logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2022
54m 53s

S1 Ep8: Dorothea Puente, The Killer OAP

Audioboom Studios
About this episode
Helen Anderson and Danni Howard travel back to 90’s America to visit a boarding house for people down on their luck, run by sweet little old lady Dorothea Puente… but is Dorothea all that she seems? After discovering a body in her front garden, detective John Cabrera has a hunch that this kindly caretaker might not be all that she seemed to be… Expect grisly discoveries, missing teeth, and an OAP on the run. Devils in The Dark contains graphic details of sexual assault and violence and is not intended for all audiences. Listener discretion is strongly advised.  

00:00 - Introduction
11:25 - Where Dorothea’s story begins
16:26 - The murder of Ruth Monroe
20:29 - Dorothea’s first stint in prison
22:54 - The disappearance of Alvaro ‘Bert’ Montoya
24:18 - Dorothea gets a visit from the police
25:55 - Danni has thoughts about Lin Manuel Miranda
27:15 - John Cabrera digs in Dorothea’s garden
31:49 - Dorothea goes on the run
38:38 - Dorothea gets found
39:58 - Identifying the bodies
41:25 - How did Dorothea do it?
43:03 - The murder of Everson Gillmouth
44:17 - The trial of Dorothea Puente
49:00 - Cooking with a Serial Killer
53:39 - Outro

Follow Helen Anderson at @helenanderz and Danni Howard at @thatdannihoward. Special thanks to Woodcut Media. See audioboom.com/about/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. Produced by Alexandra Jueno at Audioboom Studios. 

If you have been affected by any of the themes in this week’s episode please consider contacting the following resources:

The Samaritans helpline: 116 123
Confidential Emotional Support Line: 01708 765200

Up next
Aug 2023
S3 Ep14: Issei Sagawa, The Kobe Cannibal
For the series finale... Helen and Danni explore the story of Issei Sagawa, he had a craving for human flesh and walked the streets of Paris in the late 1970's looking for victim's to satisfy his cannibalism urges. Devils in The Dark contains details of graphic violence, murder a ... Show More
48m 43s
Aug 2023
S3 Ep13: Elizabeth Báthory, The Blood Countess
A real vampire from Transylvania? She was a noblewomen and an alleged blood-bathing serial killer, born in the 16th century. In this episode Helen and Danni dive into the notorious tale of Elizabeth Báthory, and find out all about her vampiric tendencies... Devils in The Dark con ... Show More
57m 27s
Jul 2023
S3 Ep12: The Boogeyman Of Westfield, John List
This one is particularly HARROWING. In this episode Helen and Danni dive into the John List murders... find out how this man killed his entire family, one by one, and then escaped on the run for eighteen years, until his new identity was discovered. Devils in The Dark contains de ... Show More
1h 4m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2022
#404: The Shenandoah Murders - Part 1
In May 1996, Lollie Winans and Julie Williams were murdered at their campsite in the popular Shenandoah National Park in the middle of rural Virginia, not far from a busy tourist resort called Skyland. Many people, including park and resort staff, had seen the happy, friendly cou ... Show More
48m 58s
Apr 2024
Dorothea Puente: The Serial Killer Granny
To the outside world, Dorothea Puente presented herself as a kind grandmotherly figure who cared for the disabled and vulnerable residents of her boarding house in downtown Sacramento. But behind closed doors, nothing was as it seemed… Not only was she stealing the money of her t ... Show More
46m 59s
Jan 2025
Episode 639: The Unsolved Murder of Melissa Witt
On December 1, 1994, nineteen-year-old Melissa Witt planned to meet her mother at a Fort Smith, Arkansas bowling alley, but by all appearances, she only made it as far as the parking lot. Two days later, investigators discovered Melissa’s car abandoned in the Bowling World parkin ... Show More
52m 11s
Jul 2024
Episode 582: The Murder of Julia Martha Thomas
In early March 1879, fifty-five-year-old widow Julia Martha Thomas disappeared from her home in southwest London. Julia often travelled by herself on moment’s notice, so neighbors thought nothing of her absence; however, when several female body parts were discovered in the Thame ... Show More
1h 5m
Dec 2020
Margaret, Murder - And The Missing Motive (Part 2)
Continuing the multi-parter we began last time on The True Crime Enthusiast Podcast, where this time around, we hear of the continuing investigation into the horrific murder of grandmother Margaret Wilson in East Yorkshire in 1995, senselessly slaughtered on a country lane near h ... Show More
1h 9m
Mar 2025
Episode 656: The Attempted Murder of Alison Botha
On December 18, 1994, twenty-seven-year-old Alison Botha was abducted from the parking lot of her apartment in Port Elizabeth by two men she didn’t know and had never seen. After forcing her into her car, her abductors drove her to a remote field, where she was sexually assaulted ... Show More
1h 14m
Jan 2025
355: Christa Pike- Youngest Woman on Death Row in TN
On Jan 13th, 1995 in Knoxville, TN a battered body, nude from the waist up, was found in a grizzly scene. The victim had been tortured, murdered and her skull crushed. But that's not all- she had pentagrams carved into her forehead and chest. The investigation led police to a you ... Show More
41m 19s
Mar 2025
MURDERED: Helen Betty Osborne
The discovery of 19-year-old Helen Betty Osborne’s body should have outraged the residents of The Pas, Manitoba. Yet, the truth of what happened to her, and who killed her, would remain an open secret for years. But, like all secrets, what happened that night eventually came to l ... Show More
47m 26s
Nov 2022
S2 E8: Madam Nerva Sees Death
Rachel Dobkin has come to see her psychic advisor, Madam Nerva. After years of bitter disagreements and financial wranglings with her estranged and violent husband, Rachel wants to know what the spirits think she should do next. Through Madam Nerva the spirts tell Rachel not to g ... Show More
50m 13s
Mar 2025
Barbara & Antony Baekeland: How a Mother Made a Murderer
Retired FBI agent and criminal profiler Candice DeLong dives into the case of mother-son duo Barbara and Antony Baekeland. Behind the facade of a beautiful socialite and doting mother, Barbara Baekeland was not as charming as she seemed. She harbored a dark and twisted obsession ... Show More
51m 28s