logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2022
21m 29s

The Holiness Movement | Christian Fundam...

Chris Staron
About this episode

Can a Christian be holy? Can we go a week, a day, or an hour without sinning?

These are questions that modern Christians struggle with. They have their origin in John Wesley, a hymn writer, preacher, and one of the founders of Methodism. In this episode of Truce, we track how this seemingly simple concept got tied up in movements from fundamentalism to Pentecostalism.

This episode is going to seem a bit "out there". But this information is important to fundamentalism. Keswick Holiness in particular created an "us and them" scenario where there are Christians who "get it" and those who don't. The divide is between "carnal" Christians and those who are really saved. This impulse makes it easier for fundamentalists to see themselves as set apart from other Christians.

We're joined by Chris Evans, author of "Do Everything" which is a biography of suffragette Frances Willard.


Helpful Sources and Links:

  • D.L. Moody: A Life by Kevin Belmonte
  • The Evangelicals by Frances Fitzgerald
  • John Wesley's tract on perfection
  • Fundamentalism and American Culture by George Marsden
  • Church History in Plain Language by Bruce Shelley


Discussion Questions:

  • How long can a Christian go without sinning?
  • Do you see yourself as "better" or "different" from other Christians? Why? How does that impact the way you treat them?
  • How did the holiness movement shape Pentecostalism?
  • Do you see history and ideas as straight lines, or as a tangle?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Aug 12
Republicans and Evangelicals I Segregation Academies (part 2)
Give to help Chris make the Truce Podcast In 2 Samuel 24 David is told that he must buy a certain piece of land in an act of repentance for his sins. The man who owns the land says that he'd like to give David the land and the animals to sacrifice. But David turns him down, insis ... Show More
46m 35s
Jul 29
Republicans and Evangelicals I Segregation Academies (part 1)
Give to help Chris continue Truce. Update: I would like to apologize for an error I made in the original version of this story. I stated that tuition payments to private schools are tax-exempt on the federal level. They are not. They sometimes are on the state level. The episode ... Show More
32m 9s
Jul 18
Scopes Monkey Trial - 100 Year Anniversay
Give to help Chris continue making Truce I made these episodes a few years ago, but since it is the 100th anniversary of the Scopes "Monkey" trial, I thought we should revisit them! Tennessee was the first state in the United States to crack down hard on the teaching of evolution ... Show More
1h 13m
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2024
Where Have All the Fundamentalists Gone?
With two smart British historians—one from Oxford (Andrew) and one from Aberystwyth (David)--and one curious American pastor (Kevin), you might say that this episode puts the "fun" back in fundamentalism. How did fundamentalism become a pejorative putdown? Are evangelicals and fu ... Show More
1h 9m
Jul 2024
12 Crucial Truths of Christianity
What are the essential truths of the Christian faith? How do we know they are true, and how do we live them out in relationships? In this episode, Scott interviews Sean about his recent book 12 Crucial Truths of the Christian Faith. They discuss the core issues of Christianity, h ... Show More
45m 39s
Sep 2017
What’s the Christian Ideal? Part 1: Defining Holiness
This is the first episode in a two part discussion on the Christian “Ideal.” What is the Christian Ideal? That’s exactly what we ask. Why does it seem that humanity has an inner drive to find something transcendent? What is it that we’re all searching for and hoping to attain? In ... Show More
38m 36s
Jan 2024
The Deconstruction of Christianity | with Alisa Childers and Tim Barnett
What is this thing called "deconstruction" that has disrupted, dismantled, and destroyed the faith of so many people? Is it really a quest for truth, or is this radical spiritual makeover motivated by something else? As the deconstruction movement continues to grow in popularity, ... Show More
48m 18s
Feb 2024
Does History Discredit Christianity? with John Dickson
Rebecca McLaughlin is joined by John Dickson to discuss if history discredits Christianity.Questions Covered in This Episode:Why are the core Christians's beliefs not surprising to a first century Jewish rabbi, known as Jesus?When were the Gospels written and how can we be sure?W ... Show More
36m 6s
Nov 2023
Can a Historian Believe in the Resurrection? with Molly Worthen
Rebecca McLaughlin is joined by Molly Worthen to discuss how Jesus can transform the life of an academic.Questions Covered in This Episode:What is your story of how you became a Christian?What were the main barriers from keeping you from becoming a Christian?Can you share about y ... Show More
42m 35s