logo
episode-header-image
May 2018
1h 17m

Episode 38: Problematic Gay Stuff

Amanda Jean and Austin Chant
About this episode

Content warnings: This episode references potentially triggering topics, including abusive relationships, gaslighting, murder, cannibalism, sexual assault, violence, incest, Real Person Fan Fiction, and age differences--a lot of triggers that constitute "dark" or "problematic" fiction. While we don't dwell on many of these subjects, they are referenced, and people may want to protect themselves accordingly. Also, there are mild spoilers for Hannibal and other pieces of media referenced.

Don't miss the very important announcement about the future of THR and our other podcast ventures! We have exciting news to share and want feedback from our listeners to give you the best experience possible.

This episode, we head over to the Dark Side of queer publishing and fan fiction (and give you several more TED Talks). Austin and Amanda think that the widespread use of content and trigger warnings in fandom and queer fiction give readers the ability to curate their own experience and examine their reactions to fiction in ways that mainstream media doesn't typically allow for. Amanda talks about her own journey through dark media and how she's drawn and redrawn her own lines, and Austin does the same. Ultimately, both hosts believe there is no consensus as to what constitutes "good" fiction versus "problematic" fiction, that policing other people's engagement with media is impossible and reductive, and that humans are complicated and messy by nature.

Click here to support THR on Patreon!

Episode notes:

Killing Eve (TV show)

KJ Charles - The Henchmen of Zenda

Anthony Hope - The Prisoner of Zenda

Aliette de Bodard - The Citadel of Weeping Pearls (Xuya Universe)

Margaret Killjoy - The Lamb Will Slaughter the Lion

Kelly Robson - A Human Stain

The Clarkesworld Podcast

Rich Larson - Carouseling

Rich Larson - God Decay

The Verge: Listen to one of the best short science fiction podcasts right now

Robyn Bennis - The Guns Above: A Signal Airship Novel

Heather Rose Jones - Daughter of Mystery

The Exorcist (TV show)

My Favorite Murder (Podcast)

Poppy Z. Brite - Exquisite Corpse

CS Pacat - The Captive Prince Series

Kurt/Blaine (Glee TV show)

Madeline Miller - The Song of Achilles

Hannibal/Will [Hannigram] (Hannibal TV show)

Brokeback Mountain (Film)

Boys Don't Cry (Film)

Kylo Ren/Hux [Kylux] (Star Wars films)

Clint/Coulson (MCU films)

Goodreads: Popular M/M dark books (couldn't find an F/F equivalent--let me know if you do!)

Up next
Jul 2018
Episode 40: Thanks for Coming to Our TED Talk
Content warning: This episode contains spoilers for the movie Annihilation (as well as some spoilers for the book it's based on). The ending is in no way spoiled, but some plot elements are laid out. There are also spoilers for The Picture of Dorian Gray. Also, suicide is mention ... Show More
1h 12m
Jun 2018
Episode 39: What's in a Pen Name?
Content warning: This episode mentions the Killing Stalking manhwa, discusses problematic elements of dramas (such as non-consensual grabbing, stalking, kidnapping, and misogynistic behavior), mentions drinking alcohol and smoking marijuana, fictional suicide in Orphan Black, und ... Show More
1h 16m
May 2018
Episode 37: Meet Nasty
Content warning: This contains a trigger warning for a dead dog in Killing Eve and also mentions mild spoilers for the endings of Time Was and Person of Interest. After repeated technical failure, Brooklyn Wallace finally manages to chat with Austin and Amanda about her upcoming ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2022
New Non-Fiction Writers to Look Out For in 2022 with Nihal Arthanayake
Last time we brought you some of the most exciting debut novelists to look out for in 2022, so this week we're introducing you to some of the best new non-fiction writers to add to your reading list this year. It's a veritable treasure chest of books, from a comic memoir to ornit ... Show More
34m 47s
Jan 2023
S3 Ep2: Spicy Books and Representation
Anyone else on 🌶spicy🌶 book tok or is it just Lauren? A good romance book written by a woman just hits different, but it can be really hard to find the right one (almost as hard as reading one in public🤣)!! So in this episode, Lauren’s telling us what we should look, which boo ... Show More
43m 14s
Aug 2016
Ep 34: Books that marry fiction and reality
Our guest today is Rose Booth, a technology merchandising director and cinephile who sometimes "feels like she's dating books." Rose loves female protagonists who flout convention and books where reality meets fiction, but she's also eager to fall in love with titles from one pop ... Show More
46m 53s
Dec 2022
Book 7, Ep. 7 | Sentimentality
In the wise words of Lizzo, it's about damn time! Our latest episode is all about Sentimentality, an 18th century philosophical intervention that emerged in opposition to rationality. Hannah (whose recent book, A Sentimental Education, is all about this topic) guides the episode. ... Show More
1h 7m
Feb 2023
Inside the rise of LGBTQ+ fiction
Erica Gillingham is joined by a panel of leading international LGBTQ+ writers to discuss the growing popularity of queer fiction and the challenges posed by book bans. At a time when sales are increasing and LGBTQ+ authors are winning awards, in countries including the United Sta ... Show More
27m 17s
Nov 2023
9. FLIRTING! Any Way The Wind Blows chapter 25
Today we are discussing chapter 25 of Any Way The Wind Blows by Rainbow Rowell.Don’t forget to read “Snow for Christmas” before our next episode!Join our Patreon to get access to all sorts of great things, including early, extended episodes of this podcast!The Patreon version of ... Show More
31m 52s
Dec 2019
Ep 213: Art, fear, and discovering great books
Anne chats with reader and children’s book writer Kate DiCamillo about the books that inspired her to dream up stories, the hopeful work of writing for children, and what she learns from readers about her own books. She has so much to share about the value of friendship with othe ... Show More
55m 4s
Aug 2023
No more male artists!!! 🤬 Who can identify as femme? 🤔 Also contemporary cinema flopping... 🙊
It's time to revisit Olivia Rodrigo, and the potential beef regarding her and other female artists (that we kind of know nothing about.) What we do know is that we fuck with Vampire! And we do not fuck with Morgan Wallen, because truly, who the fuck is he??? Listener submitted ho ... Show More
1h 53m
May 2024
'the idea of you' author robinne lee reacts to the movie adaptation and the new ending
Get this week's full So Into That newsletter here! https://whattocook.substack.com/p/the-idea-of-you-author-robinne-leeThe Idea of You was a book that changed the way I read. I absolutely loved it. I recommend it all the time. And it was my gateway drug into the romance genre… al ... Show More
55m 44s
Dec 2023
The Night Circus x Reading Ecosystems
One of Marcelle's favorite books is The Night Circus, so she decided to be brave and do an entire episode about the best-selling fantasy novel by Erin Morgenstern. Why brave? Well because sometimes it's hard to think critically about something you love! We all know that. ;) This ... Show More
1h 8m