Although Erin's already revealed more to Dr. Phil than she's admitted to anyone else before, a lot of questions remain unanswered. Plus, hear from Erin's father, Terry, who suffered multiple gunshot wounds but managed to escape the attack and was the lone survivor. Will Terry change his mind about his daughter's role in the killings? Plus, hear from Erin's f ... Show More
Jan 2020
S7E2: Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice
In 2012, mother of two, Michelle Warner, vanished without a trace after arguing with her live-in ex-boyfriend, Mark Castellano. Authorities say that Castellano exhibited bizarre behavior just after Michelle's disappearance, claiming that Warner had abandoned her children. He then ... Show More
57m 55s
Jan 2020
S7E3: Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice
Michelle Warner, a mother of two, disappeared without a trace in 2012 after arguing with her live-in ex-boyfriend, Mark Castellano. When Dr. Phil interviewed Castellano, he denied knowing what happened to his ex. On this week's "Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice," Myst ... Show More
37m 58s
Jan 2020
S7E4: Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice EP4
Episode 4 of the podcast "Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice," Mystery And Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil, Mark Castellano's trial begins after he confesses to killing his ex, Michelle Warner. Michelle's family honors her memory. See omnystudio.com/policies/listener for p ... Show More
39m 35s
May 2023
269: [FREE Weekly Episode] Caffey Family Murders (Erin Caffey)
On Saturday, March 1st, 2008, the Caffey family home in Emory, Texas was engulfed in flames. Terry Caffey, the father, had been shot five times and had amazingly escaped the burning home and crawled 500 yards to his neighbors’ house, where 911 was called. Firefighters found the b ... Show More
1h 14m
Sep 2023
My Family Slaughtered For My Daughter's Teenage Love: Can A Father Forgive Pt 2
Dr. Phil continues his exclusive interview with Erin Caffey, sentenced to two life terms in prison plus 25 years for murders of her mother and brothers in 2008. What does she say was her role in the brutal slayings? Plus, Erin’s father forgives, or not? Part 2
For more informatio ... Show More
44m 2s
Sep 2023
The Cold Case Murder Of A Mother And Daughter
On September 2nd, 1994, a horrific crime sent shockwaves through the hardworking community of Williamsport, PA. 23-year-old Gail Matthews was found holding her 5-year-old daughter, Tamara Berkheiser, the pair bloodied, strangled, and stabbed. Gail was well-liked by everyone in he ... Show More
59m 2s