Wanting fame and fortune as a dancer, Melissa James took Craig up on his offer to introduce her to his A-list friends and moved in with him and Kelly. But the growing conflict between the two women became strained — and turned deadly.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Aug 28
Loved Him to Death: The Brittany Holbrook Story
A roommate wakes to screaming and finds his best friend bleeding on the floor of their Florida apartment. Tyler Nulisch, 30, dies at the hospital hours later from a single gunshot wound. His girlfriend, Brittany Nicole Holbrook, tells detectives she was defending herself, but the ... Show More
47m 43s
Aug 21
'How to Murder Your Husband': Romance Novelist Turned Killer
A culinary school was thrown into chaos when a chef was found shot to death in the kitchen where he taught. Daniel Brophy's students discovered his body just before class. His wife, Nancy Brophy, played the grieving widow, but years earlier she wrote a novel titled “How to Murder ... Show More
37m 57s
Nov 2025
MURDEROUS MINDS: The Bodybuilder Love Triangle Pt. 1
At the height of their fame, bodybuilding power couple Craig Titus and Kelly Ryan were unstoppable — sculpted bodies, magazine covers, and a fitness empire built on success and control. But beneath the surface of their glamorous life was a world of drugs, jealousy, and rage.When ... Show More
50m 18s
Nov 2025
MURDEROUS MINDS: The Bodybuilder Love Triangle Pt. 2
After Melissa James’s body is found, Craig Titus and Kelly Ryan insist they’re innocent — until the lies start to crumble. As detectives chase the couple across state lines, a twisted story of vanity, manipulation, and violence emerges. From bodybuilding fame to life behind bars, ... Show More
44m 40s