for years--Was Dale an innocent victim who was coerced by an unwanted intruder, or was he an accomplice to a brazen heist? 

Returning guest Elaine Erickson joins Megan to discuss the events of September 12, 1987 and the fate of Dale Kerstetter.

For sources and episode information: http://143mysteries.com

For photos: https://www.instagram.com/143mysteries/

Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/143PODCAST

One Minute and Forty-Three Seconds is dedicated to my number one fan. Thank you, Dad. I love you, and I miss you.

Up next
Jul 25
Gone in Gary: The Disappearance of Diamond Bynum and King Walker
On a warm July day in 2015, Diamond Bynum and her young nephew King Walker vanished without a trace from their Gary, Indiana home. Ten years later, questions remain—and answers are still out of reach. In this episode, we retrace their last known steps, explore the heartbreaking s ... Show More
10m 33s
Jul 18
Unfound Justice: The Disappearance of Mahfuza Rahman
30-year old Mahfuza Rahman was a married mother of a 9-year old girl when she went missing without a trace from New York City in December of 2015. She worked a shift at her job as a nurse, then went to a class at Hunter College where she was working on obtaining a nursing degree. ... Show More
48m 10s
Aug 2024
15 Years Gone: The Disappearance of Toni Sharpless
15 years ago to the day of this episode's release, 29-year old Toni Lee Sharpless drove away from a party in the early morning hours of Sunday, August 23 and hasn't been seen since. Toni was an intelligent, driven woman who also struggled with bipolar disorder. On the n ... Show More
1h 12m
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2022
The Bain Family Murders Part 1
In mid-1994, the bodies of married couple Robin and Margaret Bain, and three of their four children, were discovered in their home in the city of Dunedin on the South Island of New Zealand. They had all been shot to death. The only person to survive was the Bain's family oldest s ... Show More
1 h
Sep 2023
Missing & Murdered Introduces: Someone Knows Something | Season 8
ost David Ridgen joins victims' family members as they investigate cold cases, tracking down leads, speaking to suspects and searching for answers. In the highly-anticipated 8th season of Someone Knows Something, award-winning investigator David Ridgen delves into a cold case tha ... Show More
48m 13s
Feb 2018
MURDERED: Amy Weidner
A teenage mother stays home from school one day with her daughter because she isn't feeling well. Just a few hours after her family leaves the house she is brutally attacked. Surely it had to be someone she knew. Did they know she would be home that day? It is a case that goes co ... Show More
31m 26s
Oct 2018
MURDERED: The Powell Family
During a blizzard on December 6, 2009 Josh Powell Claims to have taken his two young sons, ages 2 and 4, camping. When he returned home he finds friends and family frantically searching for them. They're all relieved when he and the boys arrive safely. But where is Susan? Josh be ... Show More
46m 35s
Aug 2021
Who Killed Leanne Holland?
On the eastern edge of the city of Ipswich in Queensland, lies a small suburb named Goodna.  About 20 kilometres from the Brisbane central business district, Goodna is peppered with Jacaranda, Hoop Pine, and Mango trees, and boasts numerous parks which are frequented by the publi ... Show More
34m 53s
Sep 2022
MISSING: Hang Lee
When 17-year-old Hang Lee leaves for a job interview and never comes home, police are quick to dismiss her as a troubled runaway. But when they finally take a deeper look into her case, they discover that the last man she was seen with has a violent criminal history, and no expla ... Show More
30m 13s